Abstract
SARS-CoV-2, the causative agent of COVID-19, has an RNA genome that is overall closely related to the bat coronavirus sequence RaTG13. However, the ACE2-binding domain of this virus is more similar to a coronavirus isolated from a Guangdong pangolin. In addition to this unique feature, the genome of SARS-CoV-2 (and its closely related coronaviruses) has a low CpG content. This has been postulated to be the signature of an evolutionary pressure exerted by the host antiviral protein ZAP. Here, we analyzed the sequences of a wide range of viruses using both alignment-based and alignment-free approaches to investigate the origin of the SARS-CoV-2 genome. Our analyses revealed a high level of similarity between the 5’UTR of SARS-CoV-2 and that of the Guangdong pangolin coronavirus. This suggests bat and pangolin coronaviruses might have recombined at least twice (in the 5’UTR and ACE2 binding regions) to seed the formation of SARS-CoV-2. An alternative hypothesis is that the lineage preceding SARS-CoV-2 is a yet-to-be-sampled bat coronavirus whose ACE2 binding domain and 5’UTR are distinct from other known bat coronaviruses. Additionally, we performed a detailed analysis of viral genome compositions as well as expression and RNA binding data of ZAP to show that the low CpG abundance in SARS-CoV-2 is not related to an evolutionary pressure from ZAP.
Introduction
Since the emergence of SARS-CoV-2, tracing its evolutionary trajectory has been a primary focus of the scientific community. While the virus shares significant homology with the bat coronavirus RaTG13, its ACE2-binding domain—a critical component for human infection—exhibits a striking similarity to coronaviruses found in Guangdong pangolins. This mosaic genomic structure has fueled the hypothesis that SARS-CoV-2 arose through recombination events between different animal coronaviruses.
Beyond its origin, the SARS-CoV-2 genome displays a notable depletion of CpG dinucleotides (where a Cytosine is followed by a Guanine). Historically, this depletion has been attributed to the selective pressure of the host protein Zinc Finger Antiviral Protein (ZAP), which targets CpG-rich viral RNA for degradation. This study re-examines both the recombination history of the virus and the validity of the ZAP-driven evolution theory.
Genomic Origins: The 5’UTR Connection
By employing a combination of traditional alignment-based genomics and alignment-free statistical methods, researchers identified a new piece of the evolutionary puzzle. Using "D-value" analysis—a method that calculates the ratio of a motif's observed frequency to its expected frequency—the study compared SARS-CoV-2 against a vast library of over 14,000 viral sequences.
A moving window analysis (using 20bp increments) revealed that the 5’UTR (the non-coding leader sequence at the start of the genome) of SARS-CoV-2 is nearly identical to the Guangdong pangolin coronavirus. In this specific region, SARS-CoV-2 differs from the pangolin strain at only five positions, whereas it differs significantly from the bat RaTG13 strain.
This finding suggests two primary possibilities:
- Multiple Recombination Events: The ancestor of SARS-CoV-2 may have undergone at least two distinct recombination events with pangolin-related viruses—one involving the Spike protein's ACE2-binding domain and another involving the 5’UTR.
- Unsampled Lineage: SARS-CoV-2 may have descended from a yet-to-be-discovered bat coronavirus lineage that already possessed these pangolin-like features in its 5’UTR and Spike regions.
Debunking the ZAP-Driven Evolution Hypothesis
The theory that SARS-CoV-2 evolved low CpG content to evade the host protein ZAP was tested by correlating ZAP mRNA expression levels from the FANTOM5 project with viral CpG abundance across various tissues.
The results strongly contradict the ZAP-pressure hypothesis:
- Lack of Correlation: There was virtually no statistical relationship between the level of ZAP expression in a host tissue and the CpG depletion of the viruses that infect those tissues ($R^2 = 0.04, p = 0.47$).
- Binding Motif Paradox: Analysis of CLIP-seq data showed that the specific RNA motif ZAP prefers to bind to—$C(n7)G(n)CG$—is actually more abundant in SARS-CoV-2-like viruses than in the older SARS-CoV strains. If the virus were evolving to hide from ZAP, this motif should have decreased.
- Marginal Differences: SARS-CoV-2 only possesses approximately 4.6 fewer CpGs per kilobase than the original SARS-CoV. This marginal difference is unlikely to be the primary driver of the virus's distinct transmissibility or its fundamental evolutionary shift.
A Global Genomic Shift: The Oxidative Stress Hypothesis
If ZAP is not the driver of CpG reduction, what is? The researchers observed that the reduction in CpG is not an isolated phenomenon. In fact, 15 out of 16 possible dinucleotides show significant differences between the SARS-CoV-2 group and older SARS-CoV strains. This suggests a "global" genomic shift rather than targeted selection against a single motif.
The authors propose that oxidative stress during viral replication may be the true culprit. Oxidative stress is known to induce G > T mutations. Such a mechanism would simultaneously explain the observed reductions in CpG, TpG, and GpA motifs across the genome. This model suggests that the genomic composition of SARS-CoV-2 is a byproduct of the biochemical environment of its replication rather than a specific adaptation to the host's innate immune system.
Conclusion
This study refines our understanding of the SARS-CoV-2 genome by highlighting the critical role of the 5’UTR in its evolutionary history and providing evidence against the ZAP-driven selection theory. While the oxidative stress hypothesis offers a compelling explanation for the virus's unique dinucleotide composition, further experimental work is required to confirm G > T mutation rates during active viral replication. Identifying the "missing link" in bat populations remains essential to fully resolving the recombination history of this pathogen.
Summary updated