Individual Differences in Premotor Brain Systems Underlie Behavioral Apathy

Valérie Bonnelle, Sanjay Manohar, Timothy E.j. Behrens, Masud HusainCerebral 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the neural basis of behavioral apathy in healthy individuals, finding that apathy is linked to increased sensitivity to effort and altered connectivity in brain regions involved in action planning and initiation. Specifically, reduced structural and functional connectivity between the anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and the supplementary motor area (SMA) appears to be a key factor contributing to apathy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Behavioral apathy, characterized by a lack of motivation, engagement, and initiative, is a common and impactful issue affecting personal and economic well-being. While psychological factors are well-studied, the underlying neurobiological mechanisms in healthy individuals remain less understood. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring how differences in brain systems involved in decision-making (effort/reward evaluation) and action processing (translating intentions into actions) might explain individual variations in behavioral apathy.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-modal neuroimaging approach combined with a novel behavioral task.

  • Effort and Reward-Based Decision-Making Task: Participants played a computer game where they decided whether to accept offers involving a "stake" (potential reward) and an "effort" level. Accepting an offer required a physical response (squeezing a dynamometer) to earn a portion of the stake. The task was designed to dissociate various cognitive processes, including stake evaluation, effort evaluation, expected reward calculation, cost-benefit weighing, and action anticipation.
  • Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI): Used to examine brain activity during the decision-making task. This allowed researchers to identify brain regions associated with different computational processes (e.g., stake evaluation, effort evaluation, cost-benefit weighing, and action anticipation).
  • Diffusion Tensor Imaging (DTI): Used to assess the structural integrity of white matter pathways connecting relevant brain regions. This technique helps understand how the physical connections between brain areas might influence behavior.
  • Psychophysiological Interaction (PPI) Analysis: Employed to investigate functional connectivity between specific brain regions (e.g., SMA and ACC) during task performance, revealing how these areas communicate.
  • Behavioral Modeling: A logistic regression model was used to quantify the influence of different factors (stake, effort, expected reward, probability of success) on participants' choices.
  • Questionnaires: Standardized scales (LARS-e for apathy, DASS for depression, Snaith-Hamilton Pleasure Scale for anhedonia) were used to assess individual differences in apathy and control for confounding factors.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 37 healthy, right-handed participants recruited for the experiment. No external datasets were used for training or evaluation. The paper also mentions using data from previous experiments in their lab (N=139) to establish a cutoff for "high" behavioral apathy traits.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Effort Sensitivity is Key: Apathetic individuals are more sensitive to the effort required to achieve a reward. This means they are more deterred by the prospect of exerting effort, even if the reward is substantial.
  • Action Anticipation Network Over-recruitment: Paradoxically, while apathetic individuals are less motivated to act, their brains show increased activation in regions associated with action anticipation and preparation (like SMA and cingulate motor areas) when they do decide to engage. This suggests a potential inefficiency, requiring more neural resources to initiate action.
  • Cingulum Bundle Integrity Matters: The structural integrity of the cingulum bundle, particularly its anterior portion, is a significant predictor of behavioral apathy. This pathway is crucial for connecting frontal brain regions involved in motivation and action.
  • SMA-ACC Communication Breakdown: Decreased functional and structural connectivity between the SMA and the dorsal ACC is strongly associated with higher apathy scores. This suggests that inefficient communication between these key regions involved in decision-making and action initiation might be a core mechanism underlying apathy.

Key Results

  • Behavioral: Apathy scores positively correlated with "effort sensitivity" (β effort' in the choice model).
  • fMRI:
    • Increased probability of accepting an offer (indicating willingness to act) correlated with increased activation in SMA, CMA, and M1. Apathy scores were positively correlated with this activation in these regions.
  • Effort evaluation was associated with decreased activation in basal ganglia and CMA. Apathetic individuals showed less activation in these regions as effort increased.
  • DTI: Mean FA of the cingulum bundle was strongly negatively correlated with apathy traits, with the anterior portion showing the strongest relationship.
  • PPI: Decreased functional connectivity between SMA and dACC was observed in individuals with higher behavioral apathy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Correlation vs. Causation: While the study identifies strong associations, it cannot definitively establish causation. The observed neural differences could be a cause or a consequence of apathy.
  • Healthy Population Focus: The study focuses on individual differences in healthy individuals. Further research is needed to understand how these findings translate to pathological apathy in clinical populations.
  • Mechanism of Inefficiency: The authors propose that inefficient communication between ACC and SMA leads to increased "physiological cost" and effort sensitivity. Future work could explore this mechanism further, perhaps by investigating subjective effort ratings or physiological markers of effort.
  • Clinical Implications: The findings suggest potential targets for interventions aimed at ameliorating apathy, possibly by enhancing connectivity or efficiency within the SMA-ACC network.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lack of physical engagement, productivity, and initiative-so-called "behavioral apathy"--is a common problem with significant impact, both personal and economic. Here, we investigate whether there might be a biological basis to such lack of motivation using a new effort and reward-based decision-making paradigm, combined with functional and diffusion-weighted imaging. We hypothesized that behavioral apathy in otherwise healthy people might be associated with differences in brain systems underlying either motivation to act (specifically in effort and reward-based decision-making) or in action processing (transformation of an intention into action). The results demonstrate that behavioral apathy is associated with increased effort sensitivity as well as greater recruitment of neural systems involved in action anticipation: supplementary motor area (SMA) and cingulate motor zones. In addition, decreased structural and functional connectivity between anterior cingulate cortex (ACC) and SMA were associated with increased behavioral apathy. These findings reveal that effort sensitivity and translation of intentions into actions might make a critical contribution to behavioral apathy. We propose a mechanism whereby inefficient communication between ACC and SMA might lead to increased physiological cost--and greater effort sensitivity--for action initiation in more apathetic people.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bonnelle2015individual,
  author = {Valérie Bonnelle and Sanjay Manohar and Timothy E.J. Behrens and Masud Husain},
  title = {{Individual Differences in Premotor Brain Systems Underlie Behavioral Apathy}},
  booktitle = {Cerebral},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1093/cercor/bhv247},
}
Figure