Influence of Label Design and Country of Origin Information in Wines on Consumers' Visual, Sensory, and Emotional Responses

Chang Liu, Chetan Sharma, Qiqi Xu, Claudia Gonzalez Viejo, Sigfredo Fuentes, Damir D. TorricoSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how wine label design, specifically the inclusion of "New Zealand" as a country of origin (COO) indicator (textual or symbolic), influences consumer perception. Using eye-tracking and sensory evaluation, the research found that while label design impacts visual attention and purchase intent, the effect on actual taste perception is subtle, suggesting labels are powerful but not definitive in shaping wine appreciation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The wine industry, like many consumer goods sectors, relies heavily on marketing and branding to differentiate products. Country of Origin (COO) information has long been a strategy to signal quality and evoke specific consumer expectations. However, the precise mechanisms by which COO, especially when presented visually on a label, influences consumer responses – from initial visual engagement to emotional and sensory perceptions – remain complex. This paper aims to disentangle these influences by examining how different presentations of "New Zealand" as a COO on wine labels affect consumers' visual attention, emotional responses, and taste evaluations, particularly in the context of e-commerce where visual cues are paramount.

Methods

The study employed a two-part experimental design:

  • Study 1: Eye-Tracking and Emotional Response: Participants (n=55) viewed four wine labels with varying COO information (textual "New Zealand," a fern logo representing New Zealand, or no COO information). Eye-tracking technology (Gazepoint GP3) was used to record visual attention patterns (time to first fixation, fixation duration, fixation count) on specific areas of interest (AOIs) on the labels. Simultaneously, facial expressions were analyzed using iMotions software (with Affectiva and Realeyes algorithms) to capture subconscious emotional responses. Participants also provided self-reported ratings for overall liking and purchase intention.
  • Study 2: Sensory Evaluation and Purchase Intent: A separate group of participants (n=72) blind-tasted the same wine (Pinot Noir) presented with the different label variations (including a no-label control). They then answered questionnaires on acceptability, sensory attributes (using CATA - Check All That Apply), emotions, and purchase intent.

Multivariate statistical analyses, including Principal Component Analysis (PCA) for Study 1 and Multiple Factor Analysis (MFA) for Study 2, were used to explore the relationships between visual attention, emotional responses, sensory perceptions, and purchase intent.

Datasets

The study did not utilize pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generated its own data through controlled experiments involving human participants. The stimuli were four distinct wine labels designed for the study, and the product was a specific Pinot Noir wine from Akarua Winery Ltd.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Visual Hierarchy Matters: The "photo" (central image) and "brand name" on the wine labels consistently captured the most visual attention, regardless of COO information. This suggests a fundamental visual hierarchy where imagery and brand identity are primary attention-grabbers.
  • Logo vs. Text for COO: While both textual and symbolic (logo) COO information influenced visual attention, the logo (specifically the fern) seemed to be more effective in drawing attention and potentially facilitating gaze transfer to other label elements.
  • Subtle Taste Influence: Despite significant differences in visual attention and some self-reported emotional responses, the actual taste perception of the wine was only marginally affected by the label design. This highlights a disconnect between visual appeal and gustatory experience.
  • Labels Shape Appreciation: Even when the wine taste was identical, labels with COO information (especially the logo) showed a tendency towards less positive associations with baseline (no label) appreciation, suggesting labels can influence, and sometimes even detract from, inherent product appreciation.
  • E-commerce Implications: The findings are particularly relevant for online wine sales, where visual cues on labels are the primary means of product evaluation before purchase.

Key Results

  • Eye-Tracking:
    • Time to first fixation (TFF) was significantly lower for COO information presented as text ("New Zealand") compared to labels without COO.
  • The "photo" AOI had the highest average fixation duration and fixation count across all labels.
  • Logos, compared to textual COO, showed a trend towards longer engagement (first fixation duration).
  • Sensory and Emotional Responses:
    • In Study 2, only a few sensory attributes (chemical flavor, sweet taste, heat mouthfeel) were significantly affected by COO information.
  • No statistically significant differences were found in self-reported emotions after tasting, except for "neutral."
  • Purchase Intent: Origin information marginally affected purchase intent, with some label variations showing slightly higher intent than others, though the effect was not consistently strong.
  • Multivariate Analysis: PCA revealed that visual attention metrics (like TFF, FC) and emotional responses (like Sadness, Joy) were interconnected. The "no script" label was associated with overall liking and purchase intention, while the "logo" label was linked to emotions like surprise and fear.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Participant Demographics: The study participants were primarily university staff and students, which may not fully represent the broader wine consumer market.
  • Wine Type: The study focused on Pinot Noir; results might differ for other wine varietals.
  • Controlled Environment: The experiments were conducted in sensory booths, which may not perfectly replicate real-world purchasing or consumption environments.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further research to explore the connections between taste perception, emotions, label elements, and eye-tracking more deeply. They also propose investigating the influence of other label design elements and exploring how these findings can be applied to a wider range of food products and for e-commerce platforms.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liu2022influence,
  author = {Chang Liu and Chetan Sharma and Qiqi Xu and Claudia Gonzalez Viejo and Sigfredo Fuentes and Damir D. Torrico},
  title = {{Influence of Label Design and Country of Origin Information in Wines on Consumers' Visual, Sensory, and Emotional Responses}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22062158},
}
Figure