Increased neural correlations in primate auditory cortex during slow-wave sleep

Elias B. Issa, Xiaoqin WangJournal of Neurophysiology 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that during slow-wave sleep (SWS), neural correlations in the primate auditory cortex increase specifically when processing external sounds, contrary to expectations. This suggests that SWS modifies functional connections for sensory processing, rather than solely relying on global brain rhythms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how the brain's communication networks change during different behavioral states, particularly sleep, is crucial for deciphering brain function. While we know that neuronal firing rates change during sleep, how the interactions between neurons (their correlations) evolve is less understood. Previous research often focused on spontaneous neural activity, which only captures a fraction of network interactions. This paper aims to investigate neural correlations during active sensory processing in sleep, specifically during slow-wave sleep (SWS), to see how the auditory cortex's functional connectivity is altered when it's still processing external stimuli.

Methods

The researchers recorded from multiple neurons simultaneously in the auditory cortex of common marmosets during natural sleep (wakefulness, SWS, and REM). They used acoustic stimuli to probe the auditory cortex's response and measure neural correlations in two ways:

  • Neuron-Neuron Correlations: They measured the trial-by-trial correlation of firing rates between pairs of simultaneously recorded neurons. This reflects "noise correlations" – the spontaneous covariation in neural activity.
  • Neuron-Local Field Potential (LFP) Correlations: They also examined correlations between individual neuron firing rates and the power of LFP signals in different frequency bands. LFPs are thought to reflect the collective activity of local neuronal populations.

Crucially, they compared these correlations across different sleep states (wakefulness, SWS, REM) and also between spontaneous activity and activity evoked by acoustic stimulation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study used data collected from 5 hemispheres of 4 common marmosets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sensory Processing Enhances SWS Correlations: The most striking finding is that neural correlations in the auditory cortex are higher during SWS when the brain is processing acoustic stimuli compared to wakefulness or REM sleep. This effect was not seen during spontaneous activity.
  • Local vs. Global Connectivity: While local neuron-neuron correlations increased significantly during evoked activity in SWS, global neuron-LFP correlations showed a less pronounced increase. This suggests that SWS might preferentially affect local functional connectivity during sensory processing.
  • Slow Oscillations Aren't the Whole Story: The study challenges the idea that the well-known slow oscillations of SWS are the sole drivers of increased neural synchrony. The observed increase in correlations during evoked activity, which is often suppressed by sensory stimulation, suggests other mechanisms are at play.
  • Pattern of Connectivity Changes: The specific pairs of neurons that were correlated changed between wakefulness and SWS, indicating a dynamic reorganization of functional connections rather than just a uniform increase in correlation across all pairs.
  • Spontaneous vs. Driven Activity: Interestingly, spontaneous activity correlations were higher than driven activity correlations in wakefulness, a finding consistent with previous work. However, during SWS, this pattern reversed for evoked activity.

Key Results

  • Neuron-Neuron Correlations: Median correlation increased from 0.08 (awake) to 0.20 (SWS) and 0.10 (REM) during acoustic stimulation (P < 0.002 for awake vs. SWS). This increase was significant even in well-isolated unit pairs.
  • Firing Rates: Driven firing rates remained largely similar across all states (median awake: 3.21 spikes/s, SWS: 2.85 spikes/s, REM: 3.04 spikes/s), indicating that the correlation changes were not simply a byproduct of altered overall activity levels.
  • Neuron-LFP Correlations: Correlations with high-frequency LFP power (gamma band) showed a modest increase in SWS (median awake: 0.12, SWS: 0.13), but this did not reach statistical significance compared to wakefulness.
  • Pattern Similarity: The pattern of correlations (which pairs were correlated) was dissimilar between awake and SWS states, but REM showed some similarity to awake states.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Auditory Cortex Specificity: The findings are specific to the auditory cortex. It remains an open question whether similar changes in neural correlations during SWS would be observed in other sensory areas.
  • Mechanisms of Correlation: The study highlights that slow oscillations are not the sole explanation for increased correlations during SWS. The precise underlying circuit mechanisms (e.g., changes in excitatory/inhibitory inputs, divisive normalization) that lead to these altered correlations are still unclear and require further investigation.
  • Global vs. Local: The differential changes in local (unit-unit) versus global (unit-LFP) correlations suggest that SWS might have state-dependent effects on connectivity at different spatial scales. Future work could explore these scale-dependent changes more deeply.
  • Internal Processing: The authors suggest that while increased correlations might hinder external sensory processing during SWS, they could reflect a state conducive to processing internal information or consolidating memories. This interpretation warrants further exploration.

Summary updated

Abstract

During sleep, changes in brain rhythms and neuromodulator levels in cortex modify the properties of individual neurons and the network as a whole. In principle, network-level interactions during sleep can be studied by observing covariation in spontaneous activity between neurons. Spontaneous activity, however, reflects only a portion of the effective functional connectivity that is activated by external and internal inputs (e.g., sensory stimulation, motor behavior, and mental activity), and it has been shown that neural responses are less correlated during external sensory stimulation than during spontaneous activity. Here, we took advantage of the unique property that the auditory cortex continues to respond to sounds during sleep and used external acoustic stimuli to activate cortical networks for studying neural interactions during sleep. We found that during slow-wave sleep (SWS), local (neuron-neuron) correlations are not reduced by acoustic stimulation remaining higher than in wakefulness and rapid eye movement sleep and remaining similar to spontaneous activity correlations. This high level of correlations during SWS complements previous work finding elevated global (local field potential-local field potential) correlations during sleep. Contrary to the prediction that slow oscillations in SWS would increase neural correlations during spontaneous activity, we found little change in neural correlations outside of periods of acoustic stimulation. Rather, these findings suggest that functional connections recruited in sound processing are modified during SWS and that slow rhythms, which in general are suppressed by sensory stimulation, are not the sole mechanism leading to elevated network correlations during sleep.
BibTeX
@article{issa2013increased,
  author = {Elias B. Issa and Xiaoqin Wang},
  title = {{Increased neural correlations in primate auditory cortex during slow-wave sleep}},
  journal = {Journal of Neurophysiology},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1152/jn.00695.2012},
}
Figure