Infant gut microbiome composition is associated with non-social fear behavior in a pilot study

Alexander L. Carlson, Kai Xia, M. Andrea Azcárate-Peril, Samuel P. Rosin, Jason P. Fine, Wancen Mu, Jared B. Zopp, Mary Kimmel, Martin Styner, Amanda L. Thompson, Cathi B. Propper, Rebecca KnickmeyerNature Communications 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This pilot study reveals a significant association between the composition of an infant's gut microbiome at one year of age and their non-social fear behavior. Specifically, certain microbial profiles, like lower abundance of Bacteroides and higher abundance of Veillonella, Dialister, and Clostridiales, were linked to increased fear responses. This suggests the gut microbiome may play a crucial role in shaping early fear development and related brain circuitry.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While animal studies have established a link between gut microbes and fear behavior, this connection in humans, particularly during the critical first year of life, remains largely unexplored. This period is crucial for brain development, the emergence of fearfulness, and the establishment of the gut microbiome. Understanding how these factors interact could shed light on the development of anxiety disorders and other fear-related conditions later in life. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by investigating the association between infant gut microbiome composition and non-social fear behavior in a human cohort.

Methods

The researchers employed a prospective longitudinal design, following 34 infants from one month to one year of age. Key methods included:

  • Microbiome Analysis: 16S rRNA amplicon sequencing was used to characterize the gut microbiome composition from fecal samples collected at one month and one year. This allowed for the analysis of alpha diversity (within-individual diversity) and beta diversity (between-individual dissimilarity) using metrics like Weighted Unifrac.
  • Behavioral Assessments: Non-social fear behavior was assessed using the "Mask Task" paradigm at one year, where infants were exposed to different masks. This involved coding for facial fear, vocal distress, bodily fear, escape behavior, and startle response. Social wariness was assessed using the Strange Situation paradigm. Parent-reported fear was captured via the Infant Behavior Questionnaire-Revised (IBQ-R).
  • Neuroimaging: Structural Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) was used at both one month and one year to measure the volumes of brain regions implicated in fear circuitry, specifically the medial prefrontal cortex, amygdala, and hippocampus.
  • Statistical Analysis: Linear mixed-effects models were used to test associations between microbiome measures (alpha and beta diversity principal components) and behavioral/brain volume outcomes. Bonferroni correction was applied to account for multiple comparisons. Secondary analyses explored associations with individual bacterial genera.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a cohort of 34 infants. This included:

  • Microbiome Data: 16S rRNA gene sequencing data from fecal samples at 1 month and 1 year of age.
  • Behavioral Data: Observations from the Mask Task and Strange Situation paradigms at 1 year, and parent-reported data from the IBQ-R.
  • Neuroimaging Data: Structural MRI scans at 1 month and 1 year of age.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study utilized existing behavioral paradigms and neuroimaging techniques.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gut-Brain Axis in Infancy: The study provides compelling evidence for the gut-brain axis influencing early human development, specifically in the context of fear.
  • Microbiome Composition Matters: It's not just the presence of microbes, but their specific composition (beta diversity) at one year that is strongly linked to fear behavior.
  • Early Life Microbiome Predicts Later Fear: Even at one month of age, certain aspects of microbiome diversity (richness and evenness) were associated with increased fear later in infancy.
  • Non-Social Fear is Key: The strongest associations were observed with non-social fear behaviors, suggesting a specific pathway through which the microbiome influences threat responses.
  • Potential Brain Structure Links: While not reaching statistical significance after stringent correction, suggestive associations between microbiome composition and fear-related brain volumes (amygdala, medial prefrontal cortex) were observed, hinting at underlying neurobiological mechanisms.

Key Results

  • 1-Year Microbiome and Non-Social Fear: Infants with a 1-year gut microbiome characterized by lower abundance of Bacteroides and higher abundance of Veillonella, Dialister, and Clostridiales showed significantly increased fear behavior in the Mask Task.
  • 1-Month Microbiome and Non-Social Fear: Infants with higher richness and reduced evenness of their 1-month microbiome also displayed increased non-social fear at 1 year.
  • No Social Fear Association: No significant associations were found between microbiome measures and social fear behavior or parent-reported fear (IBQ-R).
  • Suggestive Brain Volume Associations: A negative association was observed between 1-month Weighted Unifrac PC1 and 1-year medial prefrontal cortex volume, and between 1-year Weighted Unifrac PC1 and 1-year amygdala volume. These did not meet Bonferroni significance but were suggestive.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Pilot Study and Small Sample Size: The study's pilot nature and small sample size (n=34) limit generalizability and statistical power. Larger, more diverse cohorts are needed for validation.
  • Causality: The study demonstrates associations, not causality. Future research should explore causal mechanisms.
  • Confounding Variables: While efforts were made to control for confounders (birth mode, feeding), other factors like breast milk microbiome composition were not fully explored.
  • Mediators: The study did not identify specific mediators (e.g., metabolites, immune factors) linking the microbiome to fear. Future work should investigate these pathways.
  • 16S rRNA Sequencing Limitations: This method cannot resolve species-level differences and relies on PICRUSt for functional predictions, which has limitations.
  • Generalizability: The strict inclusion/exclusion criteria may limit the generalizability of findings.

Future work should focus on larger longitudinal studies, exploring causal mechanisms through interventions and metabolomic/metagenomic analyses, and investigating the role of other factors like breast milk. Examining extreme fear reactivity and its links to psychopathology is also a promising avenue.

Summary updated

Abstract

Experimental manipulation of gut microbes in animal models alters fear behavior and relevant neurocircuitry. In humans, the first year of life is a key period for brain development, the emergence of fearfulness, and the establishment of the gut microbiome. Variation in the infant gut microbiome has previously been linked to cognitive development, but its relationship with fear behavior and neurocircuitry is unknown. In this pilot study of 34 infants, we find that 1-year gut microbiome composition (Weighted Unifrac; lower abundance of Bacteroides, increased abundance of Veillonella, Dialister, and Clostridiales) is significantly associated with increased fear behavior during a non-social fear paradigm. Infants with increased richness and reduced evenness of the 1-month microbiome also display increased non-social fear. This study indicates associations of the human infant gut microbiome with fear behavior and possible relationships with fear-related brain structures on the basis of a small cohort. As such, it represents an important step in understanding the role of the gut microbiome in the development of human fear behaviors, but requires further validation with a larger number of participants.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{carlson2021infant,
  author = {Alexander L. Carlson and Kai Xia and M. Andrea Azcárate-Peril and Samuel P. Rosin and Jason P. Fine and Wancen Mu and Jared B. Zopp and Mary Kimmel and Martin Styner and Amanda L. Thompson and Cathi B. Propper and Rebecca Knickmeyer},
  title = {{Infant gut microbiome composition is associated with non-social fear behavior in a pilot study}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-021-23281-y},
}
Figure