Influences of crown size on the estimation of gap fraction and clumping index

Jun Geng, Qingjiu Tian, Lili Tu, Weiliang Fan, Xiaofei WangNational 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Canopy gap fraction (GF) and leaf clumping index (CI) are fundamental parameters in modeling vegetation interception and canopy radiation transfer. While traditional geometric models have focused extensively on crown shape (e.g., cylinders or cones), this research highlights that crown size and dimensions are equally, if not more, critical. By employing a hypergeometric distribution to model the spatial "repulsion effect" between trees and simulating seven distinct crown size types—ranging from prolate (tall and thin) to oblate (short and fat)—this study quantifies the significant impact of crown dimensions on GF and CI. The results indicate that crown size characteristics influence these metrics more substantially than shape alone, with larger projected areas leading to lower gap fractions and higher clumping indices.

Introduction

In forest remote sensing, understanding how light interacts with the canopy is essential for calculating the global carbon cycle and energy balance. Two metrics are central to this understanding: the Gap Fraction (GF), which represents the probability of light passing through the canopy to the forest floor, and the Clumping Index (CI), which quantifies the degree to which leaves deviate from a random spatial distribution.

Historically, the scientific community has prioritized crown shape as the primary structural variable in these models. However, tree dimensions—height and width—are evolutionary adaptations to local environments. For instance, trees at high latitudes often evolve to be tall and thin to maximize light capture from low-angle sunlight, whereas equatorial trees may be broader. This paper argues that ignoring these size-based adaptations leads to significant errors in forest density estimations.

Methodology

The researchers introduced two major innovations to improve the accuracy of canopy modeling:

1. The Hypergeometric Distribution and the Repulsion Effect

Standard models often use a Poisson distribution, which assumes trees are distributed randomly. A major flaw in this assumption is that it allows for infinite overlap between tree crowns. In reality, trees compete for resources and space, leading to a "repulsion effect" where crowns rarely occupy the same physical coordinates. The authors utilized a hypergeometric model to quantitatively describe this repulsion, creating a more realistic representation of forest stand structure.

2. Ellipsoidal Simulations and Controlled Variables

To isolate the effects of size, the study simulated a 100m x 100m virtual forest plot containing 2,000 trees with a fixed Leaf Area Index (LAI) of 4. They modeled seven distinct "size types" using ellipsoidal crowns, ranging from extremely prolate (tall-thin) to extremely oblate (short-fat). Two experimental paths were taken:

  • Fixed Radius: The crown footprint remained constant while the height varied.
  • Fixed Volume: The total crown volume (and thus biomass/leaf volume) remained constant while the aspect ratio changed.

Key Results

The simulations revealed that crown size is a dominant factor in canopy light interception, often overshadowing the influence of geometric shape.

Sensitivity of Gap Fraction

The impact of size on GF was most pronounced at high observation angles. For example, at a 60° angle, a "tall-thin" tree (16m height) exhibited a gap fraction 92.8% lower than that of a "short-fat" tree (0.25m height) with the identical radius. This suggests that vertical structure significantly blocks lateral light penetration.

Variance in Clumping Index

Under fixed-radius conditions, the clumping index for the tallest tree models was 261.8% higher than for the shortest models at a 60° angle. This indicates that as trees become taller and thinner, the "bunching" of leaves within the crown has a much larger mathematical impact on the overall canopy distribution.

The Role of Aspect Ratio

Even when total crown volume was held constant, the "tall-thin" models showed a gap fraction 414.1% higher at nadir (looking directly down) compared to "short-fat" models. This highlights that the projected area of the crown in the direction of the sensor or sun is the primary driver of these metrics.

Discussion and Implications

The findings suggest a potential geographical bias in current global forest models. Because tree dimensions vary systematically with latitude, models that do not account for size-scaling may be over- or under-estimating forest density and carbon sequestration potential in different climate zones.

Furthermore, the "repulsion effect" modeled by the hypergeometric distribution proved to be non-negligible. By accounting for the physical space trees occupy, the model provides a more realistic estimation of how light penetrates the canopy compared to traditional random-distribution models.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that crown size and dimensions are critical variables that must be integrated into forest remote sensing models. The transition from shape-focused to size-aware modeling, combined with the use of hypergeometric distributions to account for tree spacing, offers a path toward more accurate global vegetation assessments. Future research will focus on validating these theoretical findings using real-world data from LiDAR and high-resolution satellite missions like GEDI and ICESat-2.

Summary updated

Abstract

å† å±‚é—´éš™çŽ‡å’Œå¶ç‰‡èšé›†åº¦æŒ‡æ•°å¯¹æ¤è¢«æ‹¦æˆªå ‰å’Œå† å±‚è¾å°„ä¼ è¾“è¿‡ç¨‹æœ‰é‡è¦å½±å“ã€‚å¶ç‰‡å¾€å¾€ä»¥æ ‘å† çš„å½¢å¼èšé›†åœ¨æ£®æž—ä¸­,è€Œæ ‘å† åœ¨è¯¸å¤šæ£®æž—å† å±‚å‡ ä½•å ‰å­¦æ¨¡åž‹ä¸­æœ‰é‡è¦ä½œç”¨ã€‚ä¹‹å‰çš„ç ”ç©¶ä¸»è¦é›†ä¸­äºŽæ ‘å† çš„å½¢çŠ¶ï¼ˆä¾‹å¦‚åœ†æŸ±ã€åœ†é”¥ã€æ¤­çƒã€åœ†é”¥+åœ†æŸ±ç­‰ï¼‰ç‰¹å¾å¯¹å† å±‚é—´éš™çŽ‡å’Œå¶ç‰‡èšé›†åº¦çš„å½±å“ã€‚ç„¶è€Œ,æ ‘å† çš„ç»“æž„ç‰¹å¾é™¤äº†åŒ æ‹¬å½¢çŠ¶ç‰¹å¾å¤–,è¿˜åŒ æ‹¬å°ºå¯¸ç‰¹å¾ã€‚äº‹å®žä¸Š,æ ‘å† çš„å°ºå¯¸ç‰¹å¾æ˜¯æ¤è¢«åœ¨é•¿æœŸè¿›åŒ–è¿‡ç¨‹ä¸­ä¸Žè‡ªç„¶çŽ¯å¢ƒç›¸äº’ä½œç”¨çš„ç»“æžœ,ä¸”æ¯”æ ‘å† å½¢çŠ¶ç‰¹å¾å ·æœ‰æ›´æ˜Žæ˜¾çš„åœ°ç†ç©ºé—´ç‰¹å¾ã€‚æœ¬æ–‡é¦–å ˆä¿®æ”¹äº†å‰äººå¸¸ç”¨çš„ç”¨äºŽæè¿°æ ‘å† åˆ†å¸ƒçš„æ³Šæ¾åˆ†å¸ƒæ¨¡åž‹,å ¶æ¬¡,åˆ©ç”¨è¶ å‡ ä½•æ¨¡åž‹æ›´ä¸ºçœŸå®žåœ°ã€å®šé‡åœ°æè¿°æ ‘å† ä¹‹é—´çš„æŽ’æ–¥æ•ˆåº”å’Œæ ‘å† çš„åˆ†å¸ƒæƒ å†µ;最后,ä»¥æ¤­çƒæ ‘å† ä¸ºä¾‹,设定了从"瘦高"型到"矮胖"型等7ç§å°ºå¯¸çš„æ ‘å† ,åˆ†åˆ«é€šè¿‡å›ºå®šæ ‘å† åŠå¾„å’Œæ ‘å† ä½“ç§¯ä¸¤ç§é€”å¾„æŽ¢è®¨äº†æ ‘å† å°ºå¯¸ç‰¹å¾å¯¹å† å±‚é—´éš™çŽ‡å’Œå¶ç‰‡èšé›†åº¦çš„å½±å“ã€‚ç»“æžœè¡¨æ˜Ž:(1ï¼‰æ— è®ºå›ºå®šæ ‘å† åŠå¾„,è¿˜æ˜¯å›ºå®šæ ‘å† ä½“ç§¯,æ ‘å† å°ºå¯¸ç‰¹å¾å¯¹å† å±‚é—´éš™çŽ‡å’Œå¶ç‰‡èšé›†åº¦æŒ‡æ•°çš„å½±å“,å‡æ¯”æ ‘å† å½¢çŠ¶ç‰¹å¾å¯¹é—´éš™çŽ‡å’Œå¶ç‰‡èšé›†åº¦æŒ‡æ•°çš„å½±å“æ˜Žæ˜¾;(2ï¼‰æ ‘å† çš„å°ºå¯¸å¯¹å† å±‚é—´éš™çŽ‡å’Œå¶ç‰‡èšé›†åº¦çš„å½±å“éžå¸¸æ˜¾è‘—,ä¸”å ·æœ‰æ˜Žæ˜¾çš„è§„å¾‹æ€§ã€‚æ ‘å† åœ¨è§‚æµ‹æ–¹å‘çš„æŠ•å½±é¢ç§¯è¶Šå¤§,å† å±‚é—´éš™çŽ‡è¶Šå°,叶片聚集指数度越大,å† å±‚å† å¶ç‰‡è¶Šè¶‹äºŽæ³Šæ¾åˆ†å¸ƒã€‚
BibTeX
@inproceedings{geng2016influences,
  author = {Jun Geng and Qingjiu Tian and Lili Tu and Weiliang Fan and Xiaofei Wang},
  title = {{Influences of crown size on the estimation of gap fraction and clumping index}},
  booktitle = {National},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.11834/jrs.20166060},
}
Figure