Influence of Copper Particles on Breakdown Voltage and Frequency-Dependent Dielectric Property of Vegetable Insulating Oil

Jing Zhang, Feipeng Wang, Jian Li, Hehuan Ran, Dali HuangEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how copper particles affect the electrical insulation properties of vegetable-based transformer oils. The research reveals that while copper particles degrade both vegetable and mineral oils' breakdown voltage, vegetable oil shows greater resilience due to its higher viscosity, offering a potential advantage for transformer reliability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Transformer insulating oils are critical for preventing electrical breakdowns. However, conductive particles, such as copper, can significantly degrade these oils' insulating capabilities, leading to transformer failures. While the impact of particles on traditional mineral insulating oils is well-studied, vegetable-based oils are emerging as a more environmentally friendly alternative. This paper addresses the knowledge gap regarding how micrometer-sized copper particles specifically influence the breakdown voltage and frequency-dependent dielectric properties of vegetable insulating oil, comparing it to mineral oil to understand the differences and inform future standards.

Methods

The researchers prepared samples of both vegetable insulating oil and traditional mineral insulating oil. These oils were then intentionally contaminated with copper particles of varying sizes and concentrations.

  • Breakdown Voltage Testing: The AC breakdown voltage of the contaminated oils was measured using an automatic electrical breakdown tester. The tests were conducted at 50 Hz with a specific electrode gap and voltage ramp rate, following ASTM standards but with adjusted parameters. Multiple measurements were taken for each sample to ensure statistical reliability, and the data was analyzed using a two-parameter Weibull distribution to characterize the breakdown voltage and its dispersion.
  • Frequency-Dependent Dielectric Property Measurement: The volume resistivity, relative permittivity, and dissipation factor of the contaminated oils were measured across a wide frequency range (10⁻² Hz to 10⁶ Hz) using a broadband dielectric spectrometer. This allowed the researchers to observe how these properties changed with both frequency and the concentration of copper particles.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses prepared samples of vegetable and mineral insulating oils contaminated with copper particles.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Vegetable Oil's Resilience: Vegetable oil, despite being affected by copper particles, shows a less significant decrease in breakdown voltage compared to mineral oil. This is attributed to its higher viscosity, which impedes particle movement and the formation of "weak links" that lead to breakdown.
  • Particle Size Matters: Larger copper particles have a more pronounced negative impact on the breakdown voltage, likely due to their greater ability to induce and carry charges, facilitating the formation of conductive bridges.
  • Frequency Dependence is Crucial: The influence of copper particles on dielectric properties (resistivity, permittivity, dissipation factor) is highly dependent on frequency. At low frequencies, particle contamination has a significant effect, but this influence diminishes considerably at higher frequencies.
  • Mechanism of Degradation: Copper particles, when subjected to an electric field, become charged and can form "chains" or "weak links" across the oil gap. These links distort the electric field, initiating partial discharges and ultimately leading to breakdown.
  • Modeling Copper Particles: The study models charged copper particles as polar molecules, contributing to polarization effects within the insulating oil. This helps explain the observed changes in relative permittivity.

Key Results

  • Breakdown Voltage: The AC breakdown voltage of both vegetable and mineral insulating oils decreases with an increasing number of copper particles. This decrease is more pronounced with larger particle sizes. Vegetable oil's breakdown voltage reduction rate was found to be slower than that of mineral oil.
  • Volume Resistivity: Volume resistivity decreases with increasing copper particle concentration and generally decreases with increasing frequency, with a more dramatic drop at lower frequencies.
  • Relative Permittivity: Relative permittivity increases with increasing copper volumetric concentration, particularly at low frequencies. It also decreases with increasing frequency.
  • Dissipation Factor: The dissipation factor increases with increasing copper volumetric concentration, especially at low frequencies (below 10⁻¹ Hz), where conduction loss is dominant. It decreases with increasing frequency.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Particle Size Range: The study focused on micrometer-sized copper particles. The behavior of nanoparticles or larger particles might differ.
  • Particle Type: Only copper particles were investigated. Other metallic or non-metallic contaminants could have different effects.
  • Oil Types: While vegetable oil and one type of mineral oil were tested, the results might vary for different formulations of vegetable oils or other types of mineral oils.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research is needed to establish specific particle number limits for vegetable insulating oil in power transformers, given its distinct behavior compared to mineral oil. Investigating the combined effects of particles with other contaminants like water or oxidation products would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

The insulating performance of oil is vulnerable to particles especially the conductive particles. This paper investigated the influence of copper particles of micrometer size on the breakdown strength and frequency-dependent properties of vegetable oil. The AC breakdown voltage of contaminated vegetable oil with copper particles of different numbers (ranging from 103 to 106) was measured. The frequency-dependent dielectric properties including volume resistivity, relative permittivity and dissipation factor of the contaminated vegetable oil with copper particles of various volumetric concentrations (0.011%, 0.056% and 0.112%) were measured. Identical experiments were conducted with mineral oil for comparison. Results show that the AC breakdown voltage of vegetable oil decreases with the increase of copper particle concentration. The mineral oil exhibits a similar trend, but the influence of copper particles on the AC breakdown voltage of vegetable oil is less significant than that on mineral oil because of its greater viscosity. The relative permittivity and dissipation factor increase with increasing copper volumetric concentration while the volume resistivity decreases. The influence of copper particles on them is significant at low frequencies and this influence becomes inconspicuous as the frequency increases. Similar results were observed for mineral oil.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2017influence,
  author = {Jing Zhang and Feipeng Wang and Jian Li and Hehuan Ran and Dali Huang},
  title = {{Influence of Copper Particles on Breakdown Voltage and Frequency-Dependent Dielectric Property of Vegetable Insulating Oil}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10070938},
}
Figure