Inhibition characteristics research of aluminum alloy polishing dust explosion through addition of ultrafine Al(OH)3 inerting agent

Chen Lv, Xinqun Wang, Sheng Xue, Xinxing Xia, Shuang WangHeliyon 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the dust explosion characteristics of aluminum alloy polishing waste and demonstrates that adding ultrafine aluminum hydroxide (Al(OH)₃) significantly reduces its explosion sensitivity and flame propagation. The findings highlight that polishing waste is inherently less explosive than high-purity aluminum dust, and Al(OH)₃ offers a practical and effective inerting solution for safer industrial operations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aluminum alloy die-casting and finishing processes, particularly grinding and polishing, generate significant amounts of dust. This dust, especially when it's aluminum alloy waste, poses a serious explosion hazard, as evidenced by past industrial accidents. While research has focused on pure aluminum dust explosions, aluminum alloy polishing waste, often containing impurities and having different particle morphologies, exhibits distinct explosion characteristics. Existing safety assessments for these operations may not accurately reflect the risks if they rely solely on data from high-purity aluminum dust. Therefore, there's a critical need to understand the specific explosion behavior of aluminum alloy polishing waste and to develop effective, practical prevention and control measures.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged experimental approach:

  1. Standardized Hartmann Tester: This apparatus was used to determine the minimum ignition energy (MIE) and lower explosion limit (LEL) of the dust samples.
  2. Developed Experimental Platform: This setup, featuring a flame propagation tube, dust dispersion device, high-speed camera, and data acquisition system, was used to observe and quantify flame propagation characteristics, including velocity and flame structure.

They tested both high-purity aluminum dust and aluminum alloy polishing waste dust. The core of their investigation involved systematically adding ultrafine Al(OH)₃ powder as an inerting agent at varying concentrations (inerting ratios) to the polishing waste dust and observing the impact on explosion parameters. Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) was used to analyze the morphology of the dust particles, providing insights into their structural differences.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary types of dust samples:

  • Aluminum alloy polishing waste dust: Collected from a real-world industrial site.
  • High-purity aluminum dust: Used for comparative analysis, with a similar mean particle diameter to the polishing waste.

The ultrafine Al(OH)₃ powder served as the inerting agent. No specific benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study focused on characterizing the behavior of these specific materials under controlled experimental conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Polishing Waste is Less Explosive: A key finding is that aluminum alloy polishing waste dust is significantly less prone to ignition and explosion than high-purity aluminum dust. This is attributed to its lower combustion activity, likely due to impurities and its fibrous particle structure, which hinders optimal contact with oxygen.
  • Morphology Matters: SEM analysis revealed that the spherical, folded, and well-dispersed particles of high-purity aluminum dust facilitate better air contact and larger surface area compared to the smooth, fibrous particles of polishing waste. This structural difference is a primary driver of their differing explosion sensitivities.
  • Al(OH)₃ is an Effective Inerting Agent: Ultrafine Al(OH)₃ powder proved to be a highly effective inerting agent for aluminum alloy polishing waste. Even at moderate concentrations, it significantly increased the MIE and LEL, and at 30% inerting ratio, it rendered the dust virtually non-explosive, preventing self-sustained flame propagation.
  • Inappropriate to Extrapolate Data: The stark differences in explosion characteristics mean that using high-purity aluminum dust data for risk assessment in aluminum alloy polishing operations is misleading and potentially dangerous.

Key Results

  • Minimum Ignition Energy (MIE): High-purity aluminum dust had an MIE of 40-45 mJ, while aluminum alloy polishing waste dust had an MIE of 500-550 mJ – an order of magnitude higher. With 30% Al(OH)₃, the polishing waste MIE increased to approximately 1 J.
  • Lower Explosion Limit (LEL): The LEL for high-purity aluminum dust was 80 g/m³, whereas for polishing waste, it was 150 g/m³. With 30% Al(OH)₃, the polishing waste LEL increased to 190 g/m³.
  • Flame Propagation Velocity: The peak flame propagation velocity for polishing waste dust was 7.368 m/s at 300 g/m³, which is about 56.85% of that for high-purity aluminum dust. Increasing Al(OH)₃ concentration progressively reduced this velocity.
  • Flame Structure: The addition of Al(OH)₃ disrupted the flame structure, leading to more discrete and discontinuous flame propagation, especially at higher inerting ratios.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their current study focused on flame propagation within a pipeline. They suggest that future research should incorporate the measurement of explosion pressure, which is a critical metric for assessing explosive strength in confined spaces. They plan to improve their experimental apparatus by adding pressure sensors to capture transient explosion pressure signals and further investigate the influence of dust concentration and particle size on explosion pressure propagation with Al(OH)₃ inerting. Additionally, while the study demonstrates the effectiveness of Al(OH)₃, its long-term impact on the recycled waste material and potential environmental considerations were not deeply explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

Investigations into the deactivation of explosion sensitivity and reduction of flame propagation for aluminium alloy polishing wastes were carried out by the addition of ultrafine Al(OH)<sub>3</sub> inerting agent. Meanwhile, high-purity aluminium powders with similar mean diameters were also used as a comparative study. The explosion propagation characteristics of high-purity aluminium dust and aluminium alloy polishing waste dust under different inerting ratios (<mml:math xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML"><mml:mrow><mml:mi>ε</mml:mi></mml:mrow></mml:math>) were tested and investigated using a standardised Hartmann tester and a developed experimental platform. The results show that the minimum ignition energy of high-purity aluminium powder is between 40 and 45 mJ, and the minimum ignition energy of aluminium alloy polishing waste is between 500 and 550 mJ, which is one order of magnitude higher than that of high-purity aluminium powder. The lower explosion limit concentration of aluminium alloy polishing waste dust is 150 g/m<sup>3</sup>, which is 53.33% of that of high-purity aluminium powder. According to the analysis of the SEM image, the main reason is that the spherical particles of high-purity aluminium dust have a folded surface and good dispersion. Compared with the smooth fibre surface of aluminium alloy polishing waste dust, the former is easier to contact with air and the contact area is larger. Therefore, in engineering practice, it is not appropriate to use high-purity aluminium dust-related explosion parameters as the basis for the risk assessment of combustion and explosion at aluminium alloy polishing work sites. In addition, as the dust concentration decreases, the combustion intensity of high-purity aluminium dust and aluminium alloy polishing waste dust also decreases, and the flame propagation appears to be a discontinuous phenomenon. The peak flame propagation velocity of aluminium alloy polishing waste is 7.368 m/s at a concentration of 300 g/m<sup>3</sup>, which is 56.85% of that of high-purity aluminium powder. As the inerting ratio increases, the propagation velocity of the explosion flame slows down. When the inerting ratio reaches 30%, the minimum ignition energy of aluminium alloy polishing waste is inerted to 1 J, and self-sustained flame propagation cannot be formed. The results show that the ultra-fine Al(OH)<sub>3</sub> powder has a significant inerting effect and is a realistic possibility in the production of aluminium alloy polishing.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lv2023inhibition,
  author = {Chen Lv and Xinqun Wang and Sheng Xue and Xinxing Xia and Shuang Wang},
  title = {{Inhibition characteristics research of aluminum alloy polishing dust explosion through addition of ultrafine Al(OH)3 inerting agent}},
  booktitle = {Heliyon},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e19747},
}
Figure