Influence of Spatial Inhomogeneity of Detector Temporal Responses on the Spectral Fidelity in Continuous Wave Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy

Zhensong Cao, Zhixin Li, Fei Xu, Yongqian Wu, Zixin Zhou, Zhaomin Tong, Weiguang Ma, Wenyue Zhu2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the spatial variations in a photodetector's response time can introduce significant errors in continuous wave cavity ringdown spectroscopy (CW-CRDS) measurements. By mapping these spatial response inhomogeneities, the researchers demonstrate that precise alignment of the photodetector is crucial for accurate spectral fidelity, especially for trace gas detection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cavity ringdown spectroscopy (CRDS) is a highly sensitive technique for measuring trace gases, relying on the precise measurement of light decay within an optical cavity. While advancements have been made to improve spectral resolution and sensitivity, a critical factor often overlooked is the photodetector's (PD) temporal response. PDs, especially traditional ones, can exhibit spatial variations in their response time, meaning they react differently depending on where the light hits their surface. This spatial inhomogeneity can distort the measured decay signal, leading to inaccurate spectral line shapes and values, and ultimately compromising the accuracy of gas concentration measurements. The problem this paper addresses is quantifying and understanding this spatial effect of PDs on CW-CRDS measurements to ensure reliable and precise results.

Methods

The researchers employed a systematic approach to characterize the spatial response of three different photodetectors (Newport models 1611 and 1811, and Thorlabs model PDA10CF-EC).

  1. Spatial Mapping of PD Response: They used a continuous wave (CW) fiber laser and an acousto-optic modulator (AOM) to create a pulsed laser beam. The PD was mounted on a high-precision 3D translation stage and moved across its surface in discrete steps. For each position, the transient response of the PD to the pulsed laser was recorded using a high-speed oscilloscope. This allowed them to create two-dimensional contour plots of both the initial shut-off amplitude and the temporal response (decay time) as a function of the PD's position.
  2. CW-CRDS Experiment Setup: A standard CW-CRDS setup was used, incorporating a high-finesse optical cavity and a frequency-stabilized laser. The transmitted light from the cavity was focused onto the PD. A threshold circuit was employed to trigger the data acquisition.
  3. Spatial Effect in CRDS: The PD was then translated within the CRDS setup, and ringdown decay signals were recorded at various positions. This allowed them to observe how the spatial variations in the PD's response directly influenced the measured ringdown time and initial shut-off amplitude in the CRDS experiment.
  4. Trace Gas Detection Analysis: To demonstrate the practical impact, they analyzed the spectral line shape of C2H2 gas at a specific wavenumber. By measuring the absorption profiles at different PD positions, they showed how the spatial effect led to variations in the calculated absorption coefficients.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments involved measurements of photodetector responses and CRDS signals, not pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • PDs are not uniform: Traditional photodetectors, even those with fast response times, exhibit significant spatial inhomogeneity in their temporal response. The closer the light hits the center of the PD, the faster the response.
  • Spatial effect directly impacts CRDS: This spatial inhomogeneity directly translates into distorted ringdown decay signals in CW-CRDS. This distortion can lead to underestimations of intracavity loss and inaccurate measurements of gas absorption.
  • Effective Detection Area (EDA): The paper highlights the concept of an "Effective Detection Area" (EDA) for PDs, which is the region where the detector provides optimal and fast response. This EDA is often slightly smaller than the manufacturer-specified active area.
  • Alignment is paramount: For accurate CW-CRDS measurements, it is crucial to align the PD so that the laser spot is entirely contained within this EDA. Misalignment can introduce significant errors.
  • Faster PDs still susceptible: Even with PDs boasting nanosecond response times, spatial effects can still be significant, especially when the laser spot size is comparable to or larger than the PD's EDA.

Key Results

  • Model 1611 (DC output): Exhibited slow response times in the microsecond range, with spatial variations evident.
  • Models 1811 and PDA10CF-EC (faster PDs): Showed much faster response times (ns range). Their spatial response plots revealed a clear trend of faster response towards the center. The initial shut-off amplitude also varied spatially, generally being higher for faster responses.
  • CRDS measurements: When the PD was misaligned in the CRDS setup, the measured ringdown times were observed to be longer, deviating from the true cavity decay time. This deviation was directly linked to the PD's slower response at off-center positions.
  • Trace gas analysis: In the C2H2 absorption measurement, PD misalignment led to different offsets in the ringdown time profiles, resulting in variations in the calculated peak absorption coefficients. The error was estimated to be around 1% for the best alignment, but could be larger with misalignment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited PD types: The study focused on three specific PD models. Further investigation into a wider range of PD types and manufacturers would be beneficial.
  • Laser spot size: While the laser spot size was controlled, its interaction with the PD's EDA could be further explored for different spot sizes and shapes.
  • Influence of other factors: The paper primarily focuses on spatial inhomogeneity. Future work could investigate the combined effects of spatial inhomogeneity with other factors like temperature, aging, or different laser wavelengths.
  • Automated alignment: The authors suggest that precise alignment is critical. Future work could explore automated alignment systems for CRDS setups to ensure optimal PD positioning.
  • Development of PDs with uniform response: The ideal solution would be the development of PDs with spatially uniform temporal responses, which would eliminate this source of error.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{cao2019influence,
  author = {Zhensong Cao and Zhixin Li and Fei Xu and Yongqian Wu and Zixin Zhou and Zhaomin Tong and Weiguang Ma and Wenyue Zhu},
  title = {{Influence of Spatial Inhomogeneity of Detector Temporal Responses on the Spectral Fidelity in Continuous Wave Cavity Ringdown Spectroscopy}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/s19235232},
}

Loading related content...

Figure