Infodemiological Study on COVID-19 Epidemic and COVID-19 Infodemic

Hu Zhi, Zhongliang Yang, Qi Li, An Zhang, Yongfeng HuangPreprints.org 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Less aligned emphasis has been given to the COVID-19 infodemic coordinating with the COVID-19 outbreak. Global profusion of tangled monikers and hashtags has found their ways in daily communication and contributed to backlash against Chinese. Official naming efforts against infodemic should be meet with a fair share of identification. Based on brief critical reviews on previous multifarious naming practices, we punctuate heuristic introspection in scientific conventions and sociocultural paradigms. Infodemiological analysis promises to articulate that people around the globe are divided in their favor stigmatized monikers in the public and scientific communities because of perceptual bias. There is no positive correlation between the degree of infection in their territories and collective perceptual bias to COVID-19. The official portfolio “COVID-19” and “SARS-CoV-2” has not become de facto standard usages, but full-fledged official names are excepted to duly contribute to the resilience of negative perceptual bias and collective behavioral propensities.

Introduction

As the biological spread of COVID-19 accelerated in early 2020, it was shadowed by a parallel "infodemic"—the viral spread of information, misinformation, and stigmatized naming conventions. This study explores the "naming gap" between a pathogen's discovery and its official nomenclature, which allowed geographically-linked monikers like "Wuhan Virus" to take root, fueling social contagion and racial bias. By treating naming as a public health intervention, the authors analyze how these linguistic choices exacerbate panic and collective perceptual bias.

Methods

The research utilizes a multi-pronged "infodemiological" approach:

  • Diachronic Discourse Analysis: Tracking term frequencies in the Google Books Ngram Corpus (GBNC) from 1800 to 2008.
  • Convergent Cross Mapping (CCM): A non-linear dynamic modeling technique used to detect causal relationships between "epidemics" and "panic."
  • Four-Quadrant Mapping: Analyzing Google Trends Index (GTI) data from 58 countries to compare "geographical interest" in stigmatized terms against actual cumulative infection rates reported by the WHO.

Key Insights and Results

The Reciprocal Nature of Panic and Epidemics

A central finding is the historical coupling of biological outbreaks and social panic. Using CCM analysis, the researchers demonstrated that "epidemic" and "panic" are not merely correlated but are part of a coupled system where each reinforces the other. The causality scores (exceeding 0.9) indicate a strong reciprocal relationship, suggesting that managing information is as critical as managing the virus itself.

Convergent Cross Mapping (CCM) analysis demonstrating the strong reciprocal causality between 'panic' (X) and 'epidemic' (Y).

The "Psychological Typhoon Eye" and Geographical Bias

The study reveals a counterintuitive pattern in how bias manifests globally. Contrary to expectations, there is no positive correlation between a territory's infection rate and its use of stigmatized names. Instead, a "Psychological Typhoon Eye" effect was observed: populations furthest from the epicenter (with lower infection rates) often displayed the highest levels of interest in stigmatized monikers.

Four-quadrant mapping showing the relationship between geographical interest in stigmatized terms and actual cumulative infection rates across 58 countries.

Countries like Egypt, Greece, and Finland showed high interest in stigmatized terms despite low local infection rates, suggesting that sociocultural paradigms and information consumption drive bias more than direct biological risk.

The Naming Lag and Official Adoption

The transition to official terms like "COVID-19" faced significant hurdles. While "COVID-19" eventually began to overtake temporary names like "2019-nCoV," the scientific community's preference for "SARS-CoV-2" created public confusion. The association of "SARS" with high fatality rates potentially stoked further panic, illustrating the "catch-22" of scientific versus public health nomenclature.

Discussion and Limitations

This study provides a snapshot of the pandemic's onset (data through February 2020). While it highlights the dangers of the naming gap, it does not account for shifts in discourse as the virus became a global pandemic and the epicenter moved away from China. Furthermore, while Google Trends serves as a powerful proxy for public interest, it is not a direct measure of individual behavior. Future research should focus on identifying the "tipping point" where official communication can effectively neutralize the "typhoon eye" of public panic and stigma.

Summary updated

Abstract

Less aligned emphasis has been given to the COVID-19 infodemic coordinating with the COVID-19 outbreak. Global profusion of tangled monikers and hashtags has found their ways in daily communication and contributed to backlash against Chinese. Official naming efforts against infodemic should be meet with a fair share of identification. Based on brief critical reviews on previous multifarious naming practices, we punctuate heuristic introspection in scientific conventions and sociocultural paradigms. Infodemiological analysis promises to articulate that people around the globe are divided in their favor stigmatized monikers in the public and scientific communities because of perceptual bias. There is no positive correlation between the degree of infection in their territories and collective perceptual bias to COVID-19. The official portfolio “COVID-19” and “SARS-CoV-2” has not become de facto standard usages, but full-fledged official names are excepted to duly contribute to the resilience of negative perceptual bias and collective behavioral propensities.
BibTeX
@misc{zhi2020infodemiological,
  author = {Hu Zhi and Zhongliang Yang and Qi Li and An Zhang and Yongfeng Huang},
  title = {{Infodemiological Study on COVID-19 Epidemic and COVID-19 Infodemic}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.20944/preprints202002.0380.v3},
  howpublished = {Preprints.org},
}
Figure