Influence of the flow coefficient resistance to the fluctuation of total braking force in hydraulic brakes artillery weapon

Zoran Ristić, Slobodan IlićVojnotehnicki 2001 · DOI

Abstract

In this paper, the fluid flow coefficient is considered according to the model of hydraulic functioning of the artillery weapon recoil brake during the firing process. The relations for the coefficient of hydraulic resistance during primary and additional fluid flow are determined on the basis of the form of the flow through bores. The law of change of flow resistance coefficient is determined on the basis of experimental values for fluid pressure and piston velocity moving in the recoil phase. The influence of the flow resistance coefficient on the fluctuation level of the total braking force of artillery weapon recoil mass was analyzed.

Introduction: The Recoil Problem

When a large-caliber artillery piece fires, it generates massive recoil forces. To prevent damage to the carriage and the weapon itself, hydraulic brakes are used to dissipate this energy. Traditionally, engineers have relied on "classic" models that assume flow resistance coefficients ($k$)—values representing internal geometric resistance—are constant. However, fluid flow inside a recoil brake is highly dynamic, transitioning rapidly between laminar and turbulent regimes under extreme pressure. This paper challenges the static assumption, demonstrating that dynamic, stroke-dependent coefficients are essential for accurate weapon design.

Modeling the Hydraulic System

The researchers developed a non-linear differential equation model for a hydraulic brake featuring a profiled counter-piston, a common design in medium and large-caliber guns.

Schematic representation of the hydraulic brake system showing the piston, cylinder, and fluid flow paths.

As shown in Figure 1, the system involves complex fluid interactions between the main cylinder and internal cavities. To capture this complexity, the authors used MATLAB and Simulink to simulate the recoil process, calculating time-dependent functions for previously unknown non-linear coefficients.

Experimental Validation and Dynamic Coefficients

The theoretical model was validated using data from an experimental artillery weapon. Researchers measured fluid pressure in the cylinder ($p_1$), pressure in the piston cavity ($p_2$), and recoil velocity ($v_r$) throughout the stroke. Instead of using a fixed $k$ value from literature, they "back-calculated" how $k$ changes as a function of the piston's position ($x$).

Experimental curve showing the primary flow resistance coefficient $k_1$ as a function of the recoil stroke.

Figure 5 illustrates a key finding: the flow resistance coefficient is highly volatile. It spikes sharply at the very beginning of the recoil due to massive pressure gradients and again at the end as velocity drops and flow transitions toward a laminar state. The study found that the total braking force is significantly more sensitive to this primary flow coefficient ($k_1$) than to secondary flow ($k_2$).

Key Results and Accuracy Gains

The improved model showed a much higher correlation with experimental pressure curves than traditional models. While classic models exhibited deviations as high as 37% at peak pressure points, the refined model closely tracked the experimental "double peak" pressure profile. Furthermore, while literature often suggests a steady ratio between additional and primary flow resistance ($k_2/k_1$) of 3 to 5, this study found it fluctuates wildly between 2.5 and 20.8.

Conclusion

Accounting for the dynamic nature of flow resistance coefficients is critical for artillery design. The "classic" model tends to underestimate total impulse, potentially subjecting structural components to more energy than anticipated. By adopting stroke-dependent coefficients, designers can achieve pressure calculation accuracies within 1%, moving away from expensive "trial and error" prototyping toward more reliable simulation-based engineering.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the fluid flow coefficient is considered according to the model Of hydraulic functioning of the artillery weapon recoil brake during firing process. The relations for coefficient of hydraulic resistance during primary and additional fluid flow are determined on the basis of the form of the flow through bores. The law of change of flow resistance coefficient is determined on the basis of experimental values for fluid pressure and piston velocity moving in the recoil phase. The Influence of the flow resistance coefficient on the fluctuation level of the total braking force of artillery weapon recoil mass was analyzed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ristic2001influence,
  author = {Zoran Ristić and Slobodan Ilić},
  title = {{Influence of the flow coefficient resistance to the fluctuation of total braking force in hydraulic brakes artillery weapon}},
  booktitle = {Vojnotehnicki},
  year = {2001},
  doi = {10.5937/vojtehg0103267r},
}

Loading related content...

Figure