Insight into Compounds with Cu(H2O)62+ Units: New Ideas for Understanding Cu2+ in Tutton Salts

J. A. Aramburu, Arghya Bhowmik, J. M. García‐Lastra, Pablo García‐Fernández, M. MorenoThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

For decades, the behavior of copper ions in Tutton salts has been explained by the Jahn-Teller effect causing elongated octahedra. This paper challenges that long-held view, demonstrating through calculations and experimental data that the reality is a compressed octahedron, masked by an orthorhombic distortion driven by the surrounding crystal lattice's electric field.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The study of transition metal ions in crystalline solids often relies on understanding their local coordination environment. Copper(II) ions, with their d⁹ electron configuration, are particularly prone to the Jahn-Teller effect (JTE). This effect predicts that a non-linearly degenerate electronic state will distort its geometry to lower its energy, typically resulting in an elongated or compressed octahedron. For copper(II) in Tutton salts (a common class of inorganic compounds), the prevailing interpretation for the past 65 years has been that the Cu(H₂O)₆²⁺ complex undergoes a static JTE, leading to an elongated octahedron. However, experimental data, particularly from Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, has shown some puzzling aspects that don't perfectly align with this simple JTE model. This paper aims to reconcile these discrepancies and provide a more accurate picture of the Cu(H₂O)₆²⁺ geometry in Tutton salts.

Methods

The authors employed a combination of first-principles calculations and analysis of existing experimental data.

  • Density Functional Theory (DFT): They used the CRYSTAL17 code for periodic geometry optimizations of Tutton salt compounds and M(H₂O)SiF₆ systems. They also utilized the VASP code for geometry optimizations under external pressure, employing the PBEsol functional.
  • Electrostatic Potential Calculations: A crucial part of their methodology involved calculating the electrostatic potential, V<sub>R</sub>(r), created by the surrounding lattice ions on the electrons within the Cu(H₂O)₆²⁺ complex. This was done using a modified version of the Ewald's method.
  • Analysis of Experimental Data: They critically re-examined existing EPR and X-ray diffraction data for Tutton salts and related systems.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on analyzing existing experimental data from literature and performing ab initio calculations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Challenging the Dominant Paradigm: The paper directly refutes the long-standing explanation of an elongated Cu(H₂O)₆²⁺ octahedron due to a static Jahn-Teller effect in Tutton salts.
  • The Crucial Role of the Lattice Electric Field: The authors highlight that the electrostatic field (E<sub>R</sub>(r)) generated by the surrounding ions in the Tutton salt lattice is not negligible and significantly influences the electronic structure of the Cu(H₂O)₆²⁺ complex.
  • Compressed Octahedron as the True Ground State: They propose that the intrinsic geometry of the Cu(H₂O)₆²⁺ unit, when influenced by the lattice field, is actually a compressed octahedron.
  • Orthorhombic Instability as a Mask: The observed experimental geometries and EPR spectra are explained by an additional orthorhombic distortion in the XY plane, which arises from the compressed state and is unrelated to the JTE. This distortion effectively "hides" the underlying compressed geometry.
  • Singularity of Cu²⁺: The paper points out that Cu²⁺ exhibits unique behavior among 3d divalent cations, making it particularly susceptible to these types of distortions driven by lattice fields.

Key Results

  • Reinterpretation of EPR Data: The authors successfully explain the observed EPR g-tensor values and their temperature dependence in Tutton salts by considering a compressed octahedron with an orthorhombic distortion, rather than an elongated one.
  • Quantitative Agreement: Their calculations for the electrostatic potential and the resulting geometry changes show good qualitative and, in some cases, quantitative agreement with experimental observations.
  • Energy Barrier Calculations: They calculated energy barriers for different distortions, showing that the orthorhombic instability leads to a lower energy state compared to a simple compressed tetragonal geometry. For K₂Zn(H₂O)₆(SO₄)₂:Cu²⁺, they found energy differences and barriers that align with experimental observations of dynamic processes.
  • Comparison with Trigonal Systems: The paper contrasts the situation in Tutton salts with trigonal systems (like Zn(H₂O)SiF₆:Cu²⁺), where a true JTE leading to an elongated octahedron is clearly observed, highlighting the different driving forces.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Complexity of Orthorhombic Instability: While the paper explains the origin of the orthorhombic instability, the detailed mechanisms and conditions for its occurrence in various systems are still areas for further investigation.
  • Broader Applicability: The authors suggest that their approach of considering the internal electric field is crucial for understanding other transition metal ions (Ag²⁺, Mn³⁺) in low-symmetry insulating lattices where JTE is typically invoked. Future work will focus on applying these ideas to other specific compounds.
  • Experimental Verification: While the paper reinterprets existing data, further targeted experimental studies could provide even more direct evidence for the proposed compressed octahedron and orthorhombic distortion.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the last 65 years the properties of Tutton salts containing Cu2+ cations have been interpreted on the basis of elongated complexes induced by a static Jahn–Teller effect (JTE). Through the analysis of experimental data and the results of first-principles calculations, we show here that such an idea, though widely followed, is not correct. By contrast, this work proves that the local geometry of Cu(H2O)62+ units in Tutton salts actually arises from a compressed octahedron although hidden by an additional orthorhombic instability fully unrelated to the JTE. For understanding this conclusion, it is crucial to consider the effects of the internal electric field, ER(r), created by the rest of the lattice ions on the electrons localized in the Cu(H2O)62+ unit. Indeed, the ER(r) field in Tutton salts opens a gap between ∼x2–y2 and ∼3z2–r2 antibonding molecular orbitals that favors a hole in ∼3z2–r2 and triggers an orthorhombic distortion in the XY plane that reasonably explains available experimental data. The conditions responsible for the orthorhombic instability are discussed pointing out the singularity of Cu2+ complexes in the realm of 3d divalent cations. For the sake of completeness the properties of Cu(H2O)62+ units in trigonal lattices, where a JTE is clearly observed, are analyzed in detail and compared to results of Cu2+ cations in cubic lattices. In the trigonal compounds, the force constant of the Jahn–Teller mode is shown to be smaller than that for hard ligands like O2– or F– but comparable to the softer ligand Cl–. This fact helps to promote the orthorhombic instability in the Cu(H2O)62+ complex when the hole is no longer in the ∼x2–y2 orbital but in ∼3z2–r2.
BibTeX
@article{aramburu2019insight,
  author = {J. A. Aramburu and Arghya Bhowmik and J. M. García‐Lastra and Pablo García‐Fernández and M. Moreno},
  title = {{Insight into Compounds with Cu(H<sub>2</sub>O)<sub>6</sub><sup>2+</sup> Units: New Ideas for Understanding Cu<sup>2+</sup> in Tutton Salts}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.8b10441},
}
Figure