Insights into the Effect of Confinement on Swirling Flow by PIV

Tao Liu, Chi Zhang, Xin Xue, Shun Zheng, Muwei YaoEnergies 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) to systematically investigate how rectangular confinement affects swirling flow in a model combustor. They discovered a critical confinement ratio of approximately 8.92, below which wall attachment dominates, and above which swirling intensity becomes the primary driver, leading to two distinct flow patterns crucial for combustor design.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Swirling flows are vital in gas turbine engines and industrial furnaces for efficient fuel atomization, flame stabilization, and air-fuel mixing. While the importance of swirl is well-established, the specific impact of confinement—how the surrounding geometry influences this flow—remains poorly understood, especially in realistic rectangular geometries that mimic annular combustors. Previous studies often used simplified unconfined cases or a very narrow range of confinement ratios, and rarely explored rectangular confinements that better represent engine designs. This lack of systematic understanding hinders the ability to optimize combustor geometry for improved performance and stability.

Methods

The researchers employed a 2D Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) system to capture detailed flow field measurements. This technique involves seeding the airflow with tiny olive oil droplets, illuminating a plane of the flow with a laser, and using a camera to track the movement of these particles between two laser pulses. By analyzing these particle movements, they could reconstruct the velocity vectors across the illuminated plane. The experiment involved a counter-rotating swirler housed within a series of rectangular plexiglass confinements with varying confinement ratios (ranging from 5.09 to 15.61). They also conducted tests in an unconfined setup to serve as a baseline. Measurements were taken in both axial and transverse planes to provide a comprehensive view of the flow.

Datasets

The study did not use pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generated a novel dataset of PIV measurements for swirling flow under various controlled confinement ratios. This experimental data serves as the primary "dataset" for their analysis and forms the basis for their findings.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Critical Confinement Ratio: The most significant finding is the identification of a critical confinement ratio of approximately 8.92. Below this ratio, the flow exhibits one behavior, and above it, the behavior shifts dramatically.
  • Two Distinct Flow Patterns: The study clearly delineates two primary flow patterns:
  • Pattern 1 (Low Confinement Ratio < 8.92): Characterized by strong wall attachment, where the swirling flow adheres to the inner walls of the confinement. This leads to a larger central recirculation zone (CRZ) and the presence of corner recirculation zones (CORZs).
  • Pattern 2 (High Confinement Ratio > 8.92): Dominated by swirling intensity. The flow becomes more uniform, the CRZ shrinks, and the flow field starts to resemble the unconfined case.
  • Governing Factors: The research strongly suggests that the confinement ratio, rather than individual geometric parameters like width or height alone, is the primary determinant of the swirling flow field's behavior.
  • Wall Attachment vs. Swirling Intensity: The transition between the two patterns is attributed to the interplay between wall attachment effects (dominant at lower confinement ratios) and swirling intensity (dominant at higher ratios).
  • Implications for Combustion: The findings have direct implications for combustor design, suggesting that an "optimal" confinement ratio is crucial for achieving desired flow characteristics, impacting flame stability and fuel atomization.

Key Results

  • Flow Pattern Transition: A clear transition in flow topology was observed around a confinement ratio of 8.92.
  • CRZ Behavior: In low confinement cases (e.g., 5.09 to 7.64), the CRZ area increased compared to the unconfined case, while the negative peak axial velocity remained relatively constant. In high confinement cases (e.g., 11.46 to 15.61), the CRZ area decreased, and axial velocity profiles became more uniform, resembling the unconfined flow.
  • Reynolds Shear Stress: Reynolds shear stresses were found to be more concentrated near the swirler exit in higher confinement cases (5-7), potentially enhancing fuel droplet atomization. In lower confinement cases (1-4), these stresses were more concentrated near the walls.
  • Quantitative Data: The paper presents detailed velocity contours (axial and radial) and Reynolds shear stress distributions for various confinement ratios, allowing for precise comparison of flow field modifications.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Isothermal Flow: The study focused on isothermal flow conditions. Future work could investigate the effects of confinement on reacting flows, which are more complex due to heat release and combustion-driven buoyancy.
  • Simplified Geometry: While the rectangular confinement is a good simplification of annular combustors, it doesn't capture the full complexity of curvature in real annular geometries.
  • 2D PIV: The PIV measurements were 2D. Future research could employ 3D PIV or Tomo-PIV to capture the full three-dimensional flow structures, such as precessing vortex cores.
  • Optimal Design: The authors suggest that an optimal design value for confinement ratio is slightly greater than the threshold of 8.92, but further research is needed to precisely define this optimum for various engine designs and operating conditions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Confinement with a rectangular cross-section is commonly used to simulate the role of a swirl combustor, yet its effect on swirling flows remains poorly understood. This study investigates the influence of confinement on the isothermal flow field of a counter-rotating swirler. A particle image velocimetry (PIV) system was employed to measure the swirling flow field under varying confinement ratios at an air pressure drop equivalent to 3% of atmospheric pressure. The results reveal two distinct flow patterns, delineated by a critical confinement ratio of approximately 8.92. Detailed analyses of the velocity components, contour distributions, and Reynolds shear stresses were conducted. The two flow patterns are attributed to the wall attachment effect and swirling intensity, respectively. Furthermore, the results confirm that the swirling flow field is primarily governed by the confinement ratio.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025insights,
  author = {Tao Liu and Chi Zhang and Xin Xue and Shun Zheng and Muwei Yao},
  title = {{Insights into the Effect of Confinement on Swirling Flow by PIV}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/en18195155},
}
Figure