Innovative Blockchain-Based Approach for Sustainable and Credible Environment in Food Trade: A Case Study in Shandong Province, China

Dianhui Mao, Zhihao Hao, Fan Wang, Haisheng LiSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces FTSCON, a novel food trading system leveraging consortium blockchain technology to combat information asymmetry and enhance credibility in agri-food trade. By integrating an improved Byzantine Fault Tolerance (iPBFT) algorithm and an online double auction mechanism, FTSCON aims to improve transaction efficiency and merchant profitability, as demonstrated by a case study in Shandong Province, China.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The agri-food trade sector, crucial for social stability and economic development, is plagued by significant information asymmetry. This imbalance of knowledge among stakeholders (farmers, processors, traders, retailers, consumers) leads to market failures, unfair trading practices (like late payments and order cancellations), and inefficient transactions due to complex processes, high costs, and long transaction times. Existing centralized systems often rely on trusted third parties, which can be points of failure and are susceptible to data tampering. The paper seeks to address these issues by creating a more transparent, secure, and efficient trading environment.

Methods

The core of FTSCON is a consortium blockchain. Unlike public blockchains, this approach uses a limited number of authorized nodes, offering a balance between decentralization and manageable costs. Key methodological components include:

  • Consortium Blockchain Architecture: Designed to handle different authentications and permissions for various roles in food transactions, ensuring data integrity and role-based access.
  • Improved Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (iPBFT): An enhancement of the PBFT consensus algorithm, designed to improve transaction verification efficiency and speed within the blockchain network.
  • Online Double Auction Mechanism: Implemented to foster competition among buyers and sellers, aiming to achieve optimal transaction matching and price discovery in a "many-to-many" market structure.
  • Dynamic Programming Algorithm: Used for optimizing transaction combinations by selecting appropriate trading objects to meet buyer demands.
  • Smart Contracts: Employed to automate and secure transactions once agreed upon, ensuring they are executed deterministically based on predefined conditions.

Datasets

The paper utilizes data from 300 small- and medium-sized agri-food enterprises in Shandong Province, China. This dataset includes profit information from January 2014 to December 2017, covering product types, transaction weights, prices, geographical locations, and timestamps. The data was used for a case study to evaluate the effectiveness of FTSCON by comparing profit outcomes before and after its implementation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Blockchain for Agri-Food Trust: The paper strongly advocates for blockchain technology as a solution to the inherent trust deficit and information asymmetry in the food supply chain, moving beyond traditional centralized systems.
  • Consortium Blockchain's Practicality: The choice of a consortium blockchain over a public one highlights a pragmatic approach, balancing the benefits of decentralization with the need for controlled access and efficiency in a business context.
  • Synergy of Mechanisms: The combination of iPBFT for consensus, double auctions for market dynamics, and DP for optimization creates a multi-faceted system designed to tackle various aspects of inefficient and unfair trade.
  • Profitability as a Key Metric: The study directly links the technical improvements to tangible business outcomes, demonstrating that enhanced efficiency and transparency can translate into significant profit increases for merchants.

Key Results

The case study in Shandong Province indicated that FTSCON significantly improved merchant profits. Specifically:

  • Profit Rate Increase: Companies using FTSCON showed a generally higher profit rate compared to their actual profit rates before implementation. For instance, Company 3's actual profit rate was 5.4%, with the estimated rate after using FTSCON ranging from 8.4% to 22.8%.
  • Statistical Significance: Variance analysis confirmed a statistically significant difference in profit rates between companies using FTSCON and those not, with a p-value of 0.0049 (< 0.05), rejecting the null hypothesis of no difference.
  • Efficiency Improvement: The iPBFT algorithm and online double auction mechanism were designed to improve transaction efficiency, although specific quantitative metrics for this improvement were not detailed in the results section.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations inherent to current blockchain technologies, which also affect FTSCON:

  • Computational Resources: High demand for computing power can lead to reduced transaction efficiency, especially under high throughput.
  • Transaction Costs: Blockchain operations can incur significant costs.
  • Block Speed and Scalability: These are persistent challenges that limit the overall speed and capacity of the system.

Future work will focus on addressing these limitations. Additionally, the paper identifies the need for a fair mechanism to allocate the computational costs associated with the on-chain matching algorithm, as these costs are not determinable in advance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Agri-food trade has a profound impact on social stability and sustainable economic development. However, there are several technological problems in current agricultural product transactions. For example, it is almost impossible to improve the efficiency of transactions and maintain market stability. This paper designs a novel Food Trading System with COnsortium blockchaiN (FTSCON) to eliminate information asymmetry in the food trade, in order to establish a sustainable and credible trading environment, the system uses consortium blockchain technology to meet the challenge of different authentications and permissions for different roles in food trade. Meanwhile, we have used the online double auction mechanism to eliminate competition. We also have designed a improved Practical Byzantine Fault Tolerance (iPBFT) algorithm to improve efficiency. In addition, a case study based on a series of data from Shandong Province, China indicate that the FTSCON can achieve profit improvement of merchants. Therefore, the proposed system proved to have high commercial value.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mao2018innovative,
  author = {Dianhui Mao and Zhihao Hao and Fan Wang and Haisheng Li},
  title = {{Innovative Blockchain-Based Approach for Sustainable and Credible Environment in Food Trade: A Case Study in Shandong Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10093149},
}
Figure