Initial low-dose computed tomography screening results and summary of participant characteristics: based on the latest Chinese guideline

Zixuan Zhang, Yinyan Gao, Shaohui Liu, Binrong Ding, Xuewei Zhang, Xinyin WuFrontiers in Oncology 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Over one-quarter of individuals who received LDCT screening did not meet the guideline-defined high-risk populations. Appropriate cut-off values for positive nodules need to be continuously explored. More precise and localized criteria for high-risk individuals are needed, especially for non-smoking women.

Introduction

Lung cancer remains a leading cause of mortality in China. While Low-Dose Computed Tomography (LDCT) is a proven tool for early detection, its efficacy depends entirely on accurate risk stratification. If screening is too broad, it leads to overdiagnosis, unnecessary radiation exposure, and a strain on medical resources.

In 2021, China updated its national guidelines to include a broader range of risk factors, such as passive smoking and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). However, in clinical practice, many Chinese residents undergo LDCT during routine physical examinations at their own discretion. This study investigates the "compliance gap" between these new guidelines and actual clinical practice, while also characterizing the types of lung nodules found in this specific population.

Methods

This single-center, cross-sectional study was conducted at a tertiary teaching hospital in Hunan, China. Researchers analyzed data from 5,486 participants who underwent LDCT between January and December 2021.

Illustration of the Low-Dose Computed Tomography (LDCT) screening process.

Key methodological features included:

  • Guideline Comparison: Participants were evaluated against the China Guideline for the Screening and Early Detection of Lung Cancer (2021).
  • Nodule Classification: Lung nodules were categorized using Lung-RADS (Lung Reporting and Data System) version 1.1.
  • Statistical Stratification: The cohort was divided by smoking status (non-smokers, smokers, ex-smokers) and sex to identify demographic-specific trends.

The study utilized a primary clinical dataset exported from the hospital’s health management system. From an initial pool of 24,499 LDCT records, a final cohort of 5,486 participants was established by matching results with complete pre-examination questionnaires regarding risk factors like age, smoking history, and family history.

Results and Discussion

The Over-screening Phenomenon

A significant finding was that 26% of the total screened population—and 36.4% of non-smokers—did not meet the high-risk criteria defined by the 2021 guidelines. This suggests that LDCT is frequently being used as a general diagnostic tool rather than a targeted screening intervention.

The "Nodule-Positive" Paradox

While 84.3% of participants (4,622 individuals) were found to have lung nodules, the vast majority required no clinical intervention. Most nodules were low-risk (Lung-RADS 2: 73.9%), while only 1.6% were high-risk (Lung-RADS 4). This high prevalence of benign nodules highlights the risk of "incidentalomas" in low-risk populations.

Graphical abstract summarizing screening compliance, risk factors, and key radiological findings.

Threshold Sensitivity and Demographic Phenotypes

The study found that the "positive nodule" detection rate shifted dramatically from 71.2% to 46.8% depending on whether a 4mm (NLST) or 5mm (Shanghai) cut-off was used, suggesting that Western-derived thresholds may not be optimal for Asian populations. Furthermore, non-smoking women were significantly more likely to present with ground-glass opacities (GGOs) at 26.7%, compared to 21.8% in non-smoking men. This reinforces evidence that lung cancer in Asian women is a distinct pathological entity often unrelated to tobacco use.

Conclusion

While LDCT is vital for early detection, current clinical practice in China shows a significant trend toward over-screening. The authors acknowledge limitations such as single-center bias and reliance on self-reported risk factors. Future work must focus on developing more precise, localized screening criteria that account for the high incidence of lung cancer in non-smoking Asian women, potentially moving beyond traditional age and smoking-based metrics to include more nuanced risk factors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over one-quarter of individuals who received LDCT screening did not meet the guideline-defined high-risk populations. Appropriate cut-off values for positive nodules need to be continuously explored. More precise and localized criteria for high-risk individuals are needed, especially for non-smoking women.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2023initial,
  author = {Zixuan Zhang and Yinyan Gao and Shaohui Liu and Binrong Ding and Xuewei Zhang and Xinyin Wu},
  title = {{Initial low-dose computed tomography screening results and summary of participant characteristics: based on the latest Chinese guideline}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Oncology},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3389/fonc.2023.1085434},
}
Figure