Inpatient healthcare provider bypassing by women and their children in urban Bo, Sierra Leone

Lila C. Fleming, Rashid Ansumana, Alfred S. Bockarie, Joel D. Alejandre, Umaru Bangura, David Henry Jimmy, Nigel Waters, Heibatollah Baghi, David A. Stenger, Kathryn H. JacobsenPan African Medical Journal 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates why women in urban Bo, Sierra Leone, bypass closer healthcare facilities for inpatient care, finding that the Bo Government Hospital (BGH) is overwhelmingly preferred due to its perceived comprehensive and low-cost services. Despite a diverse healthcare landscape, bypassing is common, driven by a desire for advanced care and affordability, rather than just proximity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding healthcare-seeking behavior is crucial for optimizing healthcare delivery, especially in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) where resources are often constrained. While much research on healthcare bypassing (choosing a facility farther away than the nearest option) has focused on high-income countries or rural LMIC settings, there's a notable gap in understanding this phenomenon within urban LMIC environments. Urban areas often present a more complex healthcare marketplace with diverse formal and informal providers. This paper addresses this gap by examining the inpatient care bypassing behavior of women and their children in urban Bo, Sierra Leone, a city with a varied healthcare landscape, to identify the factors influencing these decisions.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining Geographic Information Systems (GIS) with a household health survey. A GIS database of Bo was created, mapping residential structures and healthcare facilities. Road distances from homes to both the nearest and preferred inpatient facilities were calculated using GIS network analysis. A two-stage survey was conducted: first, a household survey to gather demographic and socioeconomic data, and second, a maternal and child health survey with women aged 18 and older. Specific questions were designed to elicit preferences for inpatient care providers for themselves and their children, and to understand the reasons behind bypassing. Socioeconomic status (SES) was assessed using a composite index derived from factor analysis of household variables. Statistical analyses, including chi-square tests, were used to identify associations between bypassing behavior and various demographic, socioeconomic, and proximity factors.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 1,980 women in urban Bo, Sierra Leone, who participated in a maternal and child health survey between November 2010 and February 2011. The survey focused on their preferences for inpatient care for themselves and their children. Geographic data for Bo, including roads and built structures, were sourced from OpenStreetMap.org and updated by the research team.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Nearest" is Not Always the "Best": Proximity is a significant factor in healthcare access, but it's not the sole determinant of provider choice, especially in urban settings with diverse options.
  • Bo Government Hospital as a Hub: BGH, the city's main public hospital, emerged as the overwhelmingly preferred inpatient provider, suggesting it offers a unique combination of perceived quality, comprehensiveness, and affordability that outweighs the convenience of closer facilities.
  • Affordability and Comprehensive Care Trump Proximity: Women are willing to travel farther to access what they perceive as low-cost and comprehensive care, including advanced diagnostics and therapies, which may be lacking at closer, often private, facilities.
  • SES is Not the Primary Driver of Bypassing in this Context: Unlike some studies, SES did not significantly predict bypassing behavior in Bo. This suggests that the preference for BGH is widespread across socioeconomic strata, likely due to its perceived advantages for serious illnesses.
  • Reputation Matters: While cost is a consideration, the study's paired-comparison questions indicated that reputation was a higher priority for provider selection, implying BGH has built a strong positive reputation.

Key Results

  • More than 70% of participating women preferred the Bo Government Hospital (BGH) for inpatient care for themselves and their children.
  • The median distance to the nearest inpatient facility was 0.9 km, while the median distance to the preferred facility (BGH) was 2.4 km.
  • Approximately 87% of women reported they would bypass their nearest inpatient facility to access their preferred provider.
  • Bypassing rates were similar across demographic and socioeconomic groups but were higher for women living farther from the city center.
  • Women who bypassed were more likely to prioritize cost over reputation and to state they would choose a different provider if cost were not a barrier.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the questions about provider preference were hypothetical, asking about plans for future care. Actual provider choices in a real-life scenario might differ, and the influence of cost as a barrier might be more pronounced in practice. Future work could explore how bypassing behavior differs for primary care services, given the greater diversity of providers available. Additionally, replication studies in other urban LMICs would be valuable to determine if the widespread preference for a public hospital, irrespective of SES, is a common finding in settings with limited inpatient care marketplaces. The authors also suggest that private providers in Bo could improve their market position by increasing transparency in fees, enhancing their reputation, and offering novel services like chronic disease management and post-surgery rehabilitation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although Bo has a diverse healthcare marketplace, access to affordable advanced care options is limited. Most women in Bo would choose to bypass facilities nearer to their homes to seek the low-cost and comprehensive care offered by Bo Government Hospital.
BibTeX
@article{fleming2016inpatient,
  author = {Lila C. Fleming and Rashid Ansumana and Alfred S. Bockarie and Joel D. Alejandre and Umaru Bangura and David Henry Jimmy and Nigel Waters and Heibatollah Baghi and David A. Stenger and Kathryn H. Jacobsen},
  title = {{Inpatient healthcare provider bypassing by women and their children in urban Bo, Sierra Leone}},
  journal = {Pan African Medical Journal},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.11604/pamj.2016.23.146.8706},
}
Figure