Infant Weight Gain Trajectories Linked to Oral Microbiome Composition

Sarah J. C. Craig, Daniel Blankenberg, Alice Parodi, Ian M. Paul, Leann L. Birch, Jennifer S. Savage, Michele E. Marini, Jennifer L. Stokes, Anton Nekrutenko, Matthew Reimherr, Francesca Chiaromonte, Kateryna D. MakovabioRxiv 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that a child's oral microbiome at age two already exhibits patterns associated with rapid weight gain, mirroring those seen in obese adults. This suggests the oral microbiome may be an earlier indicator of obesity risk than the gut microbiome, which appears more influenced by diet at this young age.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Childhood obesity is a growing concern, and while the gut microbiome's role in adult obesity is well-studied, its influence on infant weight gain trajectories is less understood. Specifically, researchers wanted to know if the oral microbiome, often overlooked in this context, plays a role in early childhood weight gain and if these patterns are detectable by age two. Understanding these early microbial signatures could pave the way for novel obesity prevention strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of cutting-edge techniques:

  • Functional Data Analysis (FDA): This statistical approach was used to model the continuous nature of infant growth over time, creating "growth curves" rather than relying on discrete measurements. This allows for a more nuanced understanding of weight gain trajectories.
  • 16S rRNA Gene Sequencing: This standard method was used to identify and quantify the bacteria present in the oral and gut microbiomes of the children and their mothers.
  • Non-metric Multidimensional Scaling (NMDS): Used for visualizing the relationships between different microbiome communities.
  • FLAME (Functional Linear Adaptive Mixed Estimation): A novel FDA methodology developed by the authors for identifying influential taxonomic groups that predict growth curves.
  • LEfSe (Linear Discriminant Analysis Effect Size): A tool used to identify taxonomic groups that differentiate between rapid and non-rapid weight gain.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 226 mother-child dyads enrolled in the Intervention Nurses Start Infants Growing on Healthy Trajectories (INSIGHT) study. This dataset included longitudinal measurements of children's weight and length at seven time points during their first two years of life, along with oral and gut microbiome samples collected at age two. Maternal oral microbiome data was also collected.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Oral Microbiome as an Early Indicator: The oral microbiome at age two shows distinct patterns (lower diversity, higher Firmicutes-to-Bacteroidetes ratio) associated with rapid weight gain, mirroring patterns seen in obese adults. This suggests the oral microbiome might be an earlier predictor of obesity risk than the gut microbiome.
  • Gut Microbiome and Diet Interplay: The gut microbiome's association with child growth was only significant when diet was considered, highlighting its strong influence by age two.
  • Maternal Influence: A significant association was found between mothers' oral microbiome diversity and their children's growth curves, suggesting a potential familial or household microbiome signature influencing early childhood weight gain.
  • FDA's Power: The study highlights the effectiveness of FDA in capturing longitudinal information about weight gain and its association with the microbiome, providing richer insights than traditional binary analyses.

Key Results

  • Children with rapid weight gain exhibited decreased oral microbiome diversity and an increased Firmicutes-to-Bacteroidetes (F:B) ratio.
  • Mothers of children with rapid weight gain also showed decreased oral microbiome diversity.
  • The gut microbiome's alpha-diversity became a significant positive predictor of growth curves when diet-related covariates were included in the analysis.
  • FLAME identified specific bacterial groups in the gut and oral microbiomes associated with children's growth curves and mothers' oral microbiomes.
  • LEfSe identified distinct bacterial groups in children's gut and oral microbiomes associated with rapid versus non-rapid weight gain.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cross-sectional Microbiome Data: The microbiome was sampled only at age two, while growth data was longitudinal. Future studies should include longitudinal microbiome sampling to better understand the temporal dynamics.
  • Resolution of Sequencing: The 16S rRNA gene sequencing used does not provide species or strain-level resolution, limiting the identification of specific influential bacteria.
  • Functional Capacity Unknown: The study did not assess the functional capacity of the microbiome, which could provide further insights into its role in weight gain.
  • Causal Mechanisms: While associations were found, the study acknowledges that deciphering the causal mechanisms through which the oral microbiome affects weight gain is outside its scope. Further research is needed to explore these pathways.
  • Dietary Data Limitations: While diet showed strong effects on the gut microbiome, its influence on the relationship between weight gain and the gut microbiome was complex and requires further investigation.

The authors suggest that these findings could lead to non-invasive clinical screens for identifying children at risk of developing obesity later in life, enabling targeted obesity-prevention interventions.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Gut and oral microbiome perturbations have been observed in obese adults and adolescents. Less is known about how weight gain in early childhood is influenced by gut, and particularly oral, microbiomes. Here we analyze the relationships among weight gain and gut and oral microbiomes in 226 two-year-olds who were followed during the first two years of life, as part of a larger study, with weight and length measured at seven time points. We used these data to identify children with rapid weight gain (a strong risk factor for childhood obesity), and to derive growth curves with novel Functional Data Analysis (FDA) techniques. The children’s oral and gut microbiomes were sampled at the end of the two-year period, and surveyed with 16S sequencing. First, we show that growth curves are associated negatively with diversity and positively with Firmicutes-to-Bacteroidetes ratio of the oral microbiome – a relationship that is also observed in children with rapid (vs. non-rapid) weight gain. We also demonstrate an association between the gut microbiome and child growth, but only when considering the effect of diet on the microbiome. Lastly, we identify several bacterial genera that are associated with child growth patterns. These results suggest that by the age of two, the oral microbiome may have already begun to establish patterns often seen in older obese individuals. They also suggest that the gut microbiome, while strongly influenced by diet, at age two does not harbor obesity signatures many researchers identified in later life stages.
BibTeX
@misc{craig2017infant,
  author = {Sarah J. C. Craig and Daniel Blankenberg and Alice Parodi and Ian M. Paul and Leann L. Birch and Jennifer S. Savage and Michele E. Marini and Jennifer L. Stokes and Anton Nekrutenko and Matthew Reimherr and Francesca Chiaromonte and Kateryna D. Makova},
  title = {{Infant Weight Gain Trajectories Linked to Oral Microbiome Composition}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1101/208090},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure