Induction, of and by Probability

Larry A. RendellUAI 1985

TL;DR

This paper introduces Probabilistic Learning Systems (PLS) that leverage probability to guide both task performance and learning in heuristic search. PLS excels at efficient, incremental learning in noisy domains by refining probability estimates, localizing errors, and even constructing new features for heuristic functions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the fundamental challenge of induction, or generalization learning, particularly within the context of heuristic search. Heuristic search, a common AI technique for problem-solving, relies on evaluation functions (heuristics) to guide its exploration of possible solutions. However, creating effective heuristics is difficult due to:

  • Computational Complexity: The space of possible generalizations is vast.
  • Data Sparsity: Limited data makes it hard to distinguish between competing hypotheses.
  • Noisy Data: Real-world data is often imperfect, necessitating probabilistic approaches.

Traditional methods often struggle with efficiency and effectiveness in these noisy, complex environments. The authors aim to develop systems that can learn robust and accurate heuristics incrementally, even when faced with imperfect information.

Methods

The core of the PLS approach lies in its sophisticated use of probability:

  • Dual Role of Probability: Probability is used in two key ways:
  • Task Performance: To guide heuristic search, where the evaluation function estimates the probability of a state leading to success.
  • Learning: To inform the inductive process itself, helping to determine the form and parameters of the heuristic.
  • Incremental Learning and Refinement: PLS systems learn and update probability estimates incrementally. This involves:
  • Probability Reclassification: Adjusting probability estimates as new data becomes available.
  • Cell Splitting: Refining feature space partitions (cells) based on observed probability differences, effectively creating more granular knowledge.
  • Normalization of Biased Data: Correcting for biases introduced by using imperfect heuristics during data collection.
  • Error Localization and Correction: Identifying and rectifying inaccuracies in probability estimates.
  • Clustering: PLS employs a utility-based clustering algorithm. Unlike traditional information-theoretic clustering, it uses the probability of success as the criterion for grouping similar states or regions in feature space. This is crucial for handling noisy data and improving accuracy by effectively increasing sample sizes.
  • Feature Space Representation: Objects are represented as vectors in a feature space. PLS partitions this space into rectangular cells, each associated with a probability estimate and an error measure.
  • Constructive Induction (PLS0): A more advanced system, PLSO, goes beyond using pre-defined features. It can construct new features by performing higher-dimensional clustering on subspaces of primitives, effectively inducing rules of a grammar and creating structure.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed in the paper. The systems are described as learning from "sample problems" and "search trees" generated during task performance, implying a self-generated or problem-domain-specific data source rather than standard, pre-defined datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Probability as a Unified Framework: The paper argues that probability is not just a tool for handling uncertainty but can serve as a fundamental basis for both performing tasks (via heuristics) and learning those heuristics.
  • The Power of Incremental Refinement: Continuous updating of probability estimates and feature space partitions allows the system to adapt and improve its heuristics over time, even in the face of initial uncertainty.
  • Utility-Based Clustering: Using the "utility" (probability of success) as a clustering criterion is a novel way to group data that is directly relevant to the task's objective, leading to more effective learning than purely statistical measures.
  • Constructive Induction is Key for Complex Domains: For domains with highly irregular probability distributions (like raw checkerboard states), simple feature-based induction fails. Higher-dimensional clustering and feature construction (as in PLSO) are necessary to create meaningful representations.
  • Credibility as an Inductive Criterion: Beyond just probability, the paper introduces "credibility" (combining evidential and extra-evidential criteria like simplicity) as a guiding principle for induction, helping to select the "best" generalizations.

Key Results

The paper highlights the effectiveness and efficiency of PLS systems:

  • Efficient Convergence: PLS1 has demonstrated efficient convergence to optimal search heuristics.
  • Effective in Noisy Domains: The systems are capable of effective incremental learning even with noisy data.
  • Improved Search: By learning better heuristics, PLS leads to narrower and more efficient search (illustrated in Figure 4, showing a significant increase in "success" nodes).
  • Stability and Generality: PLS is described as more stable, general, and mechanized compared to earlier systems like Samuel's checker player.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Bias in Probability Estimates: A significant challenge is the inherent bias in probability estimates when using non-trivial heuristics. The paper discusses normalization techniques to address this, but it remains a complex issue.
  • Computational Complexity of Constructive Induction: While PLSO shows promise for constructive induction, the paper notes that higher-dimensional clustering can be computationally intensive, requiring strategies like layered information compression to break down the problem into more tractable levels.
  • Feature Space Representation: The paper acknowledges that for very primitive features, PLS1's reliance on uniformity of probability within cells can be problematic, motivating the development of PLSO for more complex feature spaces.
  • Future Work: The paper points towards further exploration of constructive induction, more sophisticated error correction mechanisms, and the integration of various learning schemes. The development of PLSO for creating structure and inducing rules of a grammar is a significant direction.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{rendell1985induction,
  author = {Larry A. Rendell},
  title = {{Induction, of and by Probability}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {1985},
}

Loading related content...

Figure