inite element simulation, safety assessment and countermeasure of the coke drum leaning process during the quenching stage

Zhengliang Li, He-Hui Wang, Wei Liu, Jin-sHui Zhou, Guangquan Zhang2017 · DOI

Introduction

In the petroleum refining industry, delayed coking units are essential for converting heavy residual oils into higher-value products. The coke drums used in this process are massive vertical pressure vessels that endure extreme thermal cycling. During operation, these vessels are heated to approximately 500°C as they fill with coke and are subsequently rapidly cooled, or quenched, with water.

A persistent and costly challenge in refinery maintenance is the tendency of these drums to tilt, bulge, and develop structural cracks, particularly in their support skirts. While traditional research has often assumed uniform cooling through a central channel, this model fails to explain the erratic leaning and "swaying" observed in the field. This study utilizes Finite Element Analysis (FEA) to investigate how non-uniform water flow through "branched channels" creates localized cold spots, driving structural instability and premature failure.

Numerical Simulation Methodology

The researchers employed ANSYS software to perform a transient thermal-structural analysis using an indirect coupling method. In this approach, the transient temperature field during the 3.5-hour quenching stage is solved first. These thermal results are then applied as loading conditions for a subsequent structural stress analysis.

Modeling Innovation: The Branched Channel

A critical departure from standard models is the introduction of a branched channel coke model. Traditional simulations often assume a single, centered water channel. However, real-world coke—especially "needle coke" with its porous structure—facilitates irregular water paths.

Comparison of standard (a) and branched channel (b) models alongside the drum structural schematic.

The study utilized 20-node 3D solid elements (Solid186 for thermal, Solid90 for structural) to model a drum with a height of 23,888 mm and a diameter of 4,850 mm. The model accounts for the base layer of 14Cr1MoR low alloy steel, stainless steel cladding (TP410S), and the Q345R steel support skirt. Boundary conditions included internal pressure, gravitational forces, and the hydrostatic pressure of the internal coke-water mixture.

Key Insights: The "Cold Spot" Phenomenon

The simulation revealed that branched channels allow water to reach the drum shell unevenly. This creates localized "cold spots" where the shell cools significantly faster than the surrounding material. The resulting massive thermal gradient induces bending stresses that force the drum to lean toward the cooler side.

The analysis highlights that the type of coke significantly influences this behavior. Porous needle coke promotes more irregular branching than compact asphalt coke, leading to more severe tilting. In the simulation, the branched channel model predicted a tilt of 31 mm, whereas the traditional middle-channel model showed no tilt at all.

Safety Assessment and Countermeasures

The most critical area of concern identified is the skirt seat—the transition zone where the drum is supported. As the drum tilts, this area experiences intense membrane stress. The study found that under tilting conditions, stress levels reach 403 MPa, which exceeds the yield strength of the Q345R skirt material. This explains why cracks frequently appear in this region long before the drum's theoretical design life ends.

To mitigate this, the researchers proposed a reinforcement arc plate design. By adding these stiffening plates to the skirt, the simulation showed a dramatic reduction in membrane stress from 403 MPa to 219 MPa, effectively bringing the vessel back into a safe operating regime.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This FEA study provides a robust explanation for the "mysterious" leaning of coke drums during quenching. By accounting for non-uniform cooling through branched channels, engineers can better predict "dangerous states" and implement structural reinforcements like arc plates to extend vessel life.

While the simulation successfully captured the mechanism of tilting, a discrepancy remains between the predicted 31 mm tilt and real-world observations of up to 160 mm. Future work will focus on integrating the mechanical behavior of foundation bolts, which may loosen over time due to cumulative thermal cycling, further exacerbating the lean.

Summary updated

Abstract

The coke drum with a side channel at the beginning of cooling was simulated numerically using ANYSY, and the time history of the stress and strain fields were also acquired with indirect coupling method. The calculation results indicate that temperature stress and bending stress caused by the cold spots will cause bulging of the shell and the tilt of coke drum. With the coke drum tilting, the shell at the skirt seat will yield and the coke drum was in a dangerous state. The results of ANSYS show that the reinforcement of arc plate can effectively reduce the membrane stress on the skirt. The side channel and reinforcement of arc plate serve as the analysis for coke drum leaning and design of the skirt seat.
BibTeX
@misc{li2017inite,
  author = {Zhengliang Li and He-Hui Wang and Wei Liu and Jin-sHui Zhou and Guangquan Zhang},
  title = {{inite element simulation, safety assessment and countermeasure of the coke drum leaning process during the quenching stage}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.2991/amcce-17.2017.94},
}
Figure