Influence of Virtual Reality (VR) Technology on the Teaching Effect of Engineering Practical Training

Shisheng Lyn, Feng Yan, Qiuyue SunJournal of Engineering Science and Technology Review 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies how Virtual Reality (VR) integration transforms engineering practical training, identifying five key pedagogical drivers of success. Most importantly, it reveals an "inverted U-shaped" relationship between VR usage frequency and learning effectiveness, suggesting that four sessions per week is the "sweet spot" before "VR fatigue" sets in.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Engineering education relies heavily on practical training, yet traditional methods face significant hurdles: high equipment costs, limited physical space, and inherent safety risks when students operate heavy machinery. While VR is often touted as a solution, simply "using VR" isn't a strategy.

The authors address a critical gap in educational research: How do specific pedagogical components of a VR curriculum—such as assessment methods and instructional design—actually impact learning outcomes? Furthermore, they investigate the threshold at which VR stops being a helpful tool and starts becoming a distraction or a source of fatigue.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using a structured questionnaire distributed to engineering undergraduates.

  • Survey Instrument: A 7-point Likert scale questionnaire was designed to measure five independent variables: Teaching Objectives, Instructional Design, Teaching Resources, Teaching Process, and Assessment Methods.
  • Statistical Framework: The study utilized SPSS 26.0 to perform:
  • Reliability & Validity Analysis: Using Cronbach’s alpha (reliability) and Average Variance Extracted (AVE) / Composite Reliability (CR) to ensure data quality.
  • Linear Regression: To determine the contribution of each pedagogical factor to the overall teaching effect.
  • Variance Analysis (F-test): To measure the impact of VR teaching frequency on effectiveness.

Datasets

The study collected primary data from 274 valid respondents (out of 365 surveyed) across seven universities in Wuhan, China.

  • Demographics: The cohort was 63.5% male, primarily consisting of students in Mechanical Engineering, Material Forming, and Industrial Design.
  • Context: These universities had already integrated various levels of virtual simulation and VR into their mechanical engineering curricula, providing a mature environment for the study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "VR Fatigue" Threshold: The most striking finding is the non-linear relationship between VR use and effectiveness. While more practice generally leads to better skill mastery, exceeding five sessions per week causes a sharp decline in learning efficacy. Students may begin treating the simulation like a game or experience cognitive overload.
  • Holistic Integration Matters: VR isn't just a visual aid; its success depends on the "Teaching Process" and "Assessment Methods." The authors argue that VR allows for automated data recording (tracking misoperations and prompts), which provides a more objective assessment than traditional "final paper" exams.
  • Safety and Exploration: VR provides a "fail-safe" environment that encourages students to explore the internal mechanisms of equipment—something often impossible or dangerous with physical hardware. This leads to higher "innovative consciousness."

Key Results

  • Statistical Validation: The questionnaire showed high reliability (overall Cronbach’s alpha = 0.834). All five pedagogical factors were found to have a significant positive impact on teaching effectiveness.
  • The Frequency Peak: The variance analysis ($F=2.340, p=0.042$) confirmed that frequency matters.
  • 1 time/week: Mean effectiveness of 3.13.
  • 4 times/week: Peak effectiveness of 5.17.
  • >5 times/week: Effectiveness dropped to 4.06.
  • Regression Highlights: Instructional Design ($\beta=0.194$) and Teaching Resources ($\beta=0.176$) were among the strongest predictors of a positive teaching effect.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while VR is powerful, it is not a total replacement for traditional methods.

  • Geographic/Disciplinary Bias: The data is limited to engineering students in a specific region of China (Wuhan). Future studies should explore if these results hold across different disciplines like medicine or humanities.
  • Hybrid Models: The paper suggests that future research should focus on the optimal "blend" of online VR prep and offline physical operation.
  • Long-term Retention: The study measures perceived "teaching effect" via a questionnaire; future work could benefit from longitudinal data tracking actual career performance or long-term skill retention.

Summary updated

Abstract

Emerging technologies represented by artificial intelligence, blockchain, and big data have comprehensively promoted the improvement of education quality and the reform of teaching models. The comprehensive and efficient integration of advanced technology and teaching courses is conducive to the implementation of different teaching modes and breaks through the constraints of traditional teaching modes. Using Virtual Reality (VR) technology to teach practical training courses can significantly enhance students' interest in participating in practical training, improve teaching effectiveness and quality, reduce the risk of misoperation in practical training, avoid teaching risks, improve teaching quality, and has high promotion value in the existing engineering training courses. This study designed a questionnaire on the impact of VR technology on the teaching effect of engineering training, and analyzed the impact of five aspects of VR technology (teaching objectives, teaching design, teaching resources, teaching process, and assessment methods) on the teaching effect of engineering training. The variance analysis method was used to measure the different effects of VR teaching frequency on the effect of engineering training. Results show that the overall reliability coefficient value is 0.834 and the convergent validity and discriminant validity are very good. Specifically, teaching objectives, teaching design, teaching resources, teaching process, and assessment methods in VR teaching have a significant promoting effect on the teaching effect of engineering training. The frequency of VR teaching has a 0.05 significance level for the effect of engineering practical training (F=2.340, p=0.042). In addition, the relationship between the frequency of VR teaching and the effect of engineering practical training showed an inverted U-shaped curve. Conclusions provide a valuable reference for using VR technology to support engineering training teaching and the improvement of engineering training teaching methods.
BibTeX
@article{lyn2022influence,
  author = {Shisheng Lyn and Feng Yan and Qiuyue Sun},
  title = {{Influence of Virtual Reality (VR) Technology on the Teaching Effect of Engineering Practical Training}},
  journal = {Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.25103/jestr.156.17},
}
Figure