Influence of gender on diaphragm thickness using a method for determining intima media thickness in healthy young adults

Masayoshi Oguri, Tohru Okanishi, Takuya Ikeguchi, Kaoru Ogo, Sotaro Kanai, Yoshihiro Maegaki, Shinichi Wada, Takashi HimotoBmc Medical Imaging 2022 · DOI

Introduction

The diaphragm is the primary muscle of respiration, and its assessment is crucial in managing conditions such as neuromuscular disorders, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), and in determining the readiness of patients to be weaned from mechanical ventilation. While ultrasound is a widely used, non-invasive tool for evaluating diaphragm function, manual measurements often suffer from inter-operator variability.

This study, published in BMC Medical Imaging, explores a novel application of automated vascular imaging software—specifically "Intima Media Thickness" (IMT) software—to measure diaphragm thickness. By repurposing this technology, researchers aimed to establish a more objective and reproducible metric for respiratory health and to investigate sex-specific differences in diaphragm dynamics among healthy young adults.

Methodology

The study involved 29 healthy volunteers (16 females, 13 males) aged 19–34. Researchers used a high-frequency linear ultrasound probe positioned in the intercostal space to capture images of the diaphragm.

The core innovation of this study was the use of automated IMT software, typically used to measure carotid artery walls, to calculate diaphragm thickness. The software automatically identifies the edges of the diaphragm and calculates the mean thickness across three points: a central point and two points located 10 mm on either side.

Measurements were recorded at two specific respiratory phases:

  1. Functional Residual Capacity (FRC): The volume of air remaining in the lungs after a normal, passive exhalation.
  2. Total Lung Capacity (TLC): The volume of air in the lungs after a maximal inhalation.
Fig. 1: Representative ultrasound images of the diaphragm at total lung capacity (a) and functional residual capacity (b), illustrating the three-point measurement method using IMT software.

From these measurements, a "thickening ratio" (or change ratio) was calculated to represent the percentage increase in muscle thickness from rest to full expansion. These ultrasound metrics were then correlated with traditional pulmonary function tests, including spirometry and maximal respiratory pressures.

Results

The study revealed several significant findings regarding sex-specific diaphragm characteristics:

  • Resting Thickness Paradox: Males were found to have significantly thinner diaphragms at rest (FRC) compared to females (1.2 ± 0.3 mm vs. 1.5 ± 0.2 mm, $p < 0.001$). This suggests that baseline thickness does not directly correlate with body size or overall muscle mass in this context.
  • Dynamic Performance: Despite having thinner diaphragms at rest, males exhibited a significantly higher thickening ratio during deep inspiration (67.2% vs. 57.2%, $p < 0.001$). This indicates that the dynamic contractile ability of the diaphragm is a more critical indicator of performance than static thickness.
  • Sex-Specific Correlations: In male participants, the diaphragm thickening ratio showed a strong positive correlation with Forced Vital Capacity ($r = 0.57$) and Maximal Expiratory Pressure ($r = 0.71$). Interestingly, these correlations were not statistically significant in the female cohort.
  • Methodological Reliability: The IMT method demonstrated high reproducibility, with an intra-observer correlation coefficient of 0.856, validating it as a reliable tool for clinical use.

Discussion

The successful repurposing of vascular edge-detection software for musculoskeletal imaging represents a significant step toward more automated and objective diagnostic tools. The high reproducibility of the IMT method suggests it could reduce the subjectivity inherent in manual ultrasound measurements.

The observed sex differences are particularly noteworthy. The lack of correlation between diaphragm thickening and respiratory strength in females suggests potential physiological differences, such as a greater reliance on accessory respiratory muscles during maximal effort in women. However, the authors also note that the smaller sample size of females (n=16) might have limited the statistical power to detect such correlations.

Limitations and Future Work

The study's primary limitations include its small sample size and the specific demographic (young, healthy Japanese adults). The findings may not be directly generalizable to older populations, different ethnic groups, or patients with respiratory pathologies. Furthermore, as the first study to apply the IMT method to the diaphragm, there is no existing comparative literature using this specific automated approach.

Future research will likely focus on applying this automated method to elderly populations or patients in intensive care to see if it can predict successful ventilator weaning.

Conclusion

The application of automated IMT software provides a precise and reproducible method for assessing diaphragm thickness and dynamics. The discovery that males have thinner diaphragms at rest but higher thickening ratios highlights the importance of dynamic measurements over static ones. This automated approach holds promise for clinical applications, though further research in diverse patient populations is required.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{oguri2022influence,
  author = {Masayoshi Oguri and Tohru Okanishi and Takuya Ikeguchi and Kaoru Ogo and Sotaro Kanai and Yoshihiro Maegaki and Shinichi Wada and Takashi Himoto},
  title = {{Influence of gender on diaphragm thickness using a method for determining intima media thickness in healthy young adults}},
  journal = {Bmc Medical Imaging},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1186/s12880-022-00748-y},
}
Figure