Infused ice can multiply IceCube’s sensitivity

I. Bartos, Zsuzsa Márka, Szabolcs MárkaNature Communications 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers propose infusing IceCube's deep ice drill holes with a high-refractive-index material and wavelength-shifting (WLS) substrate to dramatically boost the detector's sensitivity. This "infused ice" could increase photon detection efficiency by up to 100% for every 0.05 increase in refractive index, paving the way for a more cost-effective and powerful IceCube-Gen2.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The IceCube Neutrino Observatory, a cubic-kilometer detector at the South Pole, is a crucial instrument for studying high-energy cosmic neutrinos. However, to pinpoint the sources of these elusive particles and explore new astrophysical phenomena, IceCube needs a significant upgrade to its sensitivity. The proposed IceCube-Gen2 aims to achieve this, and a key challenge is enhancing the efficiency of photon detection within the detector's vast volume of ice. Specifically, the paper addresses how to maximize the collection of Cherenkov light produced by neutrinos interacting in the ice, which is currently limited by the optical properties of the ice and the sensitivity of the detector's optical modules (DOMs).

Methods

The authors investigate two primary modifications to the ice within IceCube's drill holes:

  • Increasing the Refractive Index: They model the effect of increasing the refractive index of the ice within the drill holes. This change alters how light refracts as it enters the hole, potentially guiding more photons towards the DOMs.
  • Infusing Wavelength-Shifting (WLS) Material: They explore the use of WLS materials that absorb UV Cherenkov photons (which are more abundant) and re-emit them at visible wavelengths where the DOMs are most sensitive. This process also involves considering the efficiency of conversion and the re-emission angle.

The study employs a combination of analytical calculations and numerical simulations to quantify the resulting "DOM sensitivity enhancement." This enhancement is defined as the fractional increase in the photon flux reaching the DOMs for a fixed flux outside the drill holes. They also analyze the temporal delay introduced by the WLS process, which is crucial for accurate event reconstruction.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical modeling and simulations based on known IceCube parameters and optical properties of ice and WLS materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Infused Ice as a WLS System: The core innovation is treating the drill holes themselves as integrated optical components, rather than just passive conduits for light.
  • Synergy of Refractive Index and WLS: The combination of increased refractive index and WLS material offers a synergistic boost in sensitivity, with WLS being the dominant factor.
  • Optimal WLS Infusion: The study suggests an optimal configuration of approximately 94% WLS infusion within the drill holes, leaving a small WLS-free region around each DOM.
  • Directional Dependence: Sensitivity enhancement is not uniform across all angles; WLS is most effective for photons arriving at more horizontal angles, while increased refractive index alone favors more vertical angles.
  • Temporal Delay Trade-off: While WLS significantly boosts sensitivity, it also introduces a temporal delay in photon arrival, which needs to be accounted for in event reconstruction.

Key Results

  • Significant Sensitivity Boost: An increase of just 0.05 in the ice's refractive index, combined with adequate WLS infusion, can lead to a 100% increase in IceCube's DOM sensitivity.
  • WLS Dominance: The majority of the sensitivity enhancement (around 75%) comes from the WLS effect, with the remaining 25% attributed to the increased refractive index.
  • Optimal Infusion: The study finds that filling 94% of the drill hole with WLS material provides the most significant enhancement.
  • Temporal Delay: The characteristic temporal delay introduced by WLS is estimated to be around 84 ns, which is significant but manageable for event reconstruction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Approximations and Simplifications: The calculations involve approximations, such as assuming uniform vertical flux distribution for re-emitted light and neglecting absorption/scattering effects in the WLS material itself.
  • Feasibility of Infusion: The practical challenges of uniformly infusing large volumes of ice with WLS material at the South Pole need further investigation, including the required concentration and potential environmental impacts.
  • Additives and Radioactivity: Identifying suitable additives that increase refractive index and enable WLS without introducing significant radioactivity is crucial.
  • DOM Design Impact: The increased refractive index of the infused ice might affect the focusing properties of the DOMs' pressure vessels, requiring consideration in future DOM designs.
  • Directional Dependence Nuances: The directional sensitivity enhancement needs to be carefully considered in relation to neutrino interaction types (cascade vs. track events) and their corresponding Cherenkov emission angles.
  • Experimental Verification: The proposed methods require experimental validation, potentially leveraging new drilling technologies like RAID.

Summary updated

Abstract

The IceCube Neutrino Observatory is the world's largest neutrino detector with a cubic-kilometer instrumented volume at the South Pole. It is preparing for a major upgrade that will significantly increase its sensitivity. A promising technological innovation investigated for this upgrade is wavelength shifting optics. Augmenting sensors with such optics could increase the photo-collection area of IceCube's digital optical modules, and shift the incoming photons' wavelength to where these modules are the most sensitive. Here we investigate the use of IceCube's drill holes as wavelength shifting optics. We calculate the sensitivity enhancement due to increasing the ice's refractive index in the holes, and infusing wavelength-shifting substrate into the ice. We find that, with adequate wavelength-shifter infusion, every ~0.05 increase in the ice's refractive index will increase IceCube's photon sensitivity by 100%, opening the possibility for the substantial, cost-effective expansion of IceCube's reach.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bartos2018infused,
  author = {I. Bartos and Zsuzsa Márka and Szabolcs Márka},
  title = {{Infused ice can multiply IceCube’s sensitivity}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-03693-z},
}
Figure