Inhibition of autotrophic nitrifiers in soil by elevated CO2

Lei Cheng, Kaihang Zhang, Weilei Lei, Huixin Zhang, Chenchao Xu, Jing Xiao, Shuyao Li, Maojun Liang, Junpan He, Yancen Lai, Ruiyang Li, Jiahua Dong, Mingkai Jiang, Jianguo Zhu, Shui-jin Hu, Roger T. Koide, Mary K. FirestoneResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Contrary to the expectation that autotrophic microbes thrive under higher carbon dioxide levels, a 15-year study reveals that elevated $\text{CO}_2$ actually inhibits soil nitrifiers in rice paddies. By increasing soil anoxic stress, elevated $\text{CO}_2$ suppresses dominant, previously uncharacterized nitrifying species, leading to a significant depletion of inorganic nitrogen pools in wetland ecosystems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autotrophic nitrifiers are the "engine room" of the nitrogen cycle, converting ammonia into nitrate. Because these microbes use $\text{CO}_2$ as their primary carbon source, scientists long assumed that rising atmospheric $\text{CO}_2$ ($\text{eCO}_2$) would act as a fertilizer, boosting their growth and activity.

However, real-world observations have been frustratingly inconsistent. This paper addresses this "perplexing inconsistency" by investigating why $\text{eCO}_2$ often fails to stimulate—and sometimes actively harms—nitrifier communities in lowland soil systems like rice paddies. Understanding this is critical for predicting how future climate scenarios will affect global food security and nitrogen runoff.

Methods

The researchers utilized a multi-pronged approach combining long-term field experiments with high-resolution molecular biology:

  • FACE Experiment: They used a 15-year Free-Air $\text{CO}_2$ Enrichment (FACE) site in a rice paddy system, comparing ambient $\text{CO}_2$ ($\text{aCO}_2$) to plots with +200 µmol/mol $\text{CO}_2$.
  • DNA-SIP (Stable Isotope Probing): This is the study's "secret sauce." By feeding the soil $^{13}\text{C}$-labeled $\text{CO}_2$, they could physically separate the DNA of microbes that were actively growing and "eating" the $\text{CO}_2$ from those that were dormant.
  • Metagenomics: They reconstructed 2,603 Metagenome-Assembled Genomes (MAGs), allowing them to identify 19 dominant nitrifying species, 17 of which were previously uncharacterized by science.
  • Microcosm Manipulations: To isolate the cause of inhibition, they conducted lab experiments varying nitrogen levels and oxygen availability.

Datasets

  • Field Data: Five years (2014–2018) of 16S rRNA sequencing and qPCR data from the FACE site.
  • Genomic Benchmarks: 19 newly identified nitrifying MAGs (including Ammonia-Oxidizing Archaea (AOA), Ammonia-Oxidizing Bacteria (AOB), and Nitrite-Oxidizing Bacteria (NOB)).
  • Meta-analysis: A synthesis of 307 observations from 28 independent experiments worldwide to validate if the decline in nitrogen pools is a global phenomenon in wetlands.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Oxygen Paradox: The "aha moment" is that the inhibition isn't about the carbon; it's about the oxygen. $\text{eCO}_2$ stimulates other soil processes (like root growth and anaerobic respiration) that consume oxygen and lower the soil's redox potential. This creates "anoxic stress" that suffocates nitrifiers.
  • Vulnerability of the "Unknown": The study found that the nitrifiers most affected were novel, uncharacterized species. These dominant but sensitive microbes lacked the genetic tools (like the fnr anaerobic regulator) to survive the increased anoxic stress caused by $\text{eCO}_2$.
  • Functional Extinction: In $\text{eCO}_2$ conditions, the researchers couldn't even recover the genomes of certain AOA species that were thriving under ambient conditions. This suggests that rising $\text{CO}_2$ could lead to the functional extinction of key microbial players in specific ecosystems.

Key Results

  • Community Decline: $\text{eCO}_2$ reduced the relative abundance of autotrophic nitrifiers by an average of 27%.
  • Absolute Numbers: qPCR showed a decline in absolute abundance for AOB (24.6%), AOA (16.1%), and NOB (17.1%) under $\text{eCO}_2$.
  • Nitrogen Depletion: A meta-analysis confirmed that $\text{eCO}_2$ tends to deplete inorganic nitrogen pools ($\text{NH}_4^+$-N and $\text{NO}_3^-$-N) by approximately 18% in rice paddies and wetlands.
  • Genetic Adaptation: Species that did survive under $\text{eCO}_2$ were found to possess specific genes (like hemN and nirK) that allow for anaerobic respiration, confirming that low oxygen is the primary selective pressure.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that these findings are specific to lowland/wetland systems where oxygen is already a limiting factor. In well-aerated upland soils, $\text{eCO}_2$ might still have a stimulatory effect.

Future research is needed to determine how this "adaptive loss of function" in the soil microbiome will impact long-term ecosystem stability. Specifically, if nitrifiers are outcompeted by denitrifiers, we may see a gradual depletion of nitrate in global water systems, potentially leading to a "nitrogen crisis" reminiscent of early Earth history.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Autotrophic nitrifiers, by catalyzing the oxidation of ammonia to nitrate, play a vital role in the global nitrogen cycle <sup>1–5</sup>. They convert carbon dioxide (CO<sub>2</sub>) into biomass <sup>1,3,6</sup> and, therefore, are expected to respond positively to increasing atmospheric CO<sub>2</sub> concentrations <sup>1,3,6</sup>. However, in a long-term free-air CO<sub>2</sub> enrichment experiment, we demonstrated that elevated atmospheric CO<sub>2</sub> inhibited the growth of autotrophic nitrifiers, resulting in a reduction in nitrification in a rice ecosystem. By coupling stable isotope probing with metagenomics, we found that the CO<sub>2</sub> inhibition of nitrifiers was mainly a consequence of CO<sub>2</sub>-induced functional loss (that is, incapable of recovering genomes) of dominant but previously uncharacterized autotrophic nitrifying species, especially those of ammonia-oxidizing archaea and nitrite-oxidizing bacteria, which comprised 63% of total dominant members identified from the active nitrifying communities. We further found that the loss of these novel nitrifying species under elevated CO<sub>2</sub> was due largely to the CO<sub>2</sub>-induced aggravation of anoxic stress in the paddy soil. Our results provide insight into the fate of inorganic nitrogen pools in global lowland soil and water systems under future climate change scenarios.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2024inhibition,
  author = {Lei Cheng and Kaihang Zhang and Weilei Lei and Huixin Zhang and Chenchao Xu and Jing Xiao and Shuyao Li and Maojun Liang and Junpan He and Yancen Lai and Ruiyang Li and Jiahua Dong and Mingkai Jiang and Jianguo Zhu and Shui-jin Hu and Roger T. Koide and Mary K. Firestone},
  title = {{Inhibition of autotrophic nitrifiers in soil by elevated CO2}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3746946/v1},
}

Loading related content...

Figure