Innovative technology for large-scale photovoltaic consumption using reversible solid oxide cells

Hongtao Mao, Dong Nie, Xi Chen, Yan-an Cai, Jie Zhao, Xuzheng Zhang, Haoyu Yu, Wanli Ma, Zepeng Lv, Jun ZhouFrontiers in Energy Research 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel optimization model for Integrated Electricity-Gas Systems (IEGS) that utilizes Reversible Solid Oxide Cells (RSOCs) to manage large-scale photovoltaic (PV) consumption. By switching between electrolysis and fuel cell modes, RSOCs significantly reduce renewable energy curtailment and lower overall system operating costs while allowing hydrogen to be safely blended into existing natural gas infrastructure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we ramp up solar and wind capacity, we face a "good problem" that is becoming a technical nightmare: we often produce more power than the grid can handle during peak hours. This leads to curtailment, where renewable energy is simply wasted because there is nowhere for it to go.

Traditional Power-to-Gas (P2G) technologies offer a way to store this excess energy as chemical energy (hydrogen or synthetic natural gas), but they often suffer from low round-trip efficiency. Furthermore, most existing models treat the power grid and the gas grid as separate silos. The challenge lies in creating a highly efficient, bidirectional bridge between these two networks that can respond dynamically to the intermittent nature of solar power.

Methods

The researchers developed a mathematical framework for an Integrated Electricity-Gas System (IEGS). The heart of this system is the Reversible Solid Oxide Cell (RSOC). Unlike standard electrolyzers, an RSOC is a "two-way street":

  1. Electrolysis Mode (SOEC): Uses excess PV power to split water into hydrogen (and potentially CO2 into SNG).
  2. Fuel Cell Mode (SOFC): Converts stored gas back into electricity when solar production drops.

To make this work in a real-world simulation, the authors used Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MILP). They tackled the inherent non-linearities of gas flow (the Weymouth formula) and RSOC performance curves using incremental linearization techniques. The model was solved using the General Algebraic Modeling System (GAMS), focusing on minimizing total operating costs, including fuel costs, start-up costs for the RSOCs, and penalties for curtailing solar power.

Datasets

The study validated its model using a hybrid test system:

  • Power Grid: A modified IEEE RTS-24-bus system featuring three large-scale PV plants with a combined capacity of 3,000 MW.
  • Gas Grid: A 20-node natural gas network (modeled after European infrastructure like the Zeebrugge-Lille-Liege area).
  • RSOC Parameters: Technical data (efficiency, ramping rates, and start-up energy requirements) were sourced from established literature (e.g., Peksen 2018; Mogensen et al., 2019).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Efficiency Edge: RSOCs can achieve energy conversion efficiencies of over 85% in electrolysis mode, far outperforming traditional alkaline or PEM electrolyzers in an integrated setting.
  • Existing Infrastructure as a Battery: Instead of building massive new hydrogen storage tanks, the model explores injecting hydrogen directly into natural gas pipelines (Hydrogen-Enriched Compressed Natural Gas, or HCNG). The "gas grid" effectively becomes a giant, distributed battery.
  • Thermal Awareness: The model uniquely accounts for the time-varying start-up costs of RSOCs. Because these cells operate at high temperatures, they can't just be flipped on and off instantly without an energy penalty; the model optimizes the schedule to minimize these "cold start" costs.
  • The 20% Sweet Spot: The research highlights that a 20% hydrogen injection ratio is a critical threshold for significantly improving the economics of renewable integration without requiring major overhauls of end-user gas equipment.

Key Results

  • Reduced Waste: In scenarios with high solar intensity (100%), the RSOC-integrated system significantly reduced PV curtailment compared to systems without P2G capabilities.
  • Cost Savings: The integrated approach lowered the total system operating cost. For instance, at 50% light intensity, the system cost dropped from $289k (at 0% H2 injection) to $283.5k (at 20% H2 injection).
  • Dynamic Balancing: The simulation showed that RSOCs successfully transitioned to electrolysis mode during the solar peak (t9–t15) and switched to power generation or standby during the night, effectively smoothing the "duck curve" of solar production.
  • Hydrogen Production: At a 20% injection limit, the system could produce nearly $1 \times 10^6 \, \text{m}^3$ of hydrogen daily, providing a substantial carbon-neutral supplement to the gas grid.

Limitations and Future Work

While the results are promising, the authors acknowledge some simplifications:

  • DC Power Flow: The model uses a DC power flow approximation, which ignores voltage magnitudes and reactive power—factors that are crucial for real-world grid stability.
  • Gas Quality: The study focuses on the quantity of hydrogen injection but doesn't deeply model the impact of varying gas heat values on specific industrial end-user processes.
  • Degradation: The long-term chemical degradation of RSOC materials due to frequent mode-switching wasn't included in the cost function.

Future research could expand this to include carbon capture and methanation (using captured CO2 to turn H2 into Synthetic Natural Gas) to create a truly circular carbon economy within the IEGS.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is inevitable that renewable energy consumption will increase as installed capacity continues to increase, primarily wind and photovoltaic power generation. Power to Gas (P2G) technology can store electrical energy in the form of chemical energy on a large scale. Reversible solid oxide cell (RSOC) has a very high conversion efficiency in both electrolytic gas production and fuel cell power generation compared with traditional electricity-to-gas devices. For the future integrated energy system, Reversible solid oxide cells are expected to play a significant role in integrating power generation and energy storage. This work proposes a new integrated energy system based on Reversible solid oxide cell for photovoltaic (PV) consumption. The Integrated Electricity-Gas System (IEGS) considers the two modes of electrolysis and power generation of Reversible solid oxide cell in the model. The model takes the minimum running cost as the objective function to linearize part of the model to generate a mixed integer linearization problem and solve it in GAMS. The case study shows that wind power is maximized, and the gas mixture can be transported in natural gas pipelines, improving the economics and stability of Integrated Electricity-Gas System. This work not only can reduce the operating cost of the system but also increase the high penetration of photovoltaic power generation. A quantitative assessment of the impact of hydrogen injection ratio and renewable energy penetration was also carried out.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mao2023innovative,
  author = {Hongtao Mao and Dong Nie and Xi Chen and Yan-an Cai and Jie Zhao and Xuzheng Zhang and Haoyu Yu and Wanli Ma and Zepeng Lv and Jun Zhou},
  title = {{Innovative technology for large-scale photovoltaic consumption using reversible solid oxide cells}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Energy Research},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fenrg.2022.1033066},
}
Figure