Inland Lakes Mapping for Monitoring Water Quality Using a Detail/Smoothing-Balanced Conditional Random Field Based on Landsat-8/Levels Data

Lifei Wei, Yu Zhang, Can Huang, Zhengxiang Wang, Qingbin Huang, Feng Yin, Yue Guo, Liqin CaoSensors 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for mapping inland lake water quality using Landsat-8 satellite imagery and a detail-preserving Conditional Random Field (CRF) model. By combining spectral information with spatial context, the approach significantly improves classification accuracy compared to traditional pixel-based methods, offering a more efficient and scalable solution for water quality monitoring in China.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Monitoring the quality of inland water bodies is crucial for sustainable development and environmental protection. China has established comprehensive standards for water quality assessment, but traditional on-site testing methods are labor-intensive, time-consuming, and struggle to keep pace with the vast monitoring needs. Furthermore, many key water quality indicators are "non-optically active," meaning their presence doesn't directly correlate with spectral signatures in satellite imagery, making remote sensing-based assessment challenging. Existing remote sensing approaches often focus on optically active parameters or struggle with the "salt-and-pepper" noise inherent in pixel-based classifications, leading to inaccurate assessments, especially for smaller water bodies.

Methods

The core of this research lies in an "Improved Conditional Random Field (CRF) Model." CRFs are probabilistic models adept at incorporating spatial information, which is vital for classifying contiguous areas like lakes. The authors propose a "detail-preserving smoothing" CRF. Here's how it works:

  • Unary Potential: This component uses the output of a Random Forest (RF) classifier. RF is chosen for its robustness and good generalization ability. The RF classifier provides the initial probability of a pixel belonging to a specific water quality class based on its spectral characteristics.
  • Pairwise Potential: This is where the "detail-preserving smoothing" comes in. Instead of just smoothing out noise, this component balances spatial context with the preservation of fine details. It considers the relationship between adjacent pixels, penalizing differences in water quality labels between neighboring pixels. However, it's designed to be less aggressive than standard smoothing, allowing for the retention of finer features and variations. A key parameter, λ, controls the balance between spatial smoothing and detail preservation.
  • Integration: The CRF model then optimizes these potentials to produce a final, more accurate classification map. The authors also compared their RF-CRF model against standalone RF, Decision Tree (DT), and Deep Neural Network (DNN) models to demonstrate its superiority.

Datasets

The study utilized Landsat-8 Operational Land Imager (OLI) imagery for two distinct study areas in Hubei Province, China:

  • Wuhan Dataset: Focused on Wuhan city and its surrounding water systems, including 76 lakes.
  • Huangshi Dataset: Centered around Huangshi city and along the Yangtze River, encompassing 49 lakes.

Water quality data for these lakes was obtained from local environmental bureaus. The paper provides detailed tables of water quality parameters (TP, COD, BOD, CODMn, NH3-N) and their superstandard multiples for representative lakes. The Landsat-8 images were processed for water extraction using vector maps obtained from the Geospatial Data Cloud. The datasets were prepared with features (seven spectral bands) and samples (individual pixels), with a training-to-test set ratio of 1:9.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Spatial Context is King (for Lakes): The paper strongly emphasizes that lakes are contiguous water bodies, and their water quality is not determined by individual pixels in isolation. Incorporating spatial relationships significantly boosts classification accuracy.
  • Balancing Act: Smoothing vs. Detail: The core innovation is the "detail-preserving smoothing" within the CRF. This is crucial because overly aggressive smoothing can obscure important variations, while no smoothing leads to noisy results. Finding this balance is key to accurate lake water quality mapping.
  • RF as a Strong Foundation: Using Random Forest as the unary potential for the CRF provides a robust starting point. RF's ability to handle complex relationships and its good generalization make it an excellent choice for initial pixel-wise classification.
  • Beyond Pixel-Based: The study highlights the limitations of purely pixel-based classification methods (like DT, DNN, and even RF alone) in dealing with the "salt-and-pepper" noise, which is particularly problematic for accurate lake classification.

Key Results

The RF-CRF model demonstrated superior performance in both study areas:

  • Wuhan Study Area: Achieved an Overall Accuracy (OA) of 89.50% and a Kappa coefficient of 0.841.
  • Huangshi Study Area: Achieved an OA of 90.35% and a Kappa coefficient of 0.868.

These results were consistently higher than those obtained by the DT, DNN, and standalone RF classifiers. The paper also notes that the RF-CRF model was particularly effective in accurately classifying Class VI lakes, often achieving near 100% accuracy for this class in both study areas. The visual results (Figure 4 and Figure 6) clearly show the reduction in salt-and-pepper noise and the improved segmentation of lake boundaries with the RF-CRF approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Lakes and Edge Regions: The authors acknowledge that the classification of very small lakes and lake edge regions can still be challenging and may lead to misjudgments. This is attributed to the influence of adjacent pixels and the limited spatial resolution of Landsat-8.
  • Spatial Resolution: To address the limitations with small lakes, the paper suggests that future research should utilize satellites with higher spatial resolution.
  • Additional Spatial Features: While the CRF incorporates spatial context, the study notes that more valuable spatial features like textures and edges were not explicitly used. Future work could explore incorporating these features and employing spatial-spectral fusion techniques for even greater accuracy.
  • Scalability and Automation: The ultimate goal is to enable rapid, large-scale assessment of inland lake water quality with minimal on-site sampling, and the authors believe their approach is a significant step towards this. Further strengthening the CRF's application and developing more stable, mobile models are key future directions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The sustainable development of water resources is always emphasized in China, and a set of perfect standards for the division of inland water environment quality have been established to monitor water quality. However, most of the 24 indicators that determine the water quality level in the standards are non-optically active parameters. The weak optical characteristics make it difficult to find significant correlations between the single parameters and the remote sensing imagery. In addition, traditional on-site testing methods have been unable to meet the increasingly extensive water-quality monitoring requirements. Based on the above questions, it’s meaningful that the supervised classification process of a detail-preserving smoothing classifier based on conditional random field (CRF) and Landsat-8 data was proposed in the two study areas around Wuhan and Huangshi in Hubei Province. The random forest classifier was selected to model the association potential of the CRF. The results (the first study area: OA = 89.50%, Kappa = 0.841; the second study area: OA = 90.35%, Kappa = 0.868) showed that the water-quality monitoring based on CRF model is feasible, and this approach can provide a reference for water-quality mapping of inland lakes. In the future, it may only require a small amount of on-site sampling to achieve the identification of the water quality levels of inland lakes across a large area of China.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wei2020inland,
  author = {Lifei Wei and Yu Zhang and Can Huang and Zhengxiang Wang and Qingbin Huang and Feng Yin and Yue Guo and Liqin Cao},
  title = {{Inland Lakes Mapping for Monitoring Water Quality Using a Detail/Smoothing-Balanced Conditional Random Field Based on Landsat-8/Levels Data}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=krXGA6x_uZs},
}
Figure