Information topology identifies emergent model classes

Mark K. Transtrum, Gus L. W. Hart, Peng QiuarXiv 2014 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We develop a language for describing the relationship among observations, mathematical models, and the underlying principles from which they are derived. Using Information Geometry, we consider geometric properties of statistical models for different observations. As observations are varied, the model manifold may be stretched, compressed, or even collapsed. Observations that preserve the structural identifiability of the parameters also preserve certain topological features (such as edges and corners) that characterize the model's underlying physical principles. We introduce Information Topology in analogy with information geometry as characterizing the "abstract model" of which statistical models are realizations. Observations that change the topology, i.e., "manifold collapse," require a modification of the abstract model in order to construct identifiable statistical models. Often, the essential topological feature is a hierarchical structure of boundaries (faces, edges, corners, etc.) which we represent as a hierarchical graph known as a Hasse diagram. Low-dimensional elements of this diagram are simple models that describe the dominant behavioral modes, what we call emergent model classes. Observations that preserve the Hasse diagram are diffeomorphically related and form a group, the collection of which form a partially ordered set. All possible observations have a semi-group structure. For hierarchical models, we consider how the topology of simple models is embedded in that of larger models. When emergent model classes are unstable to the introduction of new parameters, we classify the new parameters as relevant. Conversely, the emergent model classes are stable to the introduction of irrelevant parameters. In this way, information topology provides a general language for exploring representations of physical systems and their relationships to observations.

Introduction: The Challenge of Sloppy Models

In fields ranging from systems biology to materials science, researchers often grapple with "sloppy" models—complex systems where many parameter combinations have little to no effect on the model's output. This creates a significant gap between the microscopic "rules" of a system and the macroscopic "behaviors" we actually observe. While Information Geometry helps us understand the "distance" between model predictions, it doesn't fully explain why certain simple models, such as the Michaelis-Menten equation in chemistry, emerge so consistently from much more complex underlying machinery. This paper introduces Information Topology, a framework that explains how complex mathematical models simplify into "emergent" classes based on the act of observation.

Methodology: From Geometry to Topology

The authors build upon Information Geometry, which treats a statistical model as a manifold (a multi-dimensional surface) embedded in the space of all possible data outcomes. The Fisher Information Matrix (FIM) is used as a metric to define the "shape" of this manifold.

The conceptual relationship between abstract models (topology) and statistical models (geometry).

A key distinction is made between the Abstract Model and the Statistical Model. The Abstract Model represents the underlying physical rules and is characterized by its topology—structural features like edges and corners. The Statistical Model is a specific realization based on experimental conditions, which define the metric and statistical distances on that manifold. When observations are "coarsened" (e.g., measuring the sum of two variables instead of each individually), the manifold may fold or compress, revealing which parameters are truly "identifiable."

Emergent Model Classes and Hasse Diagrams

The core of the framework involves identifying Manifold Boundaries. These are the limits where parameters go to zero or infinity, representing simpler, "reduced" versions of the full model. The authors represent the hierarchy of these boundaries (faces, edges, corners) as a directed graph known as a Hasse diagram.

A model manifold showing the hierarchical structure of its boundaries, which correspond to emergent model classes.

The top of the Hasse diagram represents the full, complex model, while the bottom nodes represent the simplest possible "emergent" behaviors. These simple, effective theories (like thermodynamics) are not just lucky guesses; they are the low-dimensional "corners" of the manifold that represent dominant behavioral modes stable even when microscopic details vary.

Key Results and Physical Analogies

  • Michaelis-Menten Emergence: The framework shows that the Michaelis-Menten rate law is a natural node in the Hasse diagram of complex enzyme-substrate models, emerging when the manifold collapses due to specific observational limits.
  • Relevant vs. Irrelevant Parameters: Borrowing from Renormalization Group (RG) theory in physics, the authors define relevant parameters as those that make an emergent model class unstable when added. Irrelevant parameters are those to which the emergent class remains stable.
  • Observation Semi-groups: The set of all possible observations is shown to have a semi-group structure, where specific subgroups preserve the model's underlying topology.

Conclusion and Future Directions

Information Topology provides a formal language for model reduction, turning massive simulations into lean, predictive effective theories. While the current work focuses on theoretical models like Ising spin chains and cluster expansions, the framework is potentially applicable to any field using statistical modeling, including economics or climate science. Future work will focus on scaling these methods to high-dimensional systems where constructing full Hasse diagrams is computationally prohibitive, perhaps by identifying single paths down the graph to find useful approximations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We develop a language for describing the relationship among observations, mathematical models, and the underlying principles from which they are derived. Using Information Geometry, we consider geometric properties of statistical models for different observations. As observations are varied, the model manifold may be stretched, compressed, or even collapsed. Observations that preserve the structural identifiability of the parameters also preserve certain topological features (such as edges and corners) that characterize the model's underlying physical principles. We introduce Information Topology in analogy with information geometry as characterizing the "abstract model" of which statistical models are realizations. Observations that change the topology, i.e., "manifold collapse," require a modification of the abstract model in order to construct identifiable statistical models. Often, the essential topological feature is a hierarchical structure of boundaries (faces, edges, corners, etc.) which we represent as a hierarchical graph known as a Hasse diagram. Low-dimensional elements of this diagram are simple models that describe the dominant behavioral modes, what we call emergent model classes. Observations that preserve the Hasse diagram are diffeomorphically related and form a group, the collection of which form a partially ordered set. All possible observations have a semi-group structure. For hierarchical models, we consider how the topology of simple models is embedded in that of larger models. When emergent model classes are unstable to the introduction of new parameters, we classify the new parameters as relevant. Conversely, the emergent model classes are stable to the introduction of irrelevant parameters. In this way, information topology provides a general language for exploring representations of physical systems and their relationships to observations.
BibTeX
@misc{transtrum2014information,
  author = {Mark K. Transtrum and Gus L. W. Hart and Peng Qiu},
  title = {{Information topology identifies emergent model classes}},
  year = {2014},
  eprint = {1409.6203},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1409.6203},
}
Figure