Influence of Propulsion Type on the Stratified Near Wake of an Axisymmetric Self-Propelled Body

Matthew C. Jones, Eric G. PatersonJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different propeller types (single, contra-rotating, and jet) affect the near-wake of a self-propelled vehicle in a stratified environment. The key finding is that contra-rotating propellers (CRP) are most effective at reducing the wake's potential energy by mitigating swirl, which is crucial for understanding how wakes evolve and interact with stratification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the wake of a self-propelled vehicle is critical for predicting its acoustic signature, its impact on nearby structures, and its overall hydrodynamic performance. A significant challenge is characterizing the "near wake"—the region immediately behind the vehicle where complex, propeller-induced structures like vortices dominate. This region transitions to a more uniform, "far wake" over a considerable distance. Adding to this complexity, many real-world scenarios involve stratified fluids (like the ocean, with varying temperature and salinity), which can significantly influence wake dynamics through buoyancy forces. While the general transition from near to far wake is known, the specific role of propeller-induced swirl in this process, especially within a stratified environment, remains less understood. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically comparing the near-wake evolution under three distinct propulsion schemes.

Methods

The researchers employed a sophisticated computational fluid dynamics (CFD) approach using the unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (URANS) equations. To model the propellers, they utilized the Actuator-Line (AL) model, which represents the propeller's force distribution as a line of body forces within the fluid domain. This is a computationally efficient alternative to fully resolving the propeller geometry. The simulations were performed using a custom OpenFOAM solver capable of handling salinity and temperature transport in a stratified environment, incorporating the UNESCO equation of state for seawater.

Three propulsion configurations were simulated:

  1. Single Propeller: A standard propeller.
  2. Contra-Rotating Propellers (CRP): Two propellers rotating in opposite directions, placed one behind the other.
  3. Zero-Swirl Jet: A uniform-velocity jet exhaust, serving as a baseline for a non-swirling propulsion system.

The study focused on analyzing vortical structures (using the Q-criterion), axial and swirl velocity profiles, temperature deviations, and integrated kinetic and potential energy budgets downstream of the body.

Datasets

The study utilized the "Iowa Body" hull geometry, which is a standard axisymmetric shape used in previous experimental studies (specifically by Hyun and Patel [2]). This choice allows for direct comparison with existing experimental data for a non-stratified case. No new experimental datasets were generated or used for training in this paper; the focus was on numerical simulation and analysis of the generated flow fields.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Swirl Dominates Near-Wake Structure: The presence and type of swirl generated by the propeller have a profound impact on the near-wake's vortical structures and velocity profiles.
  • CRP Attenuates Swirl and Potential Energy: Contra-rotating propellers significantly reduce the magnitude of swirl compared to a single propeller. This reduction in swirl directly leads to a decrease in the wake's potential energy, which is a key factor in how the wake interacts with stratification.
  • Transition to Axisymmetry: For both single and CRP configurations, the wake transitions from an unsteady, blade-resolved state to a temporally stationary and axisymmetric (or nearly so) state by about half a body length downstream. The jet configuration is inherently axisymmetric.
  • Unique CRP Wake Signature: The CRP configuration, due to the interaction of opposing blade forces, creates a distinct hexagonal shape in the velocity and temperature fields, unlike the axisymmetric profile of the single propeller.
  • Energy Budget Differences: The CRP configuration shows the most rapid decay of total kinetic energy and a significantly lower swirl kinetic energy compared to the single propeller, highlighting its efficiency in dissipating rotational energy.

Key Results

  • Vortical Structures: Single propellers exhibit clear helical root and tip vortices. CRPs show more complex interactions between the two propellers, leading to more intricate vortical structures. The jet shows negligible vortical structures.
  • Velocity Profiles: Circumferentially-averaged axial velocity profiles were similar for single and CRP, but distinct from the jet. Swirl velocity was significantly lower for the CRP (less than half that of the single propeller) and exhibited both positive and negative regions due to opposing blade forces. The jet had zero swirl.
  • Temperature Deviation (ΔT/ΔTR): The CRP's temperature deviation magnitude was less than half that of the single propeller. The jet had the smallest ΔT/ΔTR due to the absence of swirl. The unique hexagonal structure of the CRP wake influenced its temperature distribution.
  • Energy Evolution: For the single propeller, potential energy (PE) increased due to wake expansion and entrainment of the stratified fluid. For the CRP, PE did not grow and decayed similarly to the jet, indicating effective reduction of buoyancy effects. The CRP also showed the fastest decay of total kinetic energy (KE) by x/L = 1.5.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Reynolds Number: The simulations were conducted at a high Reynolds number (ReL = 3.1 × 10⁸), which is representative of full-scale ocean conditions. However, the specific turbulence model (k-ω SST) and wall functions used are approximations.
  • Stratification: The study used a linearly varying temperature stratification. Future work could explore different stratification profiles (e.g., step-like or more complex oceanic profiles) and their impact.
  • Far Wake: The study focused on the near wake (up to x/L = 1.5). Extending the simulations to the far wake would provide a more complete picture of wake evolution and interaction with stratification.
  • Body Geometry: The study used a simplified axisymmetric "Iowa Body" without appendages. Future research could investigate the influence of appendages on the wake dynamics for different propulsion types.
  • Propeller Design: The study used a specific propeller design. Investigating how variations in propeller pitch, blade count, or blade shape might affect the wake under different propulsion schemes would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

To better understand the influence of swirl on the thermally-stratified near wake of a self-propelled axisymmetric vehicle, three propulsor schemes were considered: a single propeller, contra-rotating propellers (CRP), and a zero-swirl, uniform-velocity jet. The propellers were modeled using an Actuator-Line model in an unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier–Stokes simulation, where the Reynolds number is R e L = 3.1 × 10 8 using the freestream velocity and body length. The authors previously showed good comparison to experimental data with this approach. Visualization of vortical structures shows the helical paths of blade-tip vortices from the single propeller as well as the complicated vortical interaction between contra-rotating blades. Comparison of instantaneous and time-averaged fields shows that temporally stationary fields emerge by half of a body length downstream. Circumferentially-averaged axial velocity profiles show similarities between the single propeller and CRP in contrast to the jet configuration. Swirl velocity of the CRP, however, was attenuated in comparison to that of the single propeller case. Mixed-patch contour maps illustrate the unique temperature distribution of each configuration as a consequence of their respective swirl profiles. Finally, kinetic and potential energy is integrated along downstream axial planes to reveal key differences between the configurations. The CRP configuration creates less potential energy by reducing swirl that would otherwise persist in the near wake of a single-propeller wake.
BibTeX
@article{jones2018influence,
  author = {Matthew C. Jones and Eric G. Paterson},
  title = {{Influence of Propulsion Type on the Stratified Near Wake of an Axisymmetric Self-Propelled Body}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse6020046},
}
Figure