Index Problems for Game Automata

Josef Kittler, Alessandro Facchini, Filip Murlak, Michal SkrzypczakACM Trans. Comput. log 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the complexity of recognizing languages of infinite trees using a specific type of automaton called "game automata." The authors show that for these automata, the "index problems" – which relate to the minimal number of priorities needed for recognition – are decidable. This is a significant step towards understanding the expressive power and computational complexity of these automata.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the realm of formal languages and automata theory, understanding the complexity of recognizing different classes of languages is crucial, especially for applications in verification and model-checking. For automata that process infinite trees (which are fundamental for modeling recursive structures and temporal properties), the "acceptance condition" – how the automaton decides if a tree is recognized – plays a key role in its complexity. The Rabin-Mostowski index is a measure of this complexity, related to the priorities assigned to states in the automaton.

The paper focuses on "index problems" for various types of tree automata:

  • Non-deterministic, Alternating, and Weak Alternating Index Problems: For a given regular tree language, what's the minimum number of priorities an automaton of a specific type (non-deterministic, alternating, or weak alternating) needs to recognize it?
  • Decidability: Can we effectively determine if a language can be recognized by an automaton with a specific index?

While these problems are well-studied for deterministic automata, they remain challenging for more expressive automata like non-deterministic and alternating ones. The paper introduces "game automata," a class that can recognize languages with arbitrarily high alternating Rabin-Mostowski index, making the index problem non-trivial. The core question is: can we solve these index problems for game automata?

Methods

The paper introduces "game automata," which are alternating automata without ambiguous transitions. This structural property is key because it allows for "substitution" to preserve the automaton's index. This is a crucial difference from general alternating automata, where substitution can alter the index.

The authors then leverage this property and existing results on deterministic automata to tackle the index problems for game automata:

  • Non-deterministic Index Problem: This is solved by reducing it to the already decidable non-deterministic index problem for deterministic automata.
  • Alternating and Weak Alternating Index Problems: These are solved by developing recursive procedures that compute the alternating and weak alternating index of a language recognized by a game automaton. This involves analyzing the structure of the automaton, particularly its "strongly connected components" (SCCs) and their associated priorities.
  • Characterization of Game Automata Languages: The paper provides an effective way to identify which regular tree languages can be recognized by game automata.

The proofs rely heavily on inductive arguments, structural decompositions of automata (especially SCCs), and connections to topological hardness and Wadge hierarchies, which are standard tools in descriptive set theory for comparing the complexity of sets.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper deals with theoretical concepts and formal languages rather than empirical datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Game Automata as a Bridge: Game automata are introduced as a class that is expressive enough to capture complex index behaviors (unlike deterministic automata) but structured enough (no ambiguous transitions) to allow for index-preserving operations like substitution. This makes them a powerful tool for studying index problems beyond the deterministic case.
  • Decidability for Complex Automata: The paper demonstrates that the index problems, which are notoriously difficult for general alternating automata, become decidable for the more restricted but still expressive class of game automata.
  • Collapse of Hierarchy: For languages recognized by game automata, the alternating index hierarchy (Comp classes) collapses to match the standard Rabin-Mostowski index hierarchy (RM classes) at each level. This simplifies the understanding of their expressive power.
  • Topological Hardness as a Tool: The paper effectively uses concepts from descriptive set theory, like Wadge reducibility and game languages (Wi,j), to prove lower bounds on the index, showing that the computed bounds are tight.

Key Results

  • Decidability of Index Problems: The paper proves that the non-deterministic, alternating, and weak alternating index problems are decidable for languages recognized by game automata.
  • Characterization of Game Automata Languages: An effective characterization is provided to determine if a given regular tree language can be recognized by a game automaton.
  • Equivalence of Hierarchies: For game automata, the alternating index hierarchy (Comp classes) coincides with the Rabin-Mostowski index hierarchy (RM classes) at all levels.
  • Weak Index and Borel Rank Coincidence: For game automata, the weak index hierarchy coincides with the Borel hierarchy, and both are decidable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Maximality of Game Automata: While the paper argues that game automata are the "largest non-trivial subclass" closed under substitution that preserves index, the precise definition of "non-trivial" and the scope of this maximality could be further explored.
  • Complexity of Algorithms: The paper establishes decidability, but the exact computational complexity (e.g., time and space bounds) of the presented algorithms for computing indices is not detailed. This is a common area for future work in theoretical computer science.
  • Practical Applications: While automata theory has direct applications in verification, the specific practical implications of decidable index problems for game automata are not elaborated upon. Further research could explore how these results can be leveraged in real-world verification tools.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{kittler2016index,
  author = {Josef Kittler and Alessandro Facchini and Filip Murlak and Michal Skrzypczak},
  title = {{Index Problems for Game Automata}},
  journal = {ACM Trans. Comput. log},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1145/2946800},
}

Loading related content...

Figure