TL;DR
This study expands the classic Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB) to decode the psychological drivers of tenant loyalty in the housing market. By analyzing 300 tenants in Kaohsiung City, Taiwan, researchers found that while satisfaction and social norms are powerful anchors, situational factors—like living near family—can unexpectedly weaken the link between a tenant's positive attitude and their long-term loyalty.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In a maturing rental market, landlords face a "leaky bucket" problem: finding new tenants is expensive, but keeping existing ones (loyalty) is the key to sustainable management. While we know a lot about why people buy cars or choose vacation spots, the rental industry has been relatively under-researched from a psychological perspective.
The authors address a critical gap: What actually makes a tenant stay? Is it just about the price, or do deeper psychological layers like cognition (what they think), affection (how they feel), and conation (their proactive drive) play a role? Furthermore, the paper explores how "situational influences"—specifically the proximity of friends and family—act as a "moderator" that can change how much a tenant's personal attitude actually dictates their behavior.
Methods
The researchers developed an expanded conceptual framework based on the Theory of Planned Behavior (TPB). They moved beyond the standard model by:
- Breaking down "Attitude": Instead of treating attitude as a monolith, they looked at its antecedents: Cognition (perceived service/risk), Affection (emotional bond), and Conation (the innate motivation to rent).
- Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): This statistical technique allowed them to estimate the complex, multi-layered relationships between variables simultaneously.
- Moderation Analysis: They tested how the relationship between attitude and loyalty changes depending on whether a tenant has family or friends living nearby.
Datasets
The study relied on primary data collected via a structured questionnaire:
- Participants: 315 housing tenants in Kaohsiung City, Taiwan (300 valid responses used).
- Sampling: Convenience sampling across eight administrative districts.
- Demographics: The sample was fairly balanced (54% female, 50% aged 21–30), with a majority being single (68%) and holding undergraduate degrees (60%).
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Psychological Trinity: The study confirms that a tenant's attitude isn't just a random preference. It is built on three pillars: what they know about the service (Cognition), their emotional attachment to the space (Affection), and their goal-oriented drive to live there (Conation).
- The "Family" Paradox: One of the most interesting findings is the moderating effect of living near family. You might assume that having family nearby makes you more loyal because you like the area. However, the data shows that the presence of nearby family diminishes the influence of a tenant's personal attitude on their loyalty. In other words, if your family is close by, you might stay even if you don't particularly "like" the apartment, or you might leave despite liking it because family needs override personal preference.
- Social Pressure Matters: "Subjective norms"—the opinions of significant others—had a higher influence on tenant loyalty than even "Perceived Behavioral Control" (the tenant's sense of how easy it is to rent). What your friends and family think about your living situation is a massive factor in whether you sign that lease renewal.
Key Results
- H1–H3 (Attitude Drivers): Cognition, Affection, and Conation all significantly and positively influenced a tenant's attitude toward their tenancy.
- H4–H6 (The Satisfaction-Loyalty Link): A positive attitude leads to higher satisfaction and loyalty. Crucially, satisfied tenants are significantly more likely to recommend the landlord to others (word-of-mouth).
- H7–H8 (TPB Core): Both perceived behavioral control and subjective norms were strong predictors of loyalty.
- The Moderation Effect (H9): For tenants without family nearby, the path coefficient from Attitude to Loyalty was 0.741. For those with family nearby, it dropped to 0.447. This significant reduction (-0.294) proves that external social anchors can decouple personal feelings from actual staying behavior.
Limitations and Future Work
- One-Sided Perspective: The study focuses entirely on the "demander" (the tenant). The authors suggest future research should look at the "supplier" (the landlord) to see how management styles align with these psychological needs.
- Missing Policy Variables: The model did not account for external economic factors like government rent subsidies or tax rebates, which could significantly impact "Perceived Behavioral Control."
- Geographic Specificity: The findings are rooted in Kaohsiung City. Cultural differences regarding family proximity and rental norms in other countries might yield different results.
Summary updated