Influence of type traits on stayability in the Ital- ian Mediterranean buffalo

Damiano Altieri, Stefano Biffani, Mayra Gómez Carpio, Yuri Gombia, Dario Rossi, Luca Gubitosi, Nadia Piscopo, Francesca Carnovale, Rossella Di PaloRevista 2023 · DOI

Abstract

Over the past two decades, selection programs for the Italian Mediterranean Buffalo (IMB) have significantly increased milk yields. However, evidence from dairy cattle suggests that prioritizing production can inadvertently shorten an animal's productive lifespan. This study investigates "stayability"—a binary measure of an animal's ability to remain in the herd—and its correlation with physical "type traits" such as udder and limb structure. By analyzing records from over 276,000 buffalo cows, the research aims to establish morphological predictors for longevity, facilitating the development of genetic indexes that balance high production with physical durability.

Introduction: The Production-Longevity Trade-off

In the Italian Mediterranean Buffalo industry, the drive for higher milk production has been highly successful, supported by improved farm management and the widespread use of artificial insemination. Yet, this focus on yield has come at a cost. Similar to trends observed in dairy cows, increased production often correlates with a decrease in the average productive life of breeding females.

Longevity is a complex, multifactorial trait influenced by both physiology and morphology. When buffalo are culled prematurely, farmers face increased production costs due to higher replacement rates. To address this, it is essential to identify early-life predictors that can help select for animals capable of sustained productivity.

Methodology and Data Integration

The researchers employed stayability as a qualitative metric for longevity. Unlike quantitative measures like "age at culling," stayability is treated as a binary variable: assigned a value of 1 if the animal calved during a specific parity (from 1 to 10) and 0 otherwise.

The study integrated two massive datasets:

  1. ANASB Studbook: Containing morphological measurements and merit scores (body conformation, limbs, feet, and udder) for 276,415 buffalo cows registered since 1989.
  2. AIA (Italian Breeder’s Association): Official milk test-day records used to track calving dates and determine stayability across ten parities.

By correlating these datasets, the team sought to identify which linear type traits and aggregate merit scores most accurately predict an animal's long-term presence in the herd.

Key Insights: Morphology as a Predictor of Survival

The study's findings underscore the critical role of structural integrity in animal longevity. The core hypothesis—that sound limbs, feet, and udder structure are prerequisites for sustained high production—was supported by the data. An animal with high genetic potential for milk but poor "running gear" is significantly more likely to be culled early due to physical breakdown or injury.

Key takeaways include:

  • Stayability as a Selection Tool: The binary nature of stayability makes it a robust and easily integrated metric for large-scale genetic models.
  • Predictive Power of Type Traits: Morphological traits measured by ANASB provide a statistically significant basis for predicting how long a buffalo will remain productive.
  • Economic Impact: Selecting for physical durability alongside milk volume can lower replacement rates, thereby reducing overall farm production costs.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research validates the stayability framework as a viable tool for improving the longevity of the Italian Mediterranean Buffalo. While the study establishes the correlation between morphology and survival, further work is needed to determine the precise weightings of individual traits.

The ultimate goal is the creation of aggregated genetic indexes. These indexes will provide breeders with a comprehensive selection tool, allowing them to optimize for both high milk yield and the physical characteristics necessary for a long, healthy, and cost-effective productive life.

Summary updated

Abstract

The selection schemes adopted over the past 20 years for the Italian Mediterranean Buffalo, together with the marked improvement in farm management techniques and the systematic application of AI in an increasing number of subjects, have resulted in a sharp improvement in the quantities of milk produced per lactation. Experiences from dairy cows suggest that such an improvement could reduce the average productive life span of breeding females and, therefore, their longevity. Animal longevity has a multifactorial etiology where physiology and morphology, in close correlation with each other, cross their effects to enable animals to continue to produce efficiently on the farm. In the past, the selection of the Italian Mediterranean buffalo has mainly focused on increasing milk production, which has had an unfavorable impact on the average farm life of the IMB. This trend needs to be reversed as this inevitably leads to an increase in production costs due to the increase in the replacement rate. There are many ways to assess longevity, both quantitatively, such as age at culling and parity at culling, and qualitatively, such as in the case of stayability, where it is evaluated as a binary variable where 1 and 0 indicate the ability to stay or be culled at a given time, respectively. In a recent study, we evaluated the genetic aspects of stayability in IMB, and the results suggest the possibility of using it in the selection process. This study aimed to correlate stayability with the linear type traits measured by the ANASB for IMB and with the merit score values for body conformation, limbs, feet, and udder. Data from 276.415 buffalo cows registered in the ANASB studbook starting from 1989 were extracted and merged with the official milk test-day recording datasets from the Italian Breeder’s Association (AIA). The stayability from parity one up to 10 was assessed assigning a value of 1 if a calving date was present or 0 otherwise. Investigating the relationship between some morphological traits and longevity would give them the proper em-phasis in formulating genetic indexes or creating specific aggregated indexes to make the selection process more efficient.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{altieri2023influence,
  author = {Damiano Altieri and Stefano Biffani and Mayra Gómez Carpio and Yuri Gombia and Dario Rossi and Luca Gubitosi and Nadia Piscopo and Francesca Carnovale and Rossella Di Palo},
  title = {{Influence of type traits on stayability in the Ital- ian Mediterranean buffalo}},
  booktitle = {Revista},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.52973/rcfcv-wbc028},
}
Figure