Influence of strangers' vocal attractiveness on adolescents' epistemic trust: moderation effect of analytical thinking

Cui Zhu, Yiran Zhang, Zan Liu, Dongjie Xie, Cheng Yang, Yanjie SuFrontiers in Psychology 2026 · DOI

Abstract

Epistemic trust is closely linked to the cognitive process of evaluating knowledge to adapt to complex social environments. This trust can be influenced by cognitive biases stemming from external traits, such as the voice of a stranger. Considering that adolescence is a critical stage in social development, this research investigates the influence of strangers' vocal attractiveness on adolescents' epistemic trust and its potential moderators. Through two studies involving trustworthiness ratings of technology news summaries, the results suggest that vocal attractiveness is a crucial cue promoting epistemic trust. However, successfully activating an individual's analytical thinking can significantly reduce this influence.

Introduction

In an era of rapid information exchange, "epistemic trust"—the willingness to accept new information from others as reliable—is a vital social-cognitive skill. Adolescents are in a particularly sensitive developmental window where they must learn to balance openness to new knowledge with "epistemic vigilance" to avoid being misled. While physical attractiveness is known to trigger a "halo effect," where positive traits are subconsciously attributed to beautiful people, the specific impact of vocal attractiveness on trust remains under-researched. This paper explores how a pleasant voice creates a cognitive bias in adolescents and demonstrates that this effect can be mitigated by actively engaging analytical thinking (System 2 processing).

Methods

The researchers conducted two empirical studies using a 2x2 within-subject design, varying the speaker's vocal attractiveness and gender.

  • Study 1: Established a baseline by having 243 participants (ages 12–22) listen to 12 audio clips of technology news summaries recorded by speakers with high or low vocal attractiveness. Participants then rated the trustworthiness of the information.
  • Study 2: Investigated the moderation effect of analytical thinking with 258 new participants. An experimental group was "primed" for analytical thinking using 36 non-verbal intelligence questions (Raven’s Progressive Matrices), while a control group performed a neutral task. Both groups then completed the audio-rating task.
  • Statistical Approach: Linear Mixed Models (LMM) were used to analyze the relationship between the Trustworthiness Perception Score (TPS) and the Vocal Attractiveness Score (VAS), treating participants as random effects.

Key Results

Study 1 confirmed a significant positive main effect of vocal attractiveness on trustworthiness ($b = 0.09, p < 0.001$), showing that adolescents consistently rated information as more trustworthy when delivered by an attractive voice.

Study 2 revealed a significant interaction effect between vocal attractiveness and the experimental group ($b = -0.11, p = 0.010$). In the control group, the influence of the voice was strong ($b = 0.23, p < 0.001$), but in the experimental group where analytical thinking was activated, this influence was nearly halved ($b = 0.12, p < 0.001$).

Figure 1: Simple slopes analysis showing the interaction effect between the reader's vocal attractiveness score (VAS) and the participant's group on trustworthiness perception.

Discussion and Insights

  • The Vocal Heuristic: Vocal attractiveness serves as a "heuristic cue." In default "System 1" processing (fast, intuitive), the brain uses the pleasantness of a voice as a proxy for the reliability of the content.
  • Adolescent Vulnerability: The study highlights that adolescents are particularly susceptible to environmental cues when making trust-based decisions, likely due to ongoing prefrontal cortex development.
  • Analytical Thinking as a Shield: Analytical thinking is not just a static trait; it can be activated. By forcing the brain into "System 2" (slow, effortful) processing, the influence of the vocal halo effect is significantly dampened.
  • Epistemic Vigilance: The findings suggest that epistemic trust is a dynamic balance. While a pleasant voice might open the door to communication, analytical processing acts as a "security guard" that checks the credentials of the incoming information.

Limitations and Future Work

While providing strong evidence for the moderation effect of analytical thinking, the study has limitations. It used a cross-sectional design; longitudinal studies are needed to see how this bias evolves into adulthood. Additionally, the research was conducted in Mandarin Chinese with neutral news summaries. Future work should explore how these effects manifest across different cultures, languages, and high-emotion scenarios, such as social media or political discourse.

Summary updated

Abstract

Epistemic trust is closely linked to the cognitive process of information containing knowledge toward the adaptation to complex social environments, and can be influenced by cognitive biases from external traits such as the voice of a stranger. This influence may be moderated by factors related to the individual's thinking style and the voice's emotional content. Considering that adolescence is an important stage in the social development of individuals, we investigate the influence of strangers' vocal attractiveness on adolescents' epistemic trust, as well as its moderators, via two studies based on trustworthiness ratings of technology news summaries contained in audio messages. Experimental results suggest that vocal attractiveness is a crucial cue promoting epistemic trust when adolescents make relevant decisions during interactions with strangers. In addition, successfully activating individuals' analytical thinking has been found to reduce this influence.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2026influence,
  author = {Cui Zhu and Yiran Zhang and Zan Liu and Dongjie Xie and Cheng Yang and Yanjie Su},
  title = {{Influence of strangers' vocal attractiveness on adolescents' epistemic trust: moderation effect of analytical thinking}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2026.1700278},
}
Figure