Increasing Number of Copies Can Help Entanglement Transformation

Runyao Duan, Yuan Feng, Mingsheng YingarXiv 2003 · arXiv

Abstract

We demonstrate that in many cases the entanglement-assisted local transformation (or catalyst-assisted entanglement transformation) can be implemented by multiple-copy-assisted transformation provided sufficient copies of original states are available. We present many interesting properties of multiple-copy-assisted entanglement transformations, which exactly coincide with those satisfied by catalyst-assisted ones. These facts, together with numerous numerical calculations we have done, lead us to a conjecture that catalyst-assisted transformation and multiple-copy-assisted transformation are equivalent in the sense that they can be replaced by each other. A brief negative answer to Nielsen's conjecture about the characterization of catalyst-assisted transformation is also presented.

Introduction

In the realm of quantum information theory, entanglement serves as a fundamental resource for various protocols. A critical problem is determining the conditions under which a bipartite entangled state $|\psi\rangle$ can be transformed into another state $|\phi\rangle$ using only Local Operations and Classical Communication (LOCC). Nielsen’s Theorem provides a definitive answer: such a transformation is possible if and only if the Schmidt coefficients of $|\psi\rangle$ are majorized by those of $|\phi\rangle$.

However, the discovery of "entanglement catalysis" by Jonathan and Plenio revealed that transformations impossible under direct LOCC can sometimes be achieved if an auxiliary entangled state—a catalyst—is used and subsequently returned unchanged. This paper explores an alternative: can the same transformations be achieved by processing multiple copies of the source state simultaneously?

Theoretical Framework: Majorization and Catalysis

The authors define three distinct sets of states reachable from a target state $y$:

  1. $S(y)$: States transformable to $y$ via direct LOCC.
  2. $T(y)$: States transformable to $y$ with the assistance of a catalyst.
  3. $M(y)$: States where $k$ copies of the source can transform into $k$ copies of $y$.

The research focuses on the relationship between $T(y)$ and $M(y)$, investigating whether the "borrowed" resource of a catalyst can be replaced by the "internal" resource of additional copies.

Renyi Entropy and Necessary Conditions

To analyze these transformations, the authors employ Renyi entropies, a family of generalized entanglement measures. They prove that for any successful transformation (whether catalyzed or multi-copy), the Renyi entropy of the source must exceed or equal that of the target across all orders $\alpha$.

The Renyi entropy formula $S^{(\alpha)}(x)$ used to establish necessary conditions for entanglement transformation.

This condition provides a powerful "guardrail" for ruling out impossible transformations. Specifically, they show that both $M(y)$ and $T(y)$ are subsets of $R(y)$, the set of states satisfying the Renyi entropy conditions.

The Multi-Copy Approach and the Equivalence Conjecture

The most significant contribution of this work is the conjecture that $M(y) = T(y)$. This suggests that the ability to catalyst-assist a transformation is mathematically equivalent to the ability to multi-copy-assist it. If one has access to a sufficient number of copies of the source state, the need for an external catalyst is eliminated.

Mathematical condition for the transformation of $k$ copies of a quantum state, where the sums of Schmidt coefficients of the tensor products are compared.

The authors provide analytical proofs showing that properties satisfied by catalyst-assisted transformations are mirrored in multi-copy transformations. For instance, they demonstrate that in the classic Jonathan-Plenio catalysis example, the transformation can be achieved using three copies of the initial state without any external catalyst.

Disproving Nielsen's Conjecture

The paper also addresses a conjecture by Michael Nielsen regarding the characterization of catalyst-assisted transformations. Nielsen suggested that $T(y)$ might be perfectly characterized by a simple set of continuous functions. The authors provide a negative answer, demonstrating that the set of reachable states is not necessarily closed, meaning it cannot be fully captured by such functions.

Conclusion

This research establishes a deep link between catalysis and multi-copy processing in entanglement theory. While the equivalence conjecture $M(y) = T(y)$ remains to be rigorously proven for all cases, the numerical and theoretical evidence presented is compelling. Future work will likely focus on closing the "entropy gap"—determining if Renyi entropy conditions are sufficient as well as necessary—and exploring the computational complexity of determining transformation feasibility.

Summary updated

Abstract

We demonstrate that in many cases the entanglement-assisted local transformation (or catalyst-assisted entanglement transformation)[D. Jonathan and M. B. Plenio, Phys. Rev. Lett. 83, 3566 (1999)] can be implemented by multiple-copy-assisted transformation provided sufficient copies of original states are available. We present many interesting properties of multiple-copy-assisted entanglement transformations, which exactly coincide with those satisfied by catalyst-assisted ones. These facts, together with numerous numerical calculations we have done, lead us to a conjecture that catalyst-assisted transformation and multiple-copy-assisted transformation are equivalent in the sense that they can be replaced by each other. A brief negative answer to Nielsen's conjecture about the characterization of catalyst-assisted transformation is also presented.
BibTeX
@misc{duan2003increasing,
  author = {Runyao Duan and Yuan Feng and Mingsheng Ying},
  title = {{Increasing Number of Copies Can Help Entanglement Transformation}},
  year = {2003},
  eprint = {quant-ph/0312010},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0312010},
}
Figure