This 1990 study by the New Muon Collaboration (NMC) at CERN provides a fundamental investigation into the "glue" that binds the nucleus. By scattering high-energy muons off hydrogen and deuterium targets, researchers measured the production of $J/\psi$ particles to map the distribution of gluons within nucleons, providing critical experimental support for Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD).
Introduction
While the basic structure of protons and neutrons is often described by three valence quarks, experiments have long shown that these quarks carry only about half of the nucleon's total momentum. The remainder is carried by gluons—the massless vector bosons that mediate the strong nuclear force. Because gluons lack electric charge, they cannot be probed directly via standard electromagnetic scattering. Instead, this paper utilizes inelastic $J/\psi$ meson production as a proxy. $J/\psi$ particles (charm-anticharm bound states) are primarily created when a virtual photon from the muon beam fuses with a gluon from the target nucleon, making them a "clean" probe for the gluon distribution function, $G(x)$.
Experimental Methodology
The experiment was conducted using the M2 muon beam at the CERN Super Proton Synchrotron (SPS), utilizing 280 GeV muons directed at liquid hydrogen ($H_2$) and deuterium ($D_2$) targets. Detection was performed using an upgraded version of the EMC forward spectrometer, designed to identify both the scattered muon and the muon pair resulting from the $J/\psi$ decay.
To ensure the analysis focused on "inelastic" events—where the nucleon is excited or broken apart—rather than "diffractive" events where the nucleon remains intact, the team applied strict filters on kinematic variables. These included $z$ (the fraction of the virtual photon's energy carried by the $J/\psi$) and $P_T^2$ (the transverse momentum squared).
Theoretical Framework
The researchers evaluated their data against two primary theoretical models:
- The Colour Singlet (CS) Model: This model predicts $J/\psi$ production via photon-gluon fusion into a specific color-neutral quantum state. It is the leading QCD-based description for this process.
- Vector Meson Dominance (VMD): This older framework suggests the virtual photon fluctuates into a light vector meson before interacting with the nucleon.
Key Insights and Results
Model Validation and Gluon Spin
The Colour Singlet model emerged as the superior framework, accurately predicting the rapidity and longitudinal velocity distribution of the produced $J/\psi$ mesons. Furthermore, the study provided evidence regarding the intrinsic nature of gluons. By analyzing the azimuthal angle distribution of the $J/\psi$ (parameterized by coefficients B and C), the researchers compared experimental results against predictions for different gluon spin states.
As shown in Table 2, the experimental value for B ($-0.13 \pm 0.08$) aligns closely with the CS model's prediction for a vector gluon ($J^P = 1^-$) of $-0.14$, while significantly diverging from the scalar gluon ($J^P = 0^+$) prediction of $+0.12$. This confirms that gluons are indeed spin-1 particles.
Gluon Distribution and Isospin Symmetry
The researchers extracted the normalized gluon distribution for free nucleons, fitting it to the power-law form: $$xG(x) = \frac{\eta+1}{2} (1-x)^\eta$$ For the momentum fraction range $0.02 < x < 0.30$, they determined the shape parameter to be $\eta = 5.1 \pm 0.9$. Additionally, the ratio of $J/\psi$ production in deuterium versus hydrogen was measured at $1.01 \pm 0.15$, confirming that gluon distributions are essentially identical in protons and neutrons (isospin symmetry).
Conclusion and Limitations
While the CS model correctly described the shape of the experimental data, it underestimated the absolute cross-section by a factor of approximately 2.4. This discrepancy suggests that higher-order QCD corrections or relativistic effects within the $c\bar{c}$ bound state are necessary for a complete description. Despite this normalization gap, the study successfully parameterized the gluon density in a previously under-explored kinematic region, laying the groundwork for future high-energy physics experiments at facilities like HERA and the LHC.
Summary updated