Innovation and High-Quality Development of Enterprises—Also on the Effect of Innovation Driving the Transformation of China’s Economic Development Model

Heng Huang, Baolei Qi, Long ChenSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals a counterintuitive finding: innovation, on average, inhibits the total factor productivity (TFP) of Chinese enterprises, hindering high-quality development. This is primarily due to a dominance of "low-quality" innovation, which masks the positive effects of "high-quality" innovation and leads to resource misallocation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

China has been actively promoting an "innovation-driven development" strategy, aiming to shift from high-speed growth to high-quality development. A key metric for this is Total Factor Productivity (TFP), which reflects overall efficiency. While the narrative suggests innovation is the engine for this transformation, this paper questions whether China's innovation efforts are truly effective. The authors identify a gap in existing research by not adequately distinguishing between different qualities of innovation, leading to potentially skewed conclusions about innovation's overall impact. They aim to understand if innovation truly drives high-quality development in China and to evaluate the effectiveness of the current innovation-driven economic model transformation.

Methods

The study employs an econometric approach using panel data from Chinese A-share listed companies.

  • Benchmark Regression: A standard regression model is used to assess the relationship between innovation (measured by R&D expenditure and patent applications) and TFP.
  • Endogeneity Test: To address potential reverse causality and unobserved factors, an instrumental variable (IV) method is used, employing the average innovation level of the same industry as the instrument. A System Generalized Method of Moments (GMM) dynamic panel analysis is also conducted to account for serial correlation in TFP.
  • Robustness Checks: The authors employ several strategies to ensure the reliability of their findings:
  • Changing the measurement method for TFP (from OP to LP method).
  • Lagging key innovation variables to account for time delays.
  • Focusing solely on manufacturing enterprises, a sector heavily reliant on innovation.
  • Mechanism Analysis: To understand why innovation might be inhibitory, the study investigates resource mismatch as a mediating factor. It also examines the impact of innovation quality on executive compensation to assess the rationality of different innovation strategies.
  • Heterogeneity Tests: The paper explores how the innovation-TFP relationship varies across different regions (eastern vs. central/western China), ownership types (state-owned vs. non-state-owned), and time periods (early vs. late stages of the innovation strategy implementation).

Datasets

The study utilizes panel data from A-share listed companies in Shanghai and Shenzhen from 2013 to 2020.

  • Company-level data: Sourced from the CSMAR database.
  • Patent data: Sourced from the CNRDS database.
  • Sample size: After data cleaning (excluding financial industry, ST/ST* companies, and those with missing data), the final sample consists of 12,600 company annual observations from 1,575 listed companies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Innovation Paradox": The most striking finding is that aggregate innovation (both R&D and patents) is negatively correlated with TFP. This challenges the conventional wisdom that innovation universally drives productivity.
  • Quality Matters: Low-Quality Innovation is Detrimental: The study strongly suggests that the quality of innovation is crucial. "Low-quality" innovation (proxied by utility model and design patents) actively inhibits TFP, likely due to resource misallocation and a focus on meeting policy requirements rather than genuine productivity gains.
  • High-Quality Innovation is Beneficial, but Masked: Conversely, "high-quality" innovation (proxied by invention patents) shows a positive, albeit weaker, effect on TFP. The inhibitory effect of low-quality innovation is so strong that it masks and overwhelms the positive impact of high-quality innovation at the aggregate level.
  • Resource Mismatch as a Key Mechanism: The research identifies resource mismatch as a significant channel through which low-quality innovation leads to reduced efficiency and TFP.
  • Heterogeneity in Effects: The negative impact of innovation is more pronounced in:
  • Eastern China (likely due to fiercer competition and a greater tendency for low-quality innovation).
  • Non-state-owned enterprises (which may be more driven by policy incentives).
  • The early stages of China's innovation-driven strategy implementation (when policies may have inadvertently encouraged quantity over quality).
  • Executive Compensation Incentives: While both types of innovation positively impact executive compensation, high-quality innovation yields a stronger effect, suggesting that pursuing low-quality innovation for policy benefits is an irrational, short-sighted strategy for executives.

Key Results

  • Benchmark Regression: Both R&D expenditure and patent applications show a statistically significant negative relationship with TFP (at the 1% level).
  • Mechanism Test:
    • Low-quality patents (L-Patent) have a significant negative coefficient (-0.0337) on TFP.
  • High-quality patents (H-Patent) have a significant positive coefficient (0.0141) on TFP.
  • Resource mismatch (MISS) fully mediates the inhibitory effect of innovation on TFP.
  • Heterogeneity Tests:
    • In the eastern region, the inhibitory effect of R&D is stronger (-0.0266) than in the central/western regions (-0.0177).
  • Non-state-owned enterprises show a stronger inhibitory effect of R&D (-0.0277) compared to state-owned enterprises (-0.0154).
  • The inhibitory effect of R&D was stronger in the early stage (2013-2016) (-0.0239) than in the later stage (2017-2020) (-0.0178).
  • Executive Compensation: Patent applications (overall) show a positive impact on executive salary, but the effect is stronger for high-quality innovation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Measurement of High-Quality Development: The study acknowledges that TFP is a proxy for high-quality development and cannot capture its full connotation. Future work could involve developing a more comprehensive index.
  • Sample Scope: The reliance on listed companies might not fully represent the impact of innovation-driven development on the broader economy, as unlisted SMEs play a significant role.
  • Policy Implications: The authors suggest that China's innovation management needs a shift in focus from quantity to quality. Future policy should emphasize transformation, improve assessment mechanisms, optimize incentive policies (reducing early-stage subsidies), and strengthen specialized institutions and talent teams. They also advocate for better equity incentive mechanisms to encourage entrepreneurs to pursue high-quality innovation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Taking the A-share listed companies in Shanghai and Shenzhen from 2013 to 2020 as the research object, this paper discusses the impact of innovation on high-quality development at the enterprise level and evaluates the effectiveness of the current transformation of innovation driving China’s economic development mode. It is found that innovation inhibits the improvement of total factor productivity of enterprises overall and hinders the high-quality development of enterprises. This result also shows that China’s innovation driven economic development mode transformation has not achieved actual effect. The reason is that China is still in the dilemma that low-quality innovation occupies the dominant position of enterprise innovation. The inhibitory effect of low-quality innovation masks the promoting effect of high-quality innovation, which makes the net effect of innovation on enterprise productivity being inhibitory, and this inhibition is characterized by a loss of efficiency, which is caused by a mismatch of resources. Heterogeneity analysis shows that the inhibition effect of innovation is stronger in eastern enterprises, non-state-owned enterprises and the early implementation of innovation driven strategy. It is also found that the promotion effect of high-quality innovation on executive compensation is stronger than that of low-quality innovation, which indicates that carrying out low-quality innovation is an irrational and short-sighted behavior. The study provides important insights for China to optimize and improve innovation policies and to promote the shift of the overall innovation structure to high-quality innovation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2022innovation,
  author = {Heng Huang and Baolei Qi and Long Chen},
  title = {{Innovation and High-Quality Development of Enterprises—Also on the Effect of Innovation Driving the Transformation of China’s Economic Development Model}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14148440},
}
Figure