Industrial Revitalization of Rural Villages via Comprehensive Land Consolidation: Case Studies in Gansu, China

Jing Zhu, Siqi Ma, Qianyu ZhouLand 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores how comprehensive land consolidation can drive industrial revitalization in rural Chinese villages. By analyzing case studies in Gansu Province, the authors propose a framework that integrates spatial planning, ecological restoration, and cultural development to create a sustainable path for rural economic growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rural areas in China, particularly in regions like Gansu, face significant challenges including extensive and fragmented land use, underutilization of natural resources, and a lagging industrial sector. While comprehensive land consolidation is recognized as a tool for rural development, the specific mechanisms and pathways through which it can effectively stimulate industrial revitalization remain unclear. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by detailing the historical development of land consolidation policies in China and examining their impact on rural industrial transformation through empirical case studies.

Methods

The study employs a mixed-methods approach:

  • Qualitative Analysis: This involved field investigations, literature analysis, and examination of satellite imagery and land management data. The goal was to understand the logical relationships and interaction mechanisms between land consolidation, village planning, and industrial revitalization. Descriptive analysis was used to identify common rural development problems and assess the impact of land consolidation.
  • Quantitative Analysis: This focused on analyzing land use changes in Puhe village before and after land consolidation. Specific landscape metrics were calculated using the Fragstats 4.2 software, including:
  • Patch Shape Index (PSI): Measures the complexity of patch shapes.
  • Land Use Fragmentation Index (FS): Reflects the degree of land fragmentation.
  • Contagion Index (CONTAG): Describes the aggregation or expansion of different land use patch types.
  • Aggregation Index (AI): Indicates the aggregation degree of similar patches.

These quantitative measures were used to demonstrate how land consolidation can lead to more regular, concentrated, and aggregated land use patterns, which are beneficial for industrial development.

Datasets

The study utilized:

  • Field investigation data: Collected from four villages in Gansu Province (Puhe, Maosi, Dianzi, and Baicaopo).
  • Land management office data: Provided current village land use conditions.
  • Satellite imagery: Used for analysis of land use patterns.
  • Historical development process data: Gathered through literature review and policy analysis.
  • Land use data for Puhe village: Specifically used for quantitative landscape metric analysis, comparing data from 2020 and 2035 (projected).

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing data and village conditions were analyzed.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Nested Strategy for Revitalization: The study proposes a generic strategy for rural industrial revitalization through land consolidation, comprising:
  • Core Strategy: Consolidating the spatial layout to guide industrial development.
  • Optimization Strategy: Strengthening ecological restoration.
  • Desirable Supplement: Including and enhancing cultural industrialization.
  • Land Consolidation as a Foundation: Comprehensive land consolidation is not just about improving agricultural land but also about optimizing the "Sansheng Space" (production, living, and ecological spaces), which provides the necessary land and environmental conditions for industrial development.
  • Synergy between Planning and Consolidation: Effective village planning is crucial for identifying specific land needs for industrial development and guiding the layout of consolidation programs.
  • Beyond Agriculture: While agriculture remains a primary industry, revitalization requires extending the industrial chain through processing, logistics, and tourism, leveraging unique local resources and cultural heritage.
  • Quantitative Evidence of Improved Land Use: The landscape metric analysis in Puhe village demonstrated that land consolidation leads to more regular, concentrated, and aggregated land use, which is more conducive to industrial activities and efficient resource utilization.

Key Results

  • Qualitative Findings: The study identified common problems in rural industrial development across the case study villages, including extensive land use, fragmentation, ineffective resource utilization, and a lack of cultural integration. It also highlighted the potential of land consolidation to address these issues by providing land, improving the environment, and fostering industrial competitiveness.
  • Quantitative Findings (Puhe Village):
    • PSI: Decreased slightly from 19.5080 to 19.4292, indicating a trend towards more regular land use patch shapes.
  • FS: Decreased from 33.6380 to 33.4039, signifying reduced land fragmentation and increased land concentration.
  • CONTAG: Increased from 61.7748 to 64.8910, showing a decrease in isolated patches and improved splicing of dominant land use types.
  • AI: Decreased slightly from 84.1940 to 84.1673, suggesting a more aggregated distribution of land use types, facilitating agricultural production and life activities.
  • Case Study Observations:
    • Baicaopo and Dianzi villages, rich in agricultural resources, can extend their industrial chains through agriculture-industry integration and tourism.
  • Puhe and Maosi villages, with tourism potential, can develop a "double circulation" model, integrating primary, secondary, and tertiary industries.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that rural revitalization is a multifaceted process, and this paper primarily focuses on the logical relationships between land consolidation and industrial revitalization, not encompassing all aspects like talent revitalization or comprehensive land improvement.
  • The study did not explore methods for assessing/quantifying development goals at both the village and province levels.
  • The quantitative analysis was limited to one village (Puhe), although the qualitative findings were drawn from four.
  • Future Work:
    • Further research is needed to explore the comprehensive logical relationships among land comprehensive improvement, industrial revitalization, talent revitalization, and other aspects.
  • Developing methods for assessing and quantifying development goals at different administrative levels is suggested.
  • The authors believe their proposed framework and findings can be applied to other villages and regions worldwide, particularly in developing countries, to guide land spatial planning and industrial revitalization efforts.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although comprehensive land consolidation may stimulate industrial revitalization, the interactions and pathways between land consolidation and industrial revitalization are unclear. Using villages in China as case studies, the historical development process and pathways of comprehensive land consolidation, and rural industrial revitalization, are summarized and clarified. Development processes and pathways for villages in Puhe, Maosi, Dianzi, and Baicaopo in Gansu Province were compared. The comparison suggested the following nested generic strategy for revitalization, comprising: (1). A core strategy for guiding industrial development that consolidates the spatial layout; (2). Strengthening ecological restoration as a key part of the optimization strategy with (1); and (3). Including and enhancing cultural industrialization as a desirable supplement. Our study and worked examples can be applied to other villages or regions worldwide to explore the development path of village industry revitalization under the guidance of our proposed comprehensive land consolidation framework.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2022industrial,
  author = {Jing Zhu and Siqi Ma and Qianyu Zhou},
  title = {{Industrial Revitalization of Rural Villages via Comprehensive Land Consolidation: Case Studies in Gansu, China}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/land11081307},
}
Figure