Industrial Land Change in Chinese Silk Road Cities and Its Influence on Environments

Sidong Zhao, Yiran Yan, Jing HanLand 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how industrial land use is changing in Chinese Silk Road cities due to the "Belt and Road" initiative. Using the GeoDetector method, it reveals significant spatial heterogeneity in these changes, identifies increasingly complex driving forces, and highlights the intricate, often indirect, environmental impacts of this industrial expansion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The "Belt and Road" initiative, a massive global development strategy, is leading to a significant spatial shift of industries within China, particularly towards cities along the historic Silk Road routes. This industrialization and urban expansion raise critical questions about how industrial land is changing, what factors are driving these transformations, and what consequences these changes have for the environment. Existing research often focuses on macro-level impacts or specific regions, leaving a gap in understanding the nuanced dynamics of industrial land change at the city level within this crucial initiative. This paper aims to fill that gap by analyzing the drivers and environmental effects of industrial land change in 129 Chinese Silk Road cities.

Methods

The core methodology employed is the GeoDetector, a statistical tool designed to detect spatial heterogeneity and identify its driving factors. The authors utilized three of its functions:

  • Factor Detector: To quantify the explanatory power of individual independent variables on industrial land change.
  • Interaction Detector: To analyze how pairs of factors interact, revealing whether they enhance or weaken each other's influence.
  • Ecological Detector: To assess the ecological effects of industrial land changes.

This was complemented by GIS analysis for spatial clustering and data processing using Python and Excel.

Datasets

The study primarily used data from:

  • China Urban Construction Statistical Yearbook
  • China City Statistical Yearbook
  • Provincial and city statistical yearbooks, bulletins, and government reports.

Data for industrial land area and its changes were collected for the years 2014 and 2018. Carbon dioxide emission data were available for 2014 and 2017.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Belt and Road" as an Industrial "Spillover": The initiative is viewed as a mechanism for China's industrialization process to extend outwards, influencing the development of Silk Road cities.
  • Complex Interactions are Key: The study emphasizes that driving factors don't act in isolation. Interactions between factors, particularly "Enhance, bi" and "Enhance, nonlinear" types, significantly amplify their impact, sometimes by over tenfold. This highlights the need for policy to consider these synergistic effects.
  • Environmental Impacts are Indirect and Multifaceted: While industrial land quantity directly impacts ecological quality, its changes influence the environment indirectly, primarily through emissions, energy use, and interactions with ecological planning and policy.

Key Results

  • Spatial Heterogeneity: Industrial land development and changes in Silk Road cities are highly uneven. Dongguan had the largest industrial land area (398.44 km²) in 2018, while Longnan had the smallest (0.16 km²), a difference of about 2500 times. The variation coefficient for industrial land area was 1.68, indicating significant heterogeneity.
  • Increment Dynamics: Between 2014 and 2018, 69.77% of cities saw positive growth in industrial land. Negative growth was concentrated in core areas like the Yangtze River and Pearl River Deltas, likely due to policy pressures.
  • Diversifying Drivers: The number of driving factors influencing industrial land development increased from 19 to 22 between 2014 and 2018, indicating growing complexity. Factors like "Import" and "Export" transitioned from non-driving to key drivers.
  • Key Driving Forces: For inventory (stock) of industrial land, "Open," "Population," "Coordination," "Innovation," and "Investment" emerged as major drivers. For increment (change), "Population," "Investment," and "Innovation" were prominent.
  • Environmental Linkages: Industrial land expansion contributes to increased carbon dioxide emissions, energy consumption, and pollution, impacting air, water, and land cover. This, in turn, can lead to phenomena like the urban heat island effect and biodiversity loss.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Policy and Institutional Factors: The study acknowledges that government policies, land transfer fees, and land value increment taxes, which significantly influence industrial land supply, were not fully incorporated due to data collection challenges.
  • Geographical Scope: The analysis is limited to the Chinese section of the Silk Road. A comparative analysis with non-Silk Road cities or a broader international scope would provide a more comprehensive understanding of the "Belt and Road" initiative's global impact.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest continued research, including field studies in various countries, to develop more standardized and comprehensive analyses. They also call for more researchers to join this important area of study.

Summary updated

Abstract

The “Belt and Road” has developed from a Chinese initiative to an international consensus, and Silk Road cities are becoming a strategic step for its high-quality development. From the perspective of industrialization, the “Belt and Road” can be regarded as a “spillover” effect of the industrialization process in China. With the spatial shift of Chinese industries along the “Belt and Road” and their clustering in Silk Road cities, the development and change of industrial land in Silk Road cities has become a new area of concern for governments and scholars. In this paper, the driving mechanism of industrial land change in 129 cities along the Silk Road in China is empirically studied by the GeoDetector method. The findings include: first, the development and changes of industrial land in Silk Road cities are significantly spatially heterogeneous, and the “Belt and Road” reshapes the town system and economic geography along the route by virtue of the differentiated configuration and changes of industrial land, changing the social, political, landscape and spatial relations in cities on the line. Second, the driving forces of industrial land change in Silk Road cities under the influence of the “Belt and Road Initiative” are increasingly diversified and differentiated, with significant two-factor enhancement and non-linear enhancement interaction between two driving factors, and growing complexity of the driving mechanisms, requiring policy makers to design policies based on key factors, comprehensive factors and their interaction. Third, the environmental effect of industrial land change is highly complex. The industrial land quantity has a direct impact on the ecological state parameter and plays a decisive role in the quality of the ecological environment and its changes in Silk Road cities. However, changes in the industrial land affect the ecological state change indirectly, mainly interacting with it through the coupling of pollutant and carbon dioxide emissions, energy use, ecological planning and landscape design and policy interventions. Finally, this study provides a new framework and method for Silk Road scholars to analyze the spatial and temporal evolution characteristics of land use and coverage in cities along the “Belt and Road” and their influence mechanisms, and provides a basis for the government to make decisions on industrial land supply and layout planning and spatial governance policy design, which is of great theoretical significance and practical value.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2021industrial,
  author = {Sidong Zhao and Yiran Yan and Jing Han},
  title = {{Industrial Land Change in Chinese Silk Road Cities and Its Influence on Environments}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/land10080806},
}
Figure