Influence of Usability on Customer Satisfaction: A Case Study on Mobile Phone Services

Rodrigo de Oliveira, Mauro Cherubini, Nuria OliverI-UxSED 2012 · OpenReview

Introduction

In Human-Computer Interaction (HCI), the focus has evolved from basic usability—the functional ability to use a system—to the broader concept of User Experience (UX), which encompasses the emotional and subjective feelings of the user. Despite this shift, the precise link between objective usability goals (like efficiency) and subjective satisfaction has remained unclear. Furthermore, individual differences, such as personality, are often overlooked in UX models. This study addresses these gaps by examining how personality traits, perceived usability, and actual usage behavior collectively influence customer satisfaction in the context of mobile phone services.

Conceptual Framework and Methodology

The researchers proposed a model connecting personality traits (the "Big Five"), perceived usability, actual usage behavior, and customer satisfaction.

Conceptual model of the study's hypothesized relationships.

To validate this model, the study utilized Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) on a hybrid dataset. This dataset included subjective survey responses from 603 mobile users (aged 18-35) in Mexico and objective usage logs provided by the telecommunications operator, Telefonica. By using actual operator logs for calls and messages rather than self-reported data, the study avoids the common bias of users misestimating their own technology consumption.

Key Insights and Empirical Results

The structural model revealed several critical findings regarding the drivers of customer satisfaction.

Structural model results with path coefficients.

The Dominance of Efficiency

A primary finding is that perceived usability is the strongest direct predictor of satisfaction ($\beta = 0.47$). Interestingly, within the usability construct, efficiency (saving time) had a significantly higher loading (.82) than ease of use (.61). This suggests that for mobile service users, the value derived from getting tasks done quickly outweighs the simplicity of the interface.

The Technology Saturation Point

Contrary to what might be expected, higher actual usage does not lead to higher satisfaction. The path from mobile phone usage to satisfaction was negative ($\beta = -0.11$). This indicates a "saturation point" where excessive technology consumption—particularly synchronous activities like phone calls—may lead to stress or "message anxiety," ultimately reducing overall satisfaction.

Personality as a Perceptual Filter

Personality traits significantly moderate how users perceive service usability. Specifically:

  • Extroverts ($\beta = 0.29$) and Conscientious individuals ($\beta = 0.25$) reported higher perceived usability. Extroverts likely find mobile services highly usable because they facilitate social interaction, while conscientious users value the organizational efficiency these tools provide.
  • Intellect (Openness) showed a negative relationship with satisfaction ($\beta = -0.19$), suggesting that more intellectually curious users might have higher expectations or find standard mobile services less fulfilling.

Discussion and Future Directions

The model successfully explained 25% of the variance in customer satisfaction and 28% in perceived usability, demonstrating a good fit with real-world data. These findings have significant implications for service design, suggesting a move toward personality-based personalization. For instance, proactive spending alerts could help less organized users avoid the dissatisfaction associated with unexpected costs.

However, the study's focus on pre-paid users in a specific demographic (Mexico, ages 18-35) and on "basic" services (calls/SMS) limits its generalizability to the modern smartphone era. Future research should explore these dynamics in the context of app-heavy usage and constant social media connectivity across broader demographics.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{oliveira2012influence,
  author = {Rodrigo de Oliveira and Mauro Cherubini and Nuria Oliver},
  title = {{Influence of Usability on Customer Satisfaction: A Case Study on Mobile Phone Services}},
  booktitle = {I-UxSED},
  year = {2012},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=C5K4rApjhK},
}
Figure