Information theoretic bounds for compressed sensing

Shuchin Aeron, Venkatesh Saligrama, Manqi ZhaoIEEE Trans. Information Theory 2010 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper establishes fundamental information-theoretic limits on how well we can recover sparse signals from noisy measurements. It provides tight bounds on the number of measurements and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) needed for accurate recovery, distinguishing between "worst-case" and "average-case" (Bayesian) scenarios, and revealing crucial trade-offs between measurement count, SNR, and recovery accuracy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Compressed Sensing (CS) is a powerful technique that allows us to recover sparse signals (signals with many zero components) from far fewer measurements than traditionally thought necessary. However, real-world scenarios involve noise, and the signal's sparsity isn't always perfectly known. This paper delves into the fundamental limits of CS, asking: how many measurements and what SNR are truly required to recover a sparse signal accurately, especially when noise is present? The authors consider two main challenges:

  1. Noise Models: Noise can enter the system either after the signal is measured (output noise) or before it's measured (input noise). These different noise models can significantly impact recovery performance.
  2. Distortion Metrics: We might care about recovering the exact support (which components are non-zero) or the exact values of the non-zero components (mean-squared error). The paper addresses both.

The core problem is to precisely quantify the relationship between the signal's dimension ($n$), its sparsity ($k$), the number of measurements ($m$), the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), and the acceptable level of distortion.

Methods

The authors employ a combination of information-theoretic tools and statistical analysis:

  • Fano's Inequality: This is a cornerstone for deriving necessary conditions. By adapting Fano's inequality to handle continuous domains and arbitrary distortions, they establish lower bounds on the required number of measurements and SNR.
  • Maximum Likelihood (ML) Analysis: For deriving sufficient conditions, they develop a novel ML analysis. A key insight is that small support errors are often the dominant error events, allowing for a tighter analysis than traditional union bounds.
  • Rate-Distortion Theory: To characterize trade-offs between distortion and the number of measurements in an average-case (Bayesian) setting, they leverage rate-distortion theory. This involves defining "sensing capacity" and analyzing minimal covering properties of rate-distortion functions.
  • Worst-Case vs. Bayesian Analysis: The paper explicitly contrasts these two frameworks. Worst-case analysis considers the most challenging signal realization, leading to more stringent requirements. Bayesian analysis averages over signal distributions, often yielding more optimistic (and practical) results.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical bounds and analysis rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SNR is Crucial, Even for Sparse Signals: Even for sparse signals, recovering the exact support requires an SNR that scales logarithmically with the signal dimension ($O(\log n)$) in the output noise model. This is a fundamental limit, not just an artifact of a specific algorithm.
  • Input Noise is More Challenging: Input noise significantly degrades performance. Support recovery fails if the number of measurements doesn't scale almost linearly with the signal dimension, effectively negating the benefits of compression.
  • Trade-offs Emerge in the Bayesian Setting: When considering average-case performance (Bayesian), a constant SNR can be sufficient for recovery if some level of distortion is tolerated. This highlights a crucial difference from the worst-case scenario.
  • Rate-Distortion Theory Unlocks Measurement-Distortion Trade-offs: By using rate-distortion theory, the authors show that in the Bayesian setting, the number of measurements can scale linearly with the rate-distortion function, allowing for a direct trade-off between the number of measurements and the acceptable distortion.
  • Novel ML Analysis for Tighter Bounds: The insight that small support errors dominate the error landscape allows for a more precise ML analysis, leading to order-wise tight bounds that are less conservative than those obtained using traditional union bounds.

Key Results

  • Output Noise Model (Worst-Case):
    • Necessity: For exact support recovery, SNR must be at least $\Omega(\log n)$. The number of measurements $m$ must be at least $\Omega(k \log(n/k))$.
  • Sufficiency: With SNR = $\Omega(\log n)$ and $m = \Omega(k \log(n/k))$, exact support recovery is possible with high probability using ML.
  • Approximate Recovery: A constant SNR is sufficient if a constant fraction of support errors is tolerated.
  • Input Noise Model (Worst-Case):
    • Support recovery fails if $m = o(n \log(n) / \text{SNR})$. This implies that meaningful compression is difficult in this regime.
  • Bayesian Setting:
    • The number of measurements scales linearly with the rate-distortion function for a given SNR, allowing for trade-offs between measurements and distortion.
  • Constant SNR is sufficient for recovery with some distortion.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Worst-Case vs. Average-Case: The paper highlights that worst-case analysis can be overly pessimistic, especially regarding the need for a well-conditioned sensing matrix (non-zero minimum singular values of sub-matrices). Bayesian analysis relaxes this requirement.
  • Complexity of Bounds: While the bounds are order-wise tight, the exact constants and dependencies can be complex, especially in the Bayesian setting involving rate-distortion functions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest exploring the trade-offs between measurements and distortion in more detail, particularly in the Bayesian setting. They also point out that the analysis for input noise models raises questions about the practicality of certain sensor network compression schemes. The paper lays the groundwork for understanding these trade-offs more deeply.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we derive information theoretic performance bounds to sensing and reconstruction of sparse phenomena from noisy projections. We consider two settings: output noise models where the noise enters after the projection and input noise models where the noise enters before the projection. We consider two types of distortion for reconstruction: support errors and mean-squared errors. Our goal is to relate the number of measurements, m , and SNR, to signal sparsity, k, distortion level, d, and signal dimension, n . We consider support errors in a worst-case setting. We employ different variations of Fano's inequality to derive necessary conditions on the number of measurements and SNR required for exact reconstruction. To derive sufficient conditions, we develop new insights on max-likelihood analysis based on a novel superposition property. In particular, this property implies that small support errors are the dominant error events. Consequently, our ML analysis does not suffer the conservatism of the union bound and leads to a tighter analysis of max-likelihood. These results provide order-wise tight bounds. For output noise models, we show that asymptotically an SNR of ((n)) together with (k (n/k)) measurements is necessary and sufficient for exact support recovery. Furthermore, if a small fraction of support errors can be tolerated, a constant SNR turns out to be sufficient in the linear sparsity regime. In contrast for input noise models, we show that support recovery fails if the number of measurements scales as o(n(n)/SNR), implying poor compression performance for such cases. Motivated by the fact that the worst-case setup requires significantly high SNR and substantial number of measurements for input and output noise models, we consider a Bayesian setup. To derive necessary conditions, we develop novel extensions to Fano's inequality to handle continuous domains and arbitrary distortions. We then develop a new max-likelihood analysis over the set of rate distortion quantization points to characterize tradeoffs between mean-squared distortion and the number of measurements using rate-distortion theory. We show that with constant SNR the number of measurements scales linearly with the rate-distortion function of the sparse phenomena.
BibTeX
@article{aeron2010information,
  author = {Shuchin Aeron and Venkatesh Saligrama and Manqi Zhao},
  title = {{Information theoretic bounds for compressed sensing}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Information Theory},
  year = {2010},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=dopZQmdvtj},
}

Loading related content...

Figure