Initial Studies on the Effect of the Rice–Duck–Crayfish Ecological Co-Culture System on Physical, Chemical, and Microbiological Properties of Soils: A Field Case Study in Chaohu Lake Basin, Southeast China

Jun Yan, Jingwei Yu, Wei Huang, Xiaoxue Pan, Yucheng Li, Shunyao Li, Yalu Tao, Kang Zhang, Xuesheng ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the "rice-duck-crayfish" (RDC) ecological co-culture system in China, finding it significantly improves soil fertility, nutrient content, and enzyme activity compared to traditional rice farming. Crucially, the RDC system also reduces nitrogen and phosphorus runoff into waterways and doesn't increase heavy metal pollution, offering a promising solution for agricultural nonpoint-source pollution and enhanced farm economics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Intensive rice cultivation, a staple food globally, often relies heavily on chemical fertilizers and pesticides. This practice leads to significant environmental issues, including soil degradation, reduced fertility, and substantial nutrient runoff that contributes to water pollution, particularly eutrophication in sensitive areas like China's Chaohu Lake. While integrated farming systems like rice-fish or rice-duck have shown promise, research has largely focused on binary combinations. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the synergistic effects of a more complex, three-component system – rice, ducks, and crayfish – on soil health, nutrient management, and overall environmental impact.

Methods

The researchers conducted a field experiment in the Chaohu Lake Basin, comparing four treatment groups:

  • RDC (Rice-Duck-Crayfish): The integrated ecological co-culture system.
  • CK (Control): An idle field.
  • SSR (Single-Season Rice): Traditional single-season rice cultivation.
  • DSR (Double-Season Rice): Traditional double-season rice cultivation.

The RDC system involved a reduced chemical fertilizer application (50% less than conventional methods). Soil samples were collected and analyzed for physical properties (bulk density, porosity), chemical properties (pH, total nitrogen, total phosphorus, available nitrogen, available potassium, soil organic matter), humus content, and enzyme activities (urease, acid phosphatase, catalase). Runoff water was monitored for nitrogen and phosphorus losses. Heavy metal concentrations in the soil were also assessed. Additionally, rice quality and economic benefits were evaluated.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on field experimental data collected from the specified location.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Benefits of Integration: The RDC system demonstrates that combining three components (rice, ducks, crayfish) yields greater benefits than binary systems, particularly in soil improvement and pollution reduction.
  • Natural Fertilization and Pest Control: Ducks and crayfish act as natural fertilizers (via their manure) and pest controllers, reducing the reliance on chemical inputs and contributing to higher soil organic matter and nutrient availability.
  • Improved Soil Structure and Health: The burrowing activity of crayfish and the foraging of ducks contribute to reduced soil bulk density, increased porosity, and enhanced aeration, all crucial for healthy soil.
  • Nutrient Retention: The RDC system significantly reduces the loss of nitrogen and phosphorus through runoff, a critical factor in mitigating eutrophication in surrounding water bodies.
  • No Heavy Metal Accumulation: Despite the introduction of animals, the RDC system did not lead to an increase in harmful heavy metal concentrations in the soil, suggesting it's environmentally safe in this regard.
  • Enhanced Rice Quality and Farmer Income: Beyond environmental benefits, the RDC system leads to improved rice quality and significantly higher economic returns for farmers due to the combined yield of rice, ducks, and crayfish.

Key Results

  • Soil Fertility: The RDC system showed higher soil total nitrogen (8.54–28.37% more) and total phosphorus (8.22–30.53% more) in the top 10 cm layer compared to other systems. Soil organic matter also increased significantly (18.24–41.54%).
  • Enzyme Activity: Urease activity increased by 87.51% and acid phosphatase activity by 70.21% in the RDC system compared to the control.
  • Nutrient Runoff Reduction: RDC reduced total nitrogen runoff by 24.30% and total phosphorus runoff by 10.29% compared to the single-season rice system.
  • Heavy Metals: Soil heavy metal concentrations remained within safe limits and did not increase due to the RDC system.
  • Economic Benefits: Rice yield in the RDC system was higher than SSR, and the overall profit was significantly greater (136.61% higher than SSR and 18.35% higher than DSR), driven by the combined income from rice, ducks, and crayfish.
  • Rice Quality: RDC rice showed slightly higher brown rice, milled rice, and head milled rice rates, with significantly lower chalky rice rates and chalkiness degrees. Protein content and gel consistency were also higher.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study has limitations, including the potential for organic pollutants from duck feed and the need to optimize the quantity of ducks and crayfish. They suggest that further research is needed to fully understand these aspects. The paper also highlights the need for government support, training, and guidance for farmers to effectively implement and maximize the benefits of the RDC system. Future work could focus on scaling up the RDC system, optimizing stocking densities, and further investigating the long-term impacts on soil microbiology and broader ecosystem services.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rice-duck and rice-crayfish co-culture patterns can increase soil productivity and sustainability and reduce the use of chemical pesticides and fertilizers, thereby reducing the resulting negative environmental impacts. However, most studies have focused on the rice-duck and rice-crayfish binary patterns and have ignored integrated systems (three or more), which may have unexpected synergistic effects. To test these effects, a paddy field experiment was carried out in the Chaohu Lake Basin, Hefei city, Southeast China. Four groups, including a rice-duck-crayfish ecological co-culture system (RDC), idle field (CK), single-season rice planting system (SSR), and double-season rice planting system (DSR), were established in this study. The results showed that the RDC improved the soil physical properties, fertility, humus content, and enzyme activity. In the RDC system, the soil total nitrogen content ranged from 8.54% to 28.37% higher than other systems in the 0-10 cm soil layer. Similar increases were found for soil total phosphorus (8.22-30.53%), available nitrogen (6.93-22.72%), organic matter (18.24-41.54%), urease activity (16.67-71.51%), and acid phosphatase activity (23.41-66.20%). Relative to the SSR treatment, the RDC treatment reduced the total losses of nitrogen and phosphorus runoff by 24.30% and 10.29%, respectively. The RDC also did not cause any harm to the soil in terms of heavy metal pollution. Furthermore, the RDC improved the yield and quality of rice, farmer incomes, and eco-environmental profits. In general, the RDC can serve as a valuable method for the management of agricultural nonpoint-source pollution in the Chaohu Lake area and the revitalization of the countryside.
BibTeX
@article{yan2023initial,
  author = {Jun Yan and Jingwei Yu and Wei Huang and Xiaoxue Pan and Yucheng Li and Shunyao Li and Yalu Tao and Kang Zhang and Xuesheng Zhang},
  title = {{Initial Studies on the Effect of the Rice–Duck–Crayfish Ecological Co-Culture System on Physical, Chemical, and Microbiological Properties of Soils: A Field Case Study in Chaohu Lake Basin, Southeast China}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20032006},
}
Figure