Individualized reconstruction for severe periprosthetic fractures around the tumor prosthesis of knee under assistance of 3D printing technology

Qing Han, Xue Zhao, Chenyu Wang, Bingpeng Chen, Xiaonan Wang, Ziyan Zhang, Kesong Zhang, Yuhao Zheng, Jincheng WangMedicine 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach to reconstructing severe periprosthetic femoral fractures (PFFs) around knee tumor prostheses using 3D printing technology. By enabling precise preoperative design and simulation, this method aims to restore normal anatomy and function, offering a more accurate and effective solution for complex cases compared to traditional techniques.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Periprosthetic femoral fractures (PFFs) around knee tumor prostheses are challenging reconstructive problems. These fractures often involve significant bone defects and biomechanical complexities, making revision surgery difficult and prone to failure. Traditional methods for designing revision implants can be limited by a lack of precise anatomical representation and surgeon-engineer collaboration. This paper addresses the need for a more accurate and individualized approach to reconstruct these complex fractures, aiming to improve surgical outcomes and restore patient function.

Methods

The core of this paper's methodology lies in the integration of 3D printing technology for personalized surgical planning and implant design. The process involved:

  • 3D Reconstruction: CT scans of the patient's affected limb were used to create detailed 3D models of the femur, tibia, and fibula.
  • Virtual Measurement and Design: Key parameters of the patient's anatomy, including bone defect size, residual bone length, and prosthesis dimensions, were meticulously measured from the 3D models. Based on these measurements, novel femoral stem and nail paths were designed by surgeons.
  • Custom Implant and Navigator Fabrication: Engineers then translated the surgical design into custom-manufactured prosthetic femoral stem components and a surgical navigator using a Stereo Lithography Apparatus (SLA) 3D printer.
  • Preoperative Simulation: A 3D printed resin model of the patient's residual femur was created. This model, along with the custom components and navigator, allowed for a detailed preoperative simulation of the entire surgical procedure, including bone defect management with allograft bone.
  • Intraoperative Navigation: The custom-designed navigator was used during surgery to guide the precise placement of implants.

This approach emphasizes a close collaboration between surgeons and engineers, moving beyond traditional 2D imaging-based planning.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on a single case report utilizing patient-specific CT scan data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of "Digital Twin" Surgery: The ability to create a physical 3D model of the patient's fractured femur, alongside custom implants and a navigator, allows for an unprecedented level of preoperative simulation. This "digital twin" approach enables surgeons to rehearse complex steps, anticipate challenges, and refine their strategy before entering the operating room.
  • Enhanced Surgeon-Engineer Collaboration: The 3D printing workflow fosters a more integrated and iterative design process between surgeons and engineers. This direct interaction ensures that the implant design is not only anatomically accurate but also functionally optimized for the specific patient's needs.
  • Personalized Solutions for Complex Fractures: For severe periprosthetic fractures, especially those involving significant bone loss, a one-size-fits-all approach is insufficient. This study demonstrates that 3D printing can deliver highly individualized solutions that precisely match the unique anatomy and biomechanical requirements of the patient.
  • Improved Predictability and Reduced Risk: By simulating the entire procedure on 3D printed models, surgeons can gain a clearer understanding of the osteotomy scope and implant placement, potentially reducing intraoperative surprises and improving the overall predictability of the surgery.

Key Results

The paper reports a successful surgical reconstruction for a 32-year-old female patient with a severe periprosthetic femoral fracture around a tumor prosthesis.

  • Successful Operation: The surgery was performed successfully, with the customized prosthesis and navigator facilitating precise implantation.
  • Functional Restoration: Postoperative X-rays showed good alignment and counterpoint. The patient demonstrated significant functional recovery, with her MSTS93 score improving from 0 pre-operatively to 28 at 27 months follow-up. She was able to walk with crutches within one month and independently after 12 months, with her knee flexion and extension restoring to an acceptable range.
  • Long-Term Stability: The functional restoration was sustained well throughout the 27-month follow-up period.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Single Case Study: The primary limitation is that this is a case report involving only one patient. This limits the generalizability of the findings.
  • Need for Broader Research: The authors emphasize that more extensive research is needed to compare this 3D printing-assisted method with traditional techniques.
  • Long-Term Follow-up: While the current follow-up is 27 months, longer-term studies are necessary to fully assess the durability and long-term efficacy of this approach.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The cost-effectiveness of implementing 3D printing technology for such complex reconstructions is not discussed but is an important consideration for wider adoption.

The authors suggest that this method is suitable for popularization in complex and severe cases, implying a future direction towards broader clinical application and further validation.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Introduction: Periprosthetic femoral fractures (PFF) around tumor prosthesis of knee are stubborn problems for surgeons, huge bone defect and inappropriate biomechanics of the revision implant design can be disaster for reconstruction. With the development of three-dimensional (3D) printing technology, surgeons participate more in precise preoperative design and simulation for treatment of such fractures. In this study we explored an accurate and feasible way to restore normal anatomy and function of the knee joint with 3D printing technology. Case presentation: Rationale: This report explored an accurate and feasible way to treat PFF around tumor knee prosthesis in a 32 years old women with 3D printing technology, which restored normal anatomy and function of the knee joint. Patient concerns: Pain in left thigh lasted for 10 months after resection of left femoral chondroma and knee joint replacement four years ago. Diagnoses: periprosthetic femoral fractures (PFF) around tumor knee prosthesis. Interventions: CT images of the patient were collected and reconstructed. Parameters of bilateral femurs were virtually sliced and measured. Novel femoral stem and nail paths were specially designed by doctors according to these parameters. The prosthetic femoral stem components and navigator were customized by engineers according to the doctor's design. The residual femoral resin model, customized components and navigator were printed with Stereo Lithography Apparatus 3D printer. The shape-preconcerted allograft bone was selected as patch for the bone defect before operation with the printed bone model. All the steps were simulated preoperatively with the models printed, and then the operation was carried out. Outcomes: The operation was successfully performed. The postoperative x-ray image, MSTS93 scores were examined and the function restoration sustained well in the follow-up period from 1 month to 27 months. Lessons: 3D printing and medical interaction are key points in complex PFF cases. Conclusion: As for PFF of the complex tumor of knee, preoperative design and simulation with 3D printing technology may provide more accurate and effective operative outcome than traditional methods, which might be considered as a method suitable for popularization in complex and severe cases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2018individualized,
  author = {Qing Han and Xue Zhao and Chenyu Wang and Bingpeng Chen and Xiaonan Wang and Ziyan Zhang and Kesong Zhang and Yuhao Zheng and Jincheng Wang},
  title = {{Individualized reconstruction for severe periprosthetic fractures around the tumor prosthesis of knee under assistance of 3D printing technology}},
  booktitle = {Medicine},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1097/md.0000000000012726},
}
Figure