Insight into the Mode of Action of Celangulin V on the Transmembrane Potential of Midgut Cells in Lepidopteran Larvae

Yingying Wang, Jiwen Zhang, Mingxing Feng, Wenjun Wu, Zhaonong HuToxins 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how Celangulin V (CV), a natural insecticide from Celastrus angulatus, kills lepidopteran larvae. Researchers found that CV specifically targets and inhibits V-ATPase in the apical membrane of midgut cells in susceptible larvae (Mythimna separata), leading to rapid depolarization and disruption of essential cellular functions. This work clarifies CV's mode of action, differentiating it from Bt toxins and highlighting V-ATPase as a key insecticidal target.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The extensive use of synthetic insecticides has led to significant environmental concerns and the development of insect resistance. This has spurred a search for biologically based alternatives, with plant-derived compounds showing great promise. Celangulin V (CV) is a potent insecticidal component found in Celastrus angulatus, known to cause severe midgut damage in larvae. While previous research suggested that the V-ATPase in larval midgut cells might be a target for CV, the precise mechanism of its action, especially how it leads to larval death, remained unclear. This paper aims to elucidate this mode of action by examining CV's effects on the electrical potential of midgut cells and its direct impact on V-ATPase activity, comparing it to a well-known Bt toxin (Cry1Ab) and an inactive derivative of CV.

Methods

The researchers employed electrophysiological techniques to measure the transmembrane potential of midgut cells. Specifically, they used intracellular microelectrode recording to assess the apical membrane potential (V<sub>am</sub>) and basolateral membrane potential (V<sub>bm</sub>) in two lepidopteran species: the susceptible Mythimna separata and the less susceptible Agrotis ipsilon. Experiments involved two main approaches:

  1. Force-feeding: Larvae were fed with CV, Cry1Ab, or an inactive CV derivative (CV-MIA), and their midgut potentials were monitored over time.
  2. Direct Incubation: Isolated midgut segments were directly exposed to CV or Cry1Ab in a recording bath to observe immediate effects.

Additionally, V-ATPase activity in midgut epithelial cells was measured using enzyme assays to quantify the inhibition caused by CV and CV-MIA, with bafilomycin A1 (BA1) serving as a positive control inhibitor.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental measurements from live insect larvae and isolated midgut tissues.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CV targets the apical membrane: The study strongly suggests that CV's primary site of action is the apical membrane of midgut cells, leading to a rapid and dose-dependent depolarization (V<sub>am</sub> decay).
  • V-ATPase is the key target: Enzymatic assays confirmed that CV significantly inhibits V-ATPase activity in a dose-dependent manner, while the inactive CV-MIA did not. This provides direct evidence for V-ATPase being the molecular target of CV.
  • Species-specific sensitivity: CV's effect on V<sub>am</sub> was much more pronounced in susceptible M. separata larvae compared to less susceptible A. ipsilon larvae, particularly when applied directly to isolated midguts. This highlights differences in midgut physiology or target site accessibility between species.
  • Distinct mechanism from Bt toxins: While both CV and Cry1Ab cause V<sub>am</sub> depolarization, CV's effect appears faster and potentially more specific to V-ATPase, whereas Cry1Ab's mechanism is thought to involve pore formation.
  • Basolateral membrane unaffected: CV did not significantly alter the basolateral membrane potential (V<sub>bm</sub>), reinforcing its specific action on the apical side.

Key Results

  • Force-feeding: In M. separata larvae force-fed with CV, V<sub>am</sub> rapidly depolarized over 12 hours, reaching a significant decrease compared to controls. Cry1Ab showed a similar, though slightly slower, depolarization effect. CV-MIA had no effect on V<sub>am</sub>, and A. ipsilon larvae force-fed with CV showed no significant change in V<sub>am</sub>. The basolateral potential (V<sub>bm</sub>) remained largely unaffected by CV, Cry1Ab, or CV-MIA in both species.
  • Direct Incubation: Direct incubation of M. separata midguts with CV caused dose-dependent V<sub>am</sub> depolarization, with a faster response than Cry1Ab. A. ipsilon midguts showed a less pronounced depolarization response to CV.
  • V-ATPase Inhibition: CV significantly inhibited V-ATPase activity in M. separata midguts by up to 23.41% at 200 µmol/L, comparable to the positive control bafilomycin A1. CV-MIA did not show significant inhibition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Species-specific differences: The paper notes that the specific reasons for the divergent sensitivities of M. separata and A. ipsilon to CV require further investigation. Differences in apical membrane composition or physiological characteristics are suggested.
  • Mechanism of V-ATPase disruption: While CV is shown to inhibit V-ATPase, the precise molecular details of how CV interacts with and inhibits the V-ATPase complex remain unclear and warrant further research.
  • Downstream effects: The study demonstrates that CV disrupts intracellular pH homeostasis and nutrient transport by affecting V-ATPase. However, a more detailed understanding of how these disruptions lead to the observed symptoms (diarrhea, vomiting, body water loss, midgut rupture) and ultimately death would be beneficial.
  • In vivo vs. in vitro: While direct incubation experiments provide insights into immediate effects, the long-term consequences observed in force-feeding experiments highlight the complexity of in vivo interactions.

The authors conclude that CV targets V-ATPase in the apical membrane of midgut goblet cells, leading to the collapse of the electrochemical gradient and subsequent disruption of normal physiological function, ultimately causing irreversible midgut damage.

Summary updated

Abstract

Celangulin V (CV) is the main insecticidal constituent of <i>Celastrus angulatus</i>. The V-ATPase H subunit of the midgut cells of lepidopteran larvae is the putative target protein of CV. Here, we compared the effects of CV on the midgut membrane potentials of <i>Mythimna separata</i> and <i>Agrotis ipsilon</i> larvae with those of the Cry1Ab toxin from <i>Bacillus thuringiensis</i> and with those of inactive CV-MIA, a synthetic derivative of CV. We investigated the changes in the apical membrane potentials (<i>V<sub>am</sub></i>) and basolateral membrane potentials (<i>V<sub>bm</sub></i>) of the midguts of sixth-instar larvae force-fed with the test toxins. We also measured the <i>V<sub>am</sub></i> and <i>V<sub>bm</sub></i> of larval midguts that were directly incubated with the test toxins. Similar to the effect of Cry1Ab, the <i>V<sub>am</sub></i> of CV-treated midguts rapidly decayed over time in a dose-dependent manner. By contrast, CV-MIA did not influence <i>V<sub>am</sub></i>. Meanwhile, the <i>V<sub>am</sub></i> of <i>A. ipsilon</i> larval midguts directly incubated with CV decayed less than that of <i>M. separata</i> larval midguts, whereas that of larvae force-fed with CV did not significantly change. Similar to Cry1Ab, CV did not affect the <i>V<sub>bm</sub></i> of isolated midguts. CV significantly inhibited V-ATPase activity in a dose-dependent manner. Therefore, CV initially inhibits V-ATPase in the apical membrane and affects intracellular pH, homeostasis, and nutrient transport mechanisms in lepidopteran midgut cells.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2017insight,
  author = {Yingying Wang and Jiwen Zhang and Mingxing Feng and Wenjun Wu and Zhaonong Hu},
  title = {{Insight into the Mode of Action of Celangulin V on the Transmembrane Potential of Midgut Cells in Lepidopteran Larvae}},
  booktitle = {Toxins},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/toxins9120393},
}
Figure