Influence Mechanisms of Multidimensional Risk Communication Strategies on Public Altruistic Protective Behavior: Evidence from Public Health Emergencies

Xu Yun-peng, Shuanglei Wu, Linxiu Jiang, Shuning WangResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Altruistic protective behavior is pivotal to community resilience during public health emergencies, yet prior research has rarely integrated how multidimensional risk communication strategies shape such behavior. Drawing on the protective action decision model and risk communication theory, we examine how information sources, communication content, narrative style, and communication media influence public altruistic protective behavior through risk perception, and whether trust in authoritative information sources conditions these effects. Methods: We conducted a cross-sectional online survey in mainland China (October–December 2023) using stratified site selection across 11 provincial-level regions. After data cleaning, 1,417 valid responses were retained. Validated multi-item scales were adapted to the Chinese context. Analyses included hierarchical ordinary least squares regressions, mediation tests with bias-corrected bootstrapping, and moderation tests. Results: Each communication dimension—information sources, communication content, narrative style, and communication media—was positively associated with altruistic protective behavior. Risk perception exerted a significant positive mediating effect. Trust in authoritative information sources negatively moderated the path from information sources to risk perception, indicating a “high-trust attenuation” pattern. Conclusions: Findings extend PADM to the collective-action domain by specifying how multidimensional risk communication promotes altruistic protection via risk perception and how trust calibrates source effects.

Introduction

During public health emergencies, governments rely on "multiactor co-governance." This requires the public to do more than just protect themselves; it necessitates altruistic behavior—donating money, volunteering, or sharing resources—to build community resilience. While most existing research focuses on self-protective behaviors (like wearing a mask for one's own safety), this study investigates how multidimensional risk communication drives prosocial actions. By analyzing survey data from 1,417 respondents in China, the researchers identify risk perception as a vital psychological bridge and uncover a "high-trust attenuation" effect, where deep trust in authorities can actually reduce the influence of non-official information sources.

Methodology

The researchers conducted a cross-sectional online survey in mainland China between October and December 2023, collecting 1,417 valid responses across 11 provincial-level regions. The sample was stratified to balance economic zones and latitudinal regions. Measurement scales for variables like "Risk Perception" and "Altruistic Protective Behavior" were adapted from established international literature and localized for the Chinese context, as shown in the table below.

Measurement items for risk communication dimensions, risk perception, and altruistic behavior.

To analyze this multidimensional data, the study employed several statistical techniques:

  • Weighting: A combination of the Entropy Method (EM) and the CRITIC method was used to create a composite "Risk Communication Index."
  • Mediation Analysis: Using the PROCESS macro (Model 4), the team tested if "Risk Perception" acts as the mediator between receiving a message and acting on it.
  • Moderation Analysis: Using PROCESS (Model 1), they examined how "Trust in Authoritative Information Sources" (TIAIS) changes the relationship between information and perception.

Key Insights and Results

The "High-Trust Attenuation" Effect

One of the paper's most significant findings is that high trust in government and experts can create an "information focus effect." When the public has very high trust in authoritative sources, they become less sensitive to information from mass media or interpersonal networks. In this context, trust acts as a filter that diminishes the impact of secondary information sources on how people perceive risk.

Narrative and Content Hierarchy

  • Storytelling vs. Data: While data-based styles (graphs and statistics) are persuasive, story-based narratives—focusing on specific people and experiences—had a more pronounced effect on driving altruistic behavior by evoking empathy.
  • Institutional Response: Information regarding how the government is handling the crisis was a stronger driver of altruism than simple case counts or preventive instructions. Knowing the "system" is working encourages people to contribute to it.
  • Media Influence: The Internet emerged as the most influential medium, serving as a primary channel for verifying and reprocessing information from all other sources.

The Role of Risk Perception

Risk communication does not trigger altruism directly. It first heightens a person's perception of risk, which then creates the psychological tension necessary to motivate prosocial action. Overall, risk communication was a significant positive predictor of altruistic behavior (β = 0.648, p < 0.01).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the data is self-reported, which may lead to over-reporting of altruistic intentions. Furthermore, the cross-sectional design shows correlation rather than definitive causality over time. The findings are also deeply embedded in the Chinese context of high institutional trust. Future work should incorporate actual behavior tracking (e.g., real donation data) and longitudinal studies to see how these communication effects evolve as a crisis progresses.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background Altruistic protective behavior is pivotal to community resilience during public health emergencies, yet prior research has rarely integrated how multidimensional risk communication strategies shape such behavior. Drawing on the protective action decision model and risk communication theory, we examine how information sources, communication content, narrative style, and communication media influence public altruistic protective behavior through risk perception, and whether trust in authoritative information sources conditions these effects. Methods We conducted a cross-sectional online survey in mainland China (October–December 2023) using stratified site selection across 11 provincial-level regions. After data cleaning, 1,417 valid responses were retained. Validated multi-item scales were adapted to the Chinese context. Analyses included hierarchical ordinary least squares regressions, mediation tests with bias-corrected bootstrapping (PROCESS Model 4; 5,000 resamples), and moderation tests (PROCESS Model 1; 5,000 resamples). Multicollinearity and common-method bias were assessed (VIFs &lt; 5; Harman single-factor test). Results Each communication dimension—information sources, communication content, narrative style, and communication media—was positively associated with altruistic protective behavior,albeit with heterogeneous effect sizes across dimensions. Risk perception exerted a significant positive mediating effect between risk communication and public altruistic protective behavior. Trust in authoritative information sources negatively moderated the path from information sources to risk perception, indicating a “high-trust attenuation” pattern whereby strong trust in authoritative sources reduces the incremental impact of non-authoritative sources on perceived risk. Conclusions Findings extend PADM to the collective-action domain by specifying how multidimensional risk communication promotes altruistic protection via risk perception and how trust calibrates source effects. Practice implications include building coordinated, multi-source messaging matrices; tailoring high-precision content to audience segments; combining story-based and data-based narratives; and orchestrating cross-media delivery.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yunpeng2025influence,
  author = {XU Yun-peng and Shuanglei Wu and Linxiu Jiang and Shuning Wang},
  title = {{Influence Mechanisms of Multidimensional Risk Communication Strategies on Public Altruistic Protective Behavior: Evidence from Public Health Emergencies}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-7506021/v1},
}
Figure