Information Literacy Evaluation Index of Police College Students Based on AHP

Liang Hu, Guangwei ZhaoProceedings of the 2018 2nd International Conference on Education Innovation and Social Science (ICEISS 2018) 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Information literacy is a critical competency for university students, enabling them to leverage information technology for knowledge acquisition. In the context of police colleges, the cultivation of these skills is particularly vital due to the specialized nature of law enforcement work. Addressing the current lack of specific evaluation criteria for students in public security institutions, this research develops a tailored information literacy evaluation index system. Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), the study calculates indicator weights based on data collected from targeted questionnaires. The resulting framework provides a robust tool for assessing and enhancing the information literacy of future public security officers.

Introduction: The Need for Specialized Literacy Standards

Information literacy (IL) encompasses the ability to effectively search for, evaluate, utilize, and create information to solve complex problems. While general IL standards exist for the broader higher education landscape, they often fail to account for the unique professional requirements of law enforcement.

Police college students are the future architects of "information construction" within public security departments. Their proficiency in handling data is not merely an academic exercise; it is a fundamental requirement for modern policing, where data-driven decision-making and digital evidence are increasingly central. Furthermore, as representatives of public authority, these students must navigate information with a high degree of ethical responsibility and legal awareness. This paper addresses the gap in existing literature by constructing a weighted evaluation index specifically designed for the professional particularities of public security education.

Methodology: The Analytic Hierarchy Process

To develop a rigorous and objective evaluation framework, the researchers employed the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). This structured technique is ideal for organizing and analyzing complex multi-criteria decisions. The methodology followed four primary stages:

  1. Hierarchy Construction: Drawing from extensive literature reviews and established standards, the authors established a comprehensive two-level index system.
Conceptual model of information literacy components.
  1. Judgment Matrix Design: A scoring system was implemented to compare the relative importance of indicators at each level. Experts and stakeholders used a scale of 1 to 9 to perform pairwise comparisons.
  2. Consistency Verification: To ensure the reliability of subjective judgments, a Consistency Ratio (CR) was calculated. A CR value below 0.10 was maintained to validate the internal consistency of the judgment matrices.
  3. Weight Allocation: Finally, specific weights were derived for both "First Level" and "Second Level" indicators, identifying the most critical competencies for police students.

Data for the model was gathered through a specialized questionnaire survey distributed to public security college students, ensuring the framework reflects the actual educational environment.

The Evaluation Framework

The detailed two-level information literacy evaluation index system for police college students.

The resulting index system categorizes information literacy into four primary dimensions, which are further subdivided into specific actionable skills. The weighting of these indicators reveals several critical priorities for police education:

  • Mindset Over Mechanics: "Information Consciousness" (weighted at 0.302) emerged as more significant than "Information Ability" (0.253). This indicates that for law enforcement, the psychological readiness to recognize and ethically handle information is prioritized over technical execution.
  • The Importance of Sensitivity: Within the consciousness category, "Information Sensitivity" holds a dominant weight of 0.525. This reflects the necessity for officers to possess the "aha moment"—the ability to detect patterns or leads within vast datasets.
  • Professional Specialization: In the "Knowledge" category, "Professional Knowledge" (0.478) significantly outweighs "General Knowledge" (0.393). This underscores that police IL must go beyond general digital literacy to include mastery of specialized law enforcement tools and databases.
  • Ethics and Security: High weights for "Information Ethics" (0.301) and "Information Security" (0.174) highlight the high stakes of data privacy and legal compliance in public security work.

Results and Discussion

The final weighted index provides a clear hierarchy for evaluating a "literate" police student. The primary indicators are ranked as follows:

  1. Information Consciousness (0.302)
  2. Information Knowledge (0.288)
  3. Information Ability (0.253)
  4. Information Application (0.157)

At the secondary level, the most critical sub-skills identified are Information Sensitivity (0.525), Professional Knowledge (0.478), and Information Acquisition (0.433). This AHP-based system effectively shifts the focus from purely utilitarian technical skills toward a holistic model that fosters genuine awareness, ethical judgment, and professional analysis.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the current research successfully constructs and weights a specialized evaluation model, its application remains in the early stages. The authors identify several avenues for future development:

  • Curriculum Reform: Educational programs should transition from teaching basic computer skills toward integrated professional information analysis, guided by the weights identified in this study.
  • Strengthening Legal and Moral Education: There is a clear need to enhance "moral safety" and legal concepts regarding network information to ensure students are prepared for the ethical challenges of public security work.
  • Enhanced Supervision: Developing better mechanisms for monitoring and supporting campus information use will help reinforce these literacy standards in practice.

By implementing this specialized index, police colleges can better prepare their students for the complexities of the modern information environment, ensuring they serve as effective and ethical guardians of public security.

Summary updated

Abstract

Information literacy is a kind of ability that university students use information technology to acquire knowledge, so the cultivation of information literacy in police colleges is particularly important because of its particularity. In view of the lack of information literacy evaluation criteria for Public Security College students, this paper takes public security college students as the research object, designs a questionnaire survey to collect data, constructs an information literacy evaluation index system, and calculates the weight of indicators by using analytic hierarchy process. The results show that the index system can effectively evaluate the information literacy of police college students.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2018information,
  author = {Liang Hu and Guangwei Zhao},
  title = {{Information Literacy Evaluation Index of Police College Students Based on AHP}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the 2018 2nd International Conference on Education Innovation and Social Science (ICEISS 2018)},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2991/iceiss-18.2018.88},
}
Figure