Indirect interaction of 13C nuclear spins in diamond with NV centers: simulation of the full J-coupling tensors

Alexander Nizovtsev, Aliaksandr Pushkarchuk, S. A. Kuten, Dominik L. Michels, Dmitry Lyakhov, Nikolai I. Kargin, S. Ya. KilinFrontiers in Quantum Science and Technology 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have used advanced Density Functional Theory (DFT) to simulate the full $J$-coupling tensors of $^{13}\text{C}$ nuclear spin pairs in diamond, both in pure crystals and near Nitrogen-Vacancy (NV) centers. They found that these indirect interactions are significantly influenced by the NV center's local electron density and that anisotropic (direction-dependent) components are too large to be ignored in high-precision quantum sensing.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nitrogen-Vacancy (NV) centers in diamond are leading candidates for quantum sensing and quantum memory. Often, researchers use nearby $^{13}\text{C}$ nuclear spins as qubits because of their long coherence times. As the spectral resolution of NV-based sensors reaches the sub-Hertz regime, previously "negligible" interactions become critical.

Until now, models of these systems primarily accounted for Zeeman interactions, hyperfine coupling, and direct dipole-dipole interactions. This paper addresses the "missing piece": $J$-coupling (indirect nuclear spin-spin interaction mediated by electrons in chemical bonds). Understanding the full $J$-coupling tensor is essential for the precise control and characterization of $^{13}\text{C}$–$^{13}\text{C}$ dimers used in emerging quantum technologies.

Methods

The authors employed quantum chemistry simulations using the ORCA software package (version 5.0.3). They modeled diamond using H-terminated carbon clusters:

  • Adamantane ($C_{10}H_{16}$): Used as a benchmark to compare results with known experimental data.
  • $C_{35}H_{36}$: A larger cluster representing a pure diamond environment.
  • $C_{33}[NV^-]H_{36}$: A cluster hosting a negatively charged NV center to study its local impact.

The study utilized two levels of Density Functional Theory (DFT):

  1. B3LYP/UKS/TZVPP: A standard approach used in prior work.
  2. PBE0/UKS/pcJ-2: A more advanced level employing a basis set specifically optimized for calculating spin-spin coupling constants.

Crucially, they simulated the full $J$-coupling tensor ($J_{KL}$), decomposing it into diamagnetic, paramagnetic, Fermi-contact (FC), and spin-dipolar contributions.

Datasets

The paper does not use external machine learning datasets. Instead, it generates a primary dataset of simulated $J$-coupling values for various $^{13}\text{C}$ pairs within the diamond lattice. The results were validated against experimental NMR data for adamantane, where the isotropic $J$-coupling ($J_{iso}$) is known to be approximately $31.4 \pm 0.5 \text{ Hz}$.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Scalar" Myth: While $J$-coupling is often treated as a simple scalar constant ($J_{iso}$), this paper demonstrates that the anisotropic components are essential. For a C–C bond in diamond, the asymmetric part of the tensor ($\Delta^1J$) can be around 12 Hz, which is a significant fraction of the total interaction.
  • NV Center Enhancement: The presence of a negatively charged NV center increases the local electron density. This leads to a ~9% increase in the $J$-coupling values for $^{13}\text{C}$ pairs located immediately adjacent to the NV vacancy.
  • Dominance of Fermi-Contact: The simulations confirm that the Fermi-contact term is the primary driver of $J$-coupling in these systems, though other terms like spin-dipolar contributions are necessary for a complete tensor description.
  • Structural Sensitivity: $J$-coupling is highly sensitive to the orientation of the C–C bond relative to the NV center's axis, meaning the "position" of a dimer in the lattice changes its quantum signature more than previously thought.

Key Results

  • Adamantane Validation: The PBE0/pcJ-2 level of theory yielded $J_{iso}$ values (~30.1 Hz) that closely matched experimental benchmarks (~31.4 Hz), outperforming the simpler B3LYP model.
  • Pure Diamond ($C_{35}H_{36}$): One-bond $^{13}\text{C}$–$^{13}\text{C}$ $J_{iso}$ values were calculated in the range of 28.5–30.9 Hz.
  • NV Environment: For $^{13}\text{C}$ pairs near the NV vacancy, $J_{iso}$ rose to approximately 37.1 Hz.
  • Tensor Components: The diagonal elements of the $J$-tensor ($J_{XX}, J_{YY}, J_{ZZ}$) are not equal; typically, $J_{XX} \approx J_{YY}$ are about 1.5 times larger than $J_{ZZ}$ when the Z-axis is aligned with the C–C bond.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cluster Size: The simulations were limited to relatively small clusters ($C_{33}$ to $C_{35}$) due to the high computational cost of full tensor calculations. Larger clusters might better simulate "bulk" diamond properties.
  • Static Models: The study assumes a static lattice at 0K. Real-world experiments at room temperature may involve vibrational effects that slightly average these tensors.
  • Application to Multi-Spin Systems: The authors suggest that these full tensors should now be integrated into larger spin Hamiltonian simulations to predict the complex NMR and EPR spectra of multi-spin quantum registers more accurately.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recent experiments on the detection, imaging, characterization and control of multiple 13 C nuclear spins, as well as of individual 13 C– 13 C dimers in diamond using a single nitrogen-vacancy (NV) center as a sensor, along with the impressive progress in increasing the spectral resolution of such sensor (up to sub-Hertz), have created a request for detailed knowledge of all possible spin interactions in the studied systems. Here, we focus on the indirect interaction ( J -coupling) of 13 C nuclear spins in diamond, which was not previously taken into account in studies of NV centers. Using two different levels of the density functional theory (DFT), we simulated the full tensors n J KL (K, L = X, Y,Z), describing n-bond J -coupling of nuclear spins 13 C in H-terminated diamond-like clusters C 10 H 16 (adamantane) and C 35 H 36 , as well as in the cluster C 33 [NV − ]H 36 hosting the negatively charged NV − center. We found that, in addition to the usually considered isotropic scalar n J -coupling constant, the anisotropic contributions to the n J -coupling tensor are essential. We also showed that the presence of the NV center affects the J -coupling characteristics, especially in the case of 13 C– 13 C pairs located near the vacancy of the NV center.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{nizovtsev2024indirect,
  author = {Alexander Nizovtsev and Aliaksandr Pushkarchuk and S. A. Kuten and Dominik L. Michels and Dmitry Lyakhov and Nikolai I. Kargin and S. Ya. Kilin},
  title = {{Indirect interaction of 13C nuclear spins in diamond with NV centers: simulation of the full J-coupling tensors}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Quantum Science and Technology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/frqst.2024.1332264},
}
Figure