TL;DR
This study investigates informal community growing in mountainous urban areas of Southwest China, revealing that these "gray areas" of urban management are primarily utilized by vulnerable populations for food security and economic gain. While residents are satisfied with the food and economic benefits, they express dissatisfaction with the environmental and social impacts, suggesting a need for integrated management strategies to transform these spaces into valuable community assets.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Rapid urbanization in China has led to the expansion of cities into surrounding rural areas, often leaving behind unused or difficult-to-build-on land, particularly in mountainous regions. In Southwest China, these barren slopes and abandoned spaces are frequently transformed by residents into informal community gardens and fruit-growing areas. This phenomenon, termed "informal community growing," presents a challenge for urban management as it operates outside official regulations. While it offers benefits like local food production and economic opportunities for residents, it also raises concerns about environmental impact and social order. This paper aims to understand the characteristics of this informal growing, the profile of those involved, their motivations, and the satisfaction levels of both growers and non-growers to inform future urban planning and management strategies.
Methods
The research employed a multi-phase approach:
- Study Area Selection: A representative area in Yongchuan District, Chongqing, was chosen based on criteria including a large prevalence of informal growing on sloping land, a diverse demographic composition of residents, and its central urban location.
- Data Collection: This involved:
- Field Surveys: To gather basic data on the natural topography, planting scale, food types, distribution, and cultivation methods.
- Questionnaires: Two types were used:
- A general questionnaire to collect demographic information (age, gender, occupation, income, education, household registration, farming experience), reasons for planting, and perceptions of non-growers.
- A semantic differential (SD) questionnaire to assess resident satisfaction with various aspects of informal community growing.
- Data Analysis:
- Descriptive Statistics: Used to analyze the demographic composition of growers, their motivations, and non-growers' perceptions.
- Reliability and Validity Tests: Cronbach's alpha and Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin (KMO) tests were conducted to ensure the quality of the satisfaction questionnaires.
- Exploratory Factor Analysis: Used to identify key factors contributing to satisfaction.
- Semantic Differential (SD) Method: Applied to quantify resident satisfaction levels.
- Independent Samples t-test and One-way ANOVA: Used to analyze differences in satisfaction across various demographic variables.
Datasets
Not explicitly detailed as separate datasets. The study utilized data collected through:
- Government Data: Land use and topography information for the study area.
- Field Observations: Direct observation of planting practices, types, and distribution.
- Survey Data: Responses from 440 valid questionnaires (270 from growers, 190 from non-growers) collected between September and December 2020, with supplementary data from April 2021 and March 2022.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Vulnerable Populations Drive Informal Growing: The primary growers are often elderly, low-income, unemployed, or recently migrated individuals. This suggests informal growing is a coping mechanism for social and economic disadvantage, fulfilling basic needs for food and income.
- Food Security and Economic Gain Trump Other Benefits: While residents appreciate the access to fresh, local food and the economic returns, they place less value on the social and environmental benefits of these informal plots.
- Satisfaction Discrepancies: Growers and non-growers are generally satisfied with food access and economic benefits but dissatisfied with the environmental and social aspects, as well as the planting process itself (which can be physically demanding and inconvenient in mountainous terrain).
- Mountainous Terrain Shapes Cultivation: The steep slopes and challenging topography necessitate traditional, labor-intensive farming methods and influence the types of crops grown, favoring those with robust root systems.
- Potential for Transformation: Despite the "informal" nature, these growing areas possess inherent value and could be integrated into urban planning as community gardens or urban agriculture initiatives, provided management addresses the negative impacts and balances diverse resident interests.
Key Results
- Scale and Supply: Informal growing in the study area is large-scale, with approximately 74.55 acres dedicated to it, providing a significant local food supply (0.027 acres per household).
- Grower Demographics: 73% of growers are over 51 years old, with a majority being unemployed or retired (78.4%), earning less than 1700 RMB/month (74.8%), and having elementary education or less.
- Motivations: The primary reasons for planting are economic gain (64.8%) and food safety (58.4%), followed by decoration of idle plots (44.4%) and spending time (40.4%). Social interaction, hobbies, and exercise were surprisingly low motivators.
- Satisfaction Scores: Overall satisfaction scores were moderately low for both growers (0.14) and non-growers (0.02).
- High Satisfaction: Food quality (growers: 1.16, non-growers: 1.24) and economic benefits (growers: 0.91, non-growers: 0.95) received the highest scores.
- Low Satisfaction: Environmental benefits (growers: -0.45, non-growers: -1.01) and social benefits (growers: -0.26, non-growers: -0.32) were areas of significant dissatisfaction. The planting process also scored low, particularly for growers regarding exercise benefits and convenience.
- Variability in Satisfaction: Residents who have lived in the city for a shorter time, are older, have lower incomes and education, and possess more planting experience tend to be more satisfied with informal growing.
Limitations and Future Work
- Single Sample: The study focused on one representative area in Yongchuan. The authors acknowledge that this may not fully capture the diverse characteristics and satisfaction levels found in informal community growing across other regions. Future research should include samples from multiple regions.
- Additional Factors: Other potential factors influencing satisfaction, such as growers' physical condition, the proximity of planting plots to entrances, and the spatial relationship between non-growers' homes and planting sites, were not fully explored and warrant further investigation.
- Future Recommendations: The paper strongly advocates for integrating informal community growing into urban planning. This includes:
- Strengthening Management: Developing regulations for planting, potentially legalizing it in designated areas, and improving infrastructure.
- Supporting Vulnerable Groups: Recognizing the role of informal growing for marginalized populations and providing support through training and potentially leasing land.
- Transforming Spaces: Exploring the potential to develop these areas into multifunctional community gardens or urban agriculture zones, enhancing their social, cultural, and economic value.
- Government Intervention: Emphasizing the need for government support and partnerships to manage and sustain these initiatives effectively.
Summary updated