Initial characterization of gap phase introduction in every cell cycle of C. elegans embryogenesis

Ming‐Kin Wong, Vincy Wing Sze Ho, Xiaotai Huang, Lu-yan Chan, Dongying Xie, Runsheng Li, Xiaoliang Ren, Guoye Guan, Yiming Ma, Boyi Hu, Hong Yan, Zhongying ZhaoFrontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel "Worm-FUCCI" system in C. elegans to visualize cell cycle phases during embryonic development. Their findings reveal that most embryonic cells divide without distinct G1 or G2 phases, with only a few cells exhibiting a full cell cycle, providing a crucial initial map of gap phase introduction in metazoan embryogenesis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Early embryonic cell cycles in many organisms, including C. elegans, are characterized by rapid divisions that primarily consist of DNA synthesis (S) and mitosis (M) phases, often lacking the gap phases (G1 and G2) found in somatic cells. While it's understood that these gap phases are introduced later in development in a cell-type and time-dependent manner, the precise timing and spatial patterns of their introduction during embryogenesis have remained poorly defined. This lack of understanding hinders our ability to grasp how cell cycle progression is developmentally regulated and coordinated with cell fate decisions. The challenge lies in the rapid pace of embryonic divisions and the difficulty in reliably tracking and quantifying cell cycle markers in live embryos with high temporal resolution.

Methods

The core innovation of this study is the development and application of Worm-FUCCI reporters, a C. elegans-specific adaptation of the fluorescent ubiquitination-based cell cycle indicator (FUCCI) system. These reporters are based on pairs of fluorescent proteins (mCherry and GFP) fused to degron domains of CDT1 (a G1/G0 phase marker) and CYB1 (a G2/S phase marker). The key novelty lies in:

  • Worm-specific FUCCI constructs: Adapting human FUCCI components to C. elegans by using specific degrons (PIP box for CDT1, D-box for CYB1) and regulatory elements (his-72 promoter and pie-1 3' UTR) to ensure broad maternal and zygotic expression.
  • Single-copy transgene integration: Utilizing the miniMos technique for precise integration of the FUCCI constructs into the C. elegans genome, ensuring consistent expression levels and minimizing positional effects.
  • Time-lapse 3D confocal microscopy: Capturing high-resolution, dynamic images of developing embryos over extended periods.
  • Automated lineaging and expression profiling: Employing established computational tools to trace cell divisions and quantify the accumulation of FUCCI reporters in individual cells throughout embryogenesis. This allowed for the systematic mapping of cell cycle phases at a cellular level.
  • RNA interference (RNAi): Used to functionally validate the degradation pathways of the FUCCI reporters and to perturb cell cycle progression (e.g., by inactivating ddb-1 or fzr-1), confirming the reporters' accuracy.

Datasets

The study did not explicitly train models on large datasets or introduce new benchmark datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, the primary "dataset" generated and analyzed was:

  • Live-imaging data of C. elegans embryos: Time-lapse 3D confocal microscopy data capturing the expression dynamics of the Worm-FUCCI reporters and histone::GFP (for lineage tracing) in developing embryos. This data was collected from multiple embryos under various experimental conditions (wild-type, RNAi treatments).

The authors also referenced and utilized existing quality control cell lists and developmental stage atlases for C. elegans embryogenesis to standardize their analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Most embryonic cells skip gap phases: The most striking finding is that the vast majority of C. elegans embryonic cells appear to divide without distinct G1 or G2 phases. This challenges the assumption that a full cell cycle is the norm during early development.
  • Gap phases are rare and specific: The introduction of recognizable G1 and G2 phases is a highly specific event, observed only in a few cell pairs with significantly extended cell cycle durations, particularly those dividing late in embryogenesis.
  • Worm-FUCCI as a powerful tool: The developed Worm-FUCCI reporters are highly effective in demarcating cell cycle phases, especially in distinguishing G1 from S/G2/M, and are crucial for this initial mapping.
  • Cell cycle exit vs. G1/G0: The CDT1 reporter reliably indicates cell cycle exit (arrest in G0 or G1) after the last embryonic division, providing a clear marker for cells entering a quiescent state.
  • Asynchronous divisions driven by S/G2 phase duration: Division asymmetries between sister cells are primarily attributed to differential durations of the S or G2 phases, rather than G1, as G1 phase accumulation is largely absent.

Key Results

  • Identification of two cells with full cell cycles: The study identified a specific pair of cells, "V5QL" and "V5QR" (derived from ABplapapaa and ABprapapaa), that exhibit clear G1, S, and G2 phases during their final embryonic division, as indicated by the complementary and sequential accumulation of CDT-1D and CYB-1D reporters.
  • Most cells arrest in G0/G1: Following their last embryonic division, most cells accumulate CDT-1D, signifying arrest in G0 or G1 phase.
  • Intestine precursors show G2 phase: Intestine precursor cells ("E2" and "E4") were found to accumulate both CDT-1D and CYB-1D simultaneously, indicating the introduction of a G2 phase in these specific lineages.
  • RNAi validation confirms reporter function: Knockdown of ddb-1 (involved in CDT1 degradation) led to premature and robust CDT1D accumulation, confirming its S-phase-specific degradation. Similarly, fzr-1 RNAi affected CYB1D degradation, validating its role in G2/M phase dynamics.
  • Postembryonic development shows varied dynamics: Worm-FUCCI also demonstrated accumulation dynamics in postembryonic tissues like the germline and intestine, suggesting its utility beyond embryogenesis, though germline reporter behavior was noted as discordant.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited temporal resolution for short G1 phases: The maturation time of mCherry and the degradation kinetics of CYB-1D limit the detection of very short G1 phases (potentially 10-20 minutes). The authors suggest using faster-maturing fluorescent proteins like mRFP1 or mNeonGreen for future studies.
  • Germline reporter discordance: The CYB-1-based reporters showed discordant accumulation patterns in the germline, making them unsuitable for deducing cell cycle progression in this tissue.
  • Promoter limitations for germline progenitors: The his-72 promoter was insufficient for driving zygotic expression in germline progenitors (P4, Z2, Z3), hindering the analysis of their cell cycle progression. Future work would require promoters that can drive expression in these specific cell types.
  • Distinguishing G1 from G0: The current FUCCI system cannot differentiate between G1 and G0 phases. The authors point to recently developed CDK sensors as a potential solution for this.
  • Future Directions: The authors envision the Worm-FUCCI strains as invaluable resources for studying the coordination between cell cycle progression and cell fate differentiation, as well as for mechanistic research into endoreplication in postembryonic tissues. Further refinement of reporters for better temporal resolution and tissue-specific expression will be crucial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Early embryonic cell cycles usually alternate between S and M phases without any gap phase. When the gap phases are developmentally introduced in various cell types remains poorly defined especially during embryogenesis. To establish the cell-specific introduction of gap phases in embryo, we generate multiple fluorescence ubiquitin cell cycle indicators (FUCCI) in <i>C. elegans</i>. Time-lapse 3D imaging followed by lineal expression profiling reveals sharp and differential accumulation of the FUCCI reporters, allowing the systematic demarcation of cell cycle phases throughout embryogenesis. Accumulation of the reporters reliably identifies both G1 and G2 phases only in two embryonic cells with an extended cell cycle length, suggesting that the remaining cells divide either without a G1 phase, or with a brief G1 phase that is too short to be picked up by our reporters. In summary, we provide an initial picture of gap phase introduction in a metazoan embryo. The newly developed FUCCI reporters pave the way for further characterization of developmental control of cell cycle progression.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wong2022initial,
  author = {Ming‐Kin Wong and Vincy Wing Sze Ho and Xiaotai Huang and Lu-yan Chan and Dongying Xie and Runsheng Li and Xiaoliang Ren and Guoye Guan and Yiming Ma and Boyi Hu and Hong Yan and Zhongying Zhao},
  title = {{Initial characterization of gap phase introduction in every cell cycle of C. elegans embryogenesis}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Cell and Developmental Biology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fcell.2022.978962},
}
Figure