Influence of Traffic Activity on Heavy Metal Concentrations of Roadside Farmland Soil in Mountainous Areas

Fan Zhang, Xuedong Yan, Chen Zeng, Man Zhang, Suraj Shrestha, Lochan Prasad Devkota, Tandong YaoInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2012 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how traffic activity impacts heavy metal (Cu, Zn, Cd, Pb) concentrations in farmland soil along a mountainous highway in Nepal. While average levels are below tolerable limits, some spots show concerning peaks, highlighting the need for localized mitigation. The research reveals that altitude, terrain, and roadside trees significantly influence metal distribution, offering insights for managing traffic-related pollution in unique mountain environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Heavy metals from traffic emissions are a known source of pollution in roadside ecosystems. However, most research has focused on urban or plain environments. Mountainous regions present unique challenges due to complex terrain, varying altitudes, and potentially more intense driving conditions, which could alter how heavy metals accumulate and distribute in roadside farmland. This study aims to fill this knowledge gap by examining these factors in the context of the Trishuli Highway in Nepal, a region with significant agricultural reliance and a mountainous landscape. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for ensuring food safety and environmental health in such areas.

Methods

The researchers employed a factorial design using Multivariate Analysis of Variance (MANOVA) to assess the influence of four independent variables on heavy metal concentrations (Cu, Zn, Cd, Pb) in topsoil (0-5 cm depth). The independent variables were:

  • Altitude: Six levels ranging from 800 m to 1,800 m.
  • Distance: Five distances from the road edge (0 m, 10 m, 30 m, 50 m, 100 m), with 100 m serving as a proxy for background levels.
  • Terrain: Categorized as "upgrade" (farmland elevation increases from the road) or "downgrade" (farmland elevation decreases from the road).
  • Tree Protection: Presence or absence of trees between the farmland and the road.

Soil samples were collected from 342 locations along the Trishuli Highway. Heavy metal concentrations were determined using Inductively Coupled Plasma-Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) after microwave digestion. A pollution index (Pi) was calculated by comparing roadside sample concentrations to local background values (100 m distance) to assess the degree of traffic-related pollution.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples collected from 342 locations along the Trishuli Highway in Nepal. These samples represent a new dataset specifically collected to investigate heavy metal contamination in mountainous roadside farmland. The sampling design aimed to capture variations across different altitudes, distances from the road, terrain types, and the presence or absence of roadside trees.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mountainous environments matter: The distribution patterns of heavy metals in mountainous roadside soils are significantly different from those observed in urban or plain areas, underscoring the need for region-specific studies.
  • Localized hotspots are a concern: While average heavy metal concentrations are generally below tolerable levels, some specific locations exhibit peak concentrations of Zn, Cd, and Pb that are close to or exceed these limits, indicating potential localized severe pollution.
  • Trees offer a protective buffer: The presence of roadside trees significantly reduces the concentrations of Cu and Pb in the soil, suggesting that planting trees can be an effective strategy for mitigating traffic-related heavy metal contamination in agricultural areas.
  • Terrain plays a dual role: Pb concentrations are lower in downgrade soils compared to upgrade soils, likely due to deposition patterns. Conversely, Zn concentrations are slightly higher in downgrade soils, possibly influenced by runoff.
  • Altitude is a complex factor: While altitude itself doesn't directly explain heavy metal contamination, it acts as a significant "block factor" influencing the effects of other variables, potentially due to its correlation with terrain and driving conditions.
  • Distance decay is inconsistent: Unlike urban studies, a clear, consistent exponential decrease in heavy metal concentrations with distance from the road was not observed, likely due to factors like frequent farming activities, crop assimilation, and complex local terrain.

Key Results

  • Average concentrations of Cu (19.99 mg/kg), Zn (76.30 mg/kg), Cd (0.36 mg/kg), and Pb (22.57 mg/kg) were below the phytotoxic levels (100 mg/kg Cu, 300 mg/kg Zn, 3 mg/kg Cd, 100 mg/kg Pb).
  • However, maximum concentrations of Zn, Cd, and Pb were found to be close to or higher than tolerable levels in some spots.
  • Correlation analysis revealed significant positive correlations between Cu and Zn/Pb, and between Cd and Zn/Pb, suggesting a common traffic-related source for these metals. No significant correlation was found between Cu and Cd.
  • MANOVA results showed that Altitude significantly influenced Cu, Zn, and Pb concentrations. Tree protection significantly affected Cu and Pb. Terrain had a significant effect on Pb.
  • Pb concentration was significantly lower in downgrade roadside soil (M = 18.23 mg/kg) compared to upgrade soil (M = 26.62 mg/kg).
  • Zn concentration was marginally higher in downgrade roadside soil (M = 85.26 mg/kg) than in upgrade soil (M = 67.94 mg/kg).
  • Roadside soils with tree protection showed significantly lower concentrations of Cu and Pb compared to those without trees.
  • The pollution index (Pi) values generally fluctuated around one, indicating no widespread serious pollution, but maximum Pi values for Pb, Zn, and Cd were significantly higher than 1, confirming localized hotspots.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Inconsistent distance-decay pattern: The study could not consistently identify an attenuation pattern of heavy metal concentrations with roadside distance within 100 m. This is attributed to factors like frequent farming activities (irrigation, ploughing, fertilization) that mix topsoil, crop assimilation of metals, and complex local terrain and environmental conditions (runoff, wind).
  • Limited sampling for certain conditions: Due to on-site constraints, some specific combinations of altitude, terrain, and tree presence were not sampled, potentially limiting the full factorial analysis.
  • Future Work Suggestions:
    • Future studies should focus on more detailed sampling within the first 10 m from the road edge to better capture spatial heavy metal distribution patterns, especially given the lower traffic volumes on the Trishuli Highway.
  • Further research could explore the specific mechanisms behind the differing distribution of Pb and Zn (air deposition vs. runoff).
  • The findings suggest that planting trees along roadways is a promising mitigation strategy for existing crop plots near roads.
  • The study's insights are valuable for developing policies to avoid hazardous heavy metal contamination in agricultural soils within mountainous regions of the Third Pole.

Summary updated

Abstract

Emission of heavy metals from traffic activities is an important pollution source to roadside farmland ecosystems. However, little previous research has been conducted to investigate heavy metal concentrations of roadside farmland soil in mountainous areas. Owing to more complex roadside environments and more intense driving conditions on mountainous highways, heavy metal accumulation and distribution patterns in farmland soil due to traffic activity could be different from those on plain highways. In this study, design factors including altitude, roadside distance, terrain, and tree protection were considered to analyze their influences on Cu, Zn, Cd, and Pb concentrations in farmland soils along a mountain highway around Kathmandu, Nepal. On average, the concentrations of Cu, Zn, Cd, and Pb at the sampling sites are lower than the tolerable levels. Correspondingly, pollution index analysis does not show serious roadside pollution owing to traffic emissions either. However, some maximum Zn, Cd, and Pb concentrations are close to or higher than the tolerable level, indicating that although average accumulations of heavy metals pose no hazard in the region, some spots with peak concentrations may be severely polluted. The correlation analysis indicates that either Cu or Cd content is found to be significantly correlated with Zn and Pb content while there is no significant correlation between Cu and Cd. The pattern can be reasonably explained by the vehicular heavy metal emission mechanisms, which proves the heavy metals' homology of the traffic pollution source. Furthermore, the independent factors show complex interaction effects on heavy metal concentrations in the mountainous roadside soil, which indicate quite a different distribution pattern from previous studies focusing on urban roadside environments. It is found that the Pb concentration in the downgrade roadside soil is significantly lower than that in the upgrade soil while the Zn concentration in the downgrade roadside soil is marginally higher than in the upgrade soil; and the concentrations of Cu and Pb in the roadside soils with tree protection are significantly lower than those without tree protection. However, the attenuation pattern of heavy metal concentrations as a function of roadside distance within a 100 m range cannot be identified consistently.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2012influence,
  author = {Fan Zhang and Xuedong Yan and Chen Zeng and Man Zhang and Suraj Shrestha and Lochan Prasad Devkota and Tandong Yao},
  title = {{Influence of Traffic Activity on Heavy Metal Concentrations of Roadside Farmland Soil in Mountainous Areas}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2012},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph9051715},
}
Figure