Influence of kidney replacement therapy on indirect calorimetry in critically ill patients

Alois Knoll, Sirak Petros, Bastian Pasieka, Lorenz WeidhaseEuropean 2025 · DOI

Abstract: Clinical trial registration: NCT04599569. This prospective study evaluates the impact of continuous veno-venous hemodialysis (CVVHD) and slow extended daily dialysis (SLEDD) on the accuracy of indirect calorimetry (IC) in mechanically ventilated ICU patients.

Introduction

Accurately determining the caloric requirements of critically ill patients is a cornerstone of intensive care management. Both underfeeding and overfeeding are associated with adverse outcomes, including muscle wasting and metabolic complications. Indirect Calorimetry (IC) remains the gold standard for determining Resting Energy Expenditure (REE) by measuring oxygen consumption ($VO_2$) and carbon dioxide production ($VCO_2$).

A persistent concern in clinical practice is whether Kidney Replacement Therapy (KRT) interferes with IC accuracy. Since KRT involves gas exchange across a semi-permeable membrane, there is a theoretical risk that $CO_2$ could be removed via the dialysate, leading the IC—which only monitors pulmonary gas exchange—to underestimate the patient's true metabolic rate. This study investigates whether these theoretical concerns translate into clinically significant errors.

Methods and Patient Population

The researchers conducted a prospective observational study at the University Hospital Leipzig, involving 100 mechanically ventilated adult patients with acute kidney injury. The study focused on two prevalent KRT modalities: Continuous Veno-Venous Hemodialysis (CVVHD) with regional citrate anticoagulation and Slow Extended Daily Dialysis (SLEDD) with systemic heparin.

To ensure robust data, the study employed a crossover-style "scenario" design. In Scenario 1, IC was measured during KRT and again one hour after cessation. In Scenario 2, measurements were taken before KRT initiation and one hour after it began. Throughout these periods, clinical variables such as ventilator settings, sedation, and nutritional intake were strictly controlled.

Baseline characteristics of the study cohort (N=100).

As shown in the patient characteristics, the cohort represented a high-acuity population with significant organ dysfunction (mean SOFA score 11.3).

Key Insights

The study's findings challenge the assumption that KRT significantly alters pulmonary $CO_2$ excretion. The authors suggest that the body’s internal buffering systems, combined with the administration of bicarbonate or citrate via the dialysate, effectively compensate for any $CO_2$ lost through the dialysis circuit.

Additionally, the metabolic impact of citrate—a potential "hidden" energy source—was found to be negligible. Despite providing approximately 135-200 kcal/day, citrate did not acutely shift the Respiratory Quotient (RQ) or REE. Thermal stability, maintained through pre-warmed dialysate, also ensured that metabolic rates were not skewed by shivering or temperature-induced metabolic changes.

Results

The primary analysis revealed no statistically significant differences in metabolic parameters between "on-KRT" and "off-KRT" states.

Metabolic variables during and without kidney replacement therapy (KRT).

Key findings include:

  • CVVHD Stability: Median REE was 8029 kJ/d during therapy versus 7814 kJ/d without therapy ($p = 0.75$).
  • SLEDD Stability: Median REE was 9258 kJ/d during therapy versus 9269 kJ/d without therapy ($p = 0.63$).
  • Substrate Oxidation: The Respiratory Quotient (RQ) remained stable at approximately 0.75 across both groups, suggesting no significant shift in the type of fuel (carbohydrates vs. fats) being oxidized.
  • Sequence Independence: The timing of the measurements (before vs. after KRT) did not influence the results ($p = 0.69$), further validating the stability of the metabolic measurements.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study provides strong evidence that common forms of KRT, specifically CVVHD and SLEDD, do not meaningfully distort indirect calorimetry results in critically ill patients. For clinicians, these results simplify metabolic monitoring: IC can be performed at any time without the need to pause dialysis or apply complex mathematical corrections.

While these results are robust for the modalities studied, further research is needed to determine if they apply to Continuous Veno-Venous Hemofiltration (CVVH), where higher convection rates might alter $CO_2$ removal. Future studies incorporating direct measurement of $CO_2$ in effluent dialysate could provide a more granular understanding of the physiological mechanisms at play.

Summary updated

Abstract

gov ID: NCT04599569.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{knoll2025influence,
  author = {Alois Knoll and Sirak Petros and Bastian Pasieka and Lorenz Weidhase},
  title = {{Influence of kidney replacement therapy on indirect calorimetry in critically ill patients}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1038/s41430-025-01643-9},
}
Figure