TL;DR
This study investigates the impact of presurgical nasoalveolar molding (PNAM) on the dental arch and facial symmetry in infants with unilateral complete cleft lip and palate (UCCLP). While PNAM negatively affects dental arch width, it shows benefits for nasal and lip symmetry, though it can lead to a shorter, wider nostril shape on the cleft side.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Unilateral complete cleft lip and palate (UCCLP) is a complex congenital condition that significantly impacts a child's appearance, dental function, and overall quality of life. Surgical repair is challenging, and presurgical nasoalveolar molding (PNAM) is a common intervention aimed at improving surgical outcomes by reshaping the nose, lip, and alveolar bone before the primary surgery. However, the actual effectiveness and long-term consequences of PNAM remain a subject of debate within the medical community. Some studies suggest it improves symmetry and dental arch stability, while others indicate it might hinder facial development and negatively affect the maxillary dental arch. This paper aims to provide a clearer understanding of PNAM's effects by quantitatively assessing its impact on dental arch morphology and nasolabial symmetry in UCCLP patients.
Methods
The researchers employed advanced 3D imaging techniques to analyze the effects of PNAM. Dental arch morphology was assessed using data from a 3Shape scanning system, which generated digital 3D models of plaster casts. Specific landmarks on the teeth and dental arch were meticulously identified and measured to quantify arch width and symmetry. For nasolabial features, 3dMD stereophotography was utilized to capture high-resolution 3D facial scans. A standardized set of facial landmarks was identified on these scans to measure nasal and labial symmetry, as well as nostril dimensions. Statistical analysis, including paired and independent t-tests, was performed to compare measurements between groups (PNAM vs. non-PNAM) and sides (cleft vs. unaffected), with age stratification (under 7 and over 7 years old) to evaluate short-term and long-term effects.
Datasets
The study utilized data from 32 patients with UCCLP treated at the Hospital of Stomatology, Xi'an Jiaotong University, between 2011 and 2017. Of these, 27 provided complete dental arch models, and 30 had complete 3D facial photos. The patients were divided into two main groups: those who received PNAM treatment and those who did not. Each group was further subdivided based on age (<7 years and ≥7 years) to assess short-term and long-term outcomes. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study relied on clinical data collected from patients.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Dental Arch Compromise: PNAM appears to have a detrimental effect on the dental arch, particularly by limiting the transverse width of the maxillary canine-to-midline. This suggests a trade-off between improved nasolabial aesthetics and potential dental arch development.
- Age-Dependent Symmetry Improvements: PNAM shows a nuanced effect on symmetry. It improves nasal alae symmetry in older children (≥7 years) and lip symmetry in younger children (<7 years). This indicates that the timing of PNAM's benefits might vary with age.
- Nostril Alteration: A notable finding is that PNAM treatment leads to a shorter and wider nostril shape on the cleft side. This is an unexpected outcome that warrants further investigation, as it contrasts with the general goal of improving nasal aesthetics.
- Multidisciplinary Consideration: The findings underscore the need for a careful, multidisciplinary approach when deciding on PNAM, as its advantages in symmetry must be weighed against its negative impacts on dental arch form and potential alterations in nostril shape.
Key Results
- Dental Arch Width: PNAM negatively impacted both short-term and long-term dental arch shape. Specifically, the canine-to-midline transverse width on the cleft side was significantly reduced in PNAM-treated patients compared to those without PNAM, especially in younger children.
- Nasal Alae Symmetry: In patients over 7 years old, PNAM treatment resulted in improved symmetry of the nasal alae.
- Lip Symmetry: In patients under 7 years old, PNAM treatment improved lip symmetry.
- Nostril Morphology: Patients treated with PNAM exhibited a shorter and wider nostril shape on the cleft side compared to those without PNAM.
- Overall Dental Arch Width: No significant difference in overall dental arch width was observed between PNAM and non-PNAM groups across all ages.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations. The sample size, while adequate for initial findings, could be larger to enhance the generalizability of the results. Factors such as socioeconomic status, parental education, and compliance with treatment were not controlled for and could influence outcomes. The authors suggest that future research should consider these variables and potentially employ a prospective study design to better understand the long-term effects and influencing factors of PNAM treatment. Further investigation is also needed to understand the mechanisms behind the observed changes in nostril morphology.
Summary updated