Infectious Diseases Spreading on an Adaptive Metapopulation Network

Shanshan Feng, Zhen JinIEEE Access 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an "adaptive metapopulation network" model to study the impact of two-way travel restrictions on the global spread of infectious diseases. By defining a risk indicator based on local infection density, the model dynamically adjusts network connections, effectively simulating travel bans. Simulations show that these adaptive two-way restrictions are significantly more effective at curbing global spread than one-way restrictions, with earlier intervention and lower risk thresholds yielding better results.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid globalization and interconnectedness of the world have made emerging infectious diseases a significant threat, as evidenced by events like the black death and the recent COVID-19 pandemic. While travel restrictions are a common response, their effectiveness, particularly for two-way restrictions (akin to lockdowns), on a global scale is complex. Existing research often focuses on network structures or one-way travel restrictions. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating how dynamic, two-way travel restrictions, triggered by local risk levels, can be modeled and how they compare to other control strategies in preventing the global spread of infectious diseases.

Methods

The core of this research is the development of an adaptive metapopulation network model. This model builds upon the standard Susceptible-Infectious-Removed (SIR) epidemiological model. The novelty lies in how the network's connectivity (representing travel) is dynamically altered:

  • Risk Indicator ($\rho$): A threshold value is defined based on the relative density of infectious individuals within a subpopulation ($I_i/N_i$).
  • Subpopulation Categorization: Based on $\rho$, subpopulations are classified as risk-free, low-risk, or high-risk.
  • Adaptive Network: When a subpopulation reaches a "high-risk" state after a specified intervention time ($T_0$), the links (representing travel) to its neighbors are dynamically broken (simulating two-way travel restrictions). These links are re-established only when the subpopulation returns to a "low-risk" state.
  • Mathematical Analysis: The paper derives the basic reproduction number ($R_0$) and analyzes the model's equilibria and final size.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: The model is simulated on two types of networks (Poisson and power-law degree distributions) to compare the effectiveness of different control strategies: "In-Out" (two-way restrictions), "Out" (preventing movement from infectious subpopulations), "In" (preventing movement into infectious subpopulations), and "None" (no restrictions).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study uses simulated data generated from the proposed model on synthetically generated network structures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Restrictions are Key: The effectiveness of travel restrictions is not static. An "adaptive" approach, where restrictions are triggered by local risk and can be lifted when risk subsides, is crucial.
  • Two-Way Restrictions Dominate: Two-way travel restrictions (In-Out), simulated by the adaptive metapopulation network, are demonstrably superior in suppressing global disease spread compared to one-way restrictions.
  • Early Intervention Matters: The timing of intervention ($T_0$) is critical. Earlier implementation of two-way travel restrictions leads to significantly better outcomes in curbing global spread.
  • Risk Threshold is Important: A low risk indicator threshold ($\rho$) is necessary to trigger timely interventions. A threshold of $\rho = 0.004$ was identified as a critical point for global spread in their simulations.
  • Network Heterogeneity Amplifies Spread: The study highlights that networks with higher heterogeneity (like power-law distributions) tend to promote faster and wider global spread of infectious diseases, even with control measures in place.

Key Results

  • The basic reproduction number ($R_0$) is found to be independent of human mobility, depending only on disease parameters ($\beta$ and $\gamma$).
  • Simulations show that "In-Out" (two-way travel restrictions) can reduce the final size of an epidemic to less than 1% of the "None" (no restriction) case.
  • "Out" restrictions are moderately effective, reducing the final size by about 60% compared to "None."
  • "In" restrictions are found to be the worst, potentially accelerating global spread.
  • A critical risk indicator threshold of $\rho \approx 0.004$ was identified, beyond which global spread becomes more likely.
  • Intervention times ($T_0$) earlier than 60 days showed significant benefits; beyond this point, the adaptive network's effectiveness diminishes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uniform Intervention Time: The current model assumes a single intervention time ($T_0$) for all subpopulations. Future work could explore varying intervention times based on individual subpopulation onset times and delays.
  • All-or-Nothing Restrictions: The model considers two-way travel restrictions on all neighbor subpopulations. Future research could investigate more nuanced restrictions applied only to specific neighbors.
  • Global vs. Local Impact: This study primarily focuses on global spread. Future work should consider the impact of these measures on individual subpopulations and explore combined strategies (e.g., travel restrictions alongside social distancing and isolation within subpopulations).
  • Mobility Control: While the paper emphasizes the importance of controlling infectious individual mobility even without full travel restrictions, further detailed modeling of these specific controls could be beneficial.
  • Network Heterogeneity: The impact of network heterogeneity on disease spread is noted, suggesting further exploration into how different network structures influence intervention effectiveness.

Summary updated

Abstract

When an emerging acute infectious disease occurs, travel restrictions, one-way or two-way, are often taken to prevent its global spread. In order to investigate the impact of two-way travel restrictions in the global spread of infectious diseases, this paper defines a risk indicator according to the relative infection density. Based on this risk indicator and an intervention time on two-way travel restrictions, we define an adaptive metapopulation network. Then a susceptible-infectious-removed (SIR) metapopulation model on this network is proposed. The mathematical analysis shows that the basic reproduction number is independent of human mobility. Furthermore, this essay compares the effects of one-way travel restrictions and two-way travel restrictions on the global spread of infectious diseases. It is shown that the adaptive metapopulation network under two-way travel restrictions can effectively suppress the global spread of infectious diseases. We also obtain a threshold of risk indicator to prevent the global spread of infectious diseases by simulations. The earlier the intervention time on two-way travel restriction is, the better to curb the global spread of the disease. Even if two-way travel restrictions are not implemented, controlling the mobility of infectious persons would help prevent the global spread of the disease. This work will throw lights on the prevention and control of the globally spreading of an emerging infectious disease.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{feng2020infectious,
  author = {Shanshan Feng and Zhen Jin},
  title = {{Infectious Diseases Spreading on an Adaptive Metapopulation Network}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2020.3016016},
}
Figure